List Mgmt. 2024 List Management discussion

[Loyal Lion]

Dev Robertson for Dan McStay..... or Darcy Cameron.

Isn't Dan McStay one very unlucky fella! He goes to Collingwood in their premiership year & doesn't play due to injury. And his former club wins the flag the year after! Shades of Nathan Buckley's near flag adventures!

 

[Darren Downunder]

Oh dev anyone but Collingwood pls.

Dev could have a really good career at Collingwood … but…
He’s a great kid and deserves a good run at it …. but …. but ….
Collingwood!
Sweet suffering Jesus, No! Please No.

 

[Miluxx]

Dev could have a really good career at Collingwood … but…
He’s a great kid and deserves a good run at it …. but …. but ….
Collingwood!
Sweet suffering Jesus, No! Please No.

I think he is a starter in at least 10 teams. Just don't make it Collingwood haha. Although learning under McCrae wouldn't be horrible.

 

[Nunez]

Karma

W0t

 

[Tom14]

Lol at the surprise from Edmund that he could get a game at Collingwood but not Brisbane.

It’s true though! I don’t think he’s a starter for them if all are fit but pendles and Sidebottom are super old, Mitchell missed most of the year, and their draft picks are unseen or unimpressive.

They are pretending that Perryman will play midfield at the moment.

 

[Clarkythelion]

Brown had Lynch and Bradshaw with him. I would be saying the exact same thing even if we had a second year Brown instead of Morris. Not ready to be the #1 guy.

I'd argue Browny didn't start as the number 1 guy either and your right he had time with senior players around him like Morris had Joe, but still has Hippy, Charlie, McArthy, Rayner and this year a bit more Big O there plus now Lowman building on the same trajectory. I'm always the glass half full person, all kids are great until they prove us wrong, Morris is going great and has a bit more mongrel in him which will grow with his size.

 

[Dalions]

Karma

We low balled McStay so you honestly can’t blame him for leaving.

 

[Dalions]

It’s true though! I don’t think he’s a starter for them if all are fit but pendles and Sidebottom are super old, Mitchell missed most of the year, and their draft picks are unseen or unimpressive.

They are pretending that Perryman will play midfield at the moment.

I think the bolded is who Dev would replace from their Premiership team, perfectly.

 

[mpal6]

If this goes through as suggested by Twomey, will be interesting to see what we get for Sharp... Dees seem to be trading away most of their 2024 currency.



Edit:

Pick 49 left for Sharp - 287 points

Melbourne are trading this year like what GWS used to do normally.
Just throwing picks away to climb as high as possible on the ladder.

 

[Nunez]

We low balled McStay so you honestly can’t blame him for leaving.

We offered him a fair contract. Pies offered him overs. It happens.

 

[blueiris]

We low balled McStay so you honestly can’t blame him for leaving.

We actually offered him more than what Collingwood was but okay

 

[blueiris]

We offered him a fair contract. Pies offered him overs. It happens.

No we were offering him more he wanted out

 

[SizeMatters]

We actually offered him more than what Collingwood was but okay

Yeah. Dan left the club to win a premiership. I mean it pretty much worked out the way he thought it was just a shame he couldn’t play the GF. It’s well known he thought this team peaked in his last year here. Plus pies sorted out his partner with a sweet legal gig…

I think it worked out well his old teammates won a premiership and he didn’t.

 

[JasRulz63]

If this goes through as suggested by Twomey, will be interesting to see what we get for Sharp... Dees seem to be trading away most of their 2024 currency.



Edit:

Pick 49 left for Sharp - 287 points

If Essendon lose (or draw) one more game this year, they end up with pick 5 (in a supposedly strong draft) instead of Melbourne's future first, and still get Kako anyway.

 

[SizeMatters]

Listening Sarah Oly and some other bloke talk about Brisbane's options to replace Joe is just painful listening and they're paid to talking footy and they are just clueless. Its surprising given only hardcore fans would listen/watch this yet their knowledge is targeted to people who have NFI and just buy this crap. Its pretty embarrassing tbh.

I think they are just trying to throw names out there. I mean what they said is probably the most obvious options we have. But reef McInnes? Interesting….

 

[dlanod]

Karma

No, that's Josh Dunkley's goal song.

 

[braddsey]

It’s true though! I don’t think he’s a starter for them if all are fit but pendles and Sidebottom are super old, Mitchell missed most of the year, and their draft picks are unseen or unimpressive.

They are pretending that Perryman will play midfield at the moment.

Which is probably why it's a good move for Dev and Collingwood. I don't know what Collingwood have coming through, but given they're relying on Pendles, Sidebottom, Mitchell, you would imagine not much. Even if they're looking to draft an mid, they're drafting a skinny teenager. Even if Dev waits in the Collingwood reserves for much of 2025, he'll be in a man's body for the transition from one / multiple of P/S/M retiring end of next season.
In contrast, if Dev stays on our list he's never likely to make it considering our good fortune with Will & Levi, plus we have years' to go with Hugh, Bez, Bailey, Rayner, not to mention a few more to go for Lachie!

 

[blueiris]

Listening Sarah Oly and some other bloke talk about Brisbane's options to replace Joe is just painful listening and they're paid to talking footy and they are just clueless. Its surprising given only hardcore fans would listen/watch this yet their knowledge is targeted to people who have NFI and just buy this crap. Its pretty embarrassing tbh.

I didn't dislike the Reef McGinnis option from Josh

 

[dlanod]

They are pretending that Perryman will play midfield at the moment.

Perryman had a good run in the midfield for GWS some time ago. The main issue is that he doesn't have a real weapon once he won the ball. I also don't think he had a $900,000 run.

 

[Nathan Barley]

We offered him a fair contract. Pies offered him overs. It happens.

Offered his wife overs

 

[blueiris]

I think they are just trying to throw names out there. I mean what they said is probably the most obvious options we have. But reef McInnes? Interesting….

Ricardi or McInnes both look like decent options

 

[braddsey]

Listening Sarah Oly and some other bloke talk about Brisbane's options to replace Joe is just painful listening and they're paid to talking footy and they are just clueless. Its surprising given only hardcore fans would listen/watch this yet their knowledge is targeted to people who have NFI and just buy this crap. Its pretty embarrassing tbh.

They can just fill the airwaves with any crap because people are desperate for anything footy news. October is an awful period of radio listening... post GF but still waiting for cricket season to kick off!
...I've switched over to ABC.

 

[Nathan Barley]

Ricardi or McInnes both look like decent options

McInness has only kicked 19 goals in his whole career and you think he can kick 100 goals next season?

Should stick with what we have and play Darcy Craven at full forward

 

[SizeMatters]

I didn't dislike the Reef McGinnis option from Josh

I like him as a potential footballer but not as a KPF.

 

[Tom14]

Perryman had a good run in the midfield for GWS some time ago. The main issue is that he doesn't have a real weapon once he won the ball. I also don't think he had a $900,000 run.

This is an unfair comparison for Perryman but it reminds me of this: