Position 2024 Midfielders

[rocker_oz33]

Do we think piggy will get back to his best?
One of the best mids when up and about.
Is it more than just preseason and nose beers.?

 

[5ammy]

What are people doing with Oliver?

HOLD and hope he improves?

Or TRADE him out?

Really depends on each individuals situation.

I've got 8 trades left and too many yoyo plodders in my team as it is so I'm punting him.

Prior to last week, his form was OK for an M8/M9 but that performance against North was unforgiveable.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Definite HOLD.

Why though?

Oliver looks spent and will keep getting tagged with no Petracca there anynore.

 

[fuic08]

The piggy train has derailed. The next best time to jump off is now though.

 

[Faz 2000]

The piggy train has derailed. The next best time to jump off is now though.
View attachment 2031521

 

[Test Tickle]

Why though?

Oliver looks spent and will keep getting tagged with no Petracca there anynore.

I’ve only got 6 trades left and he is too good a player to stay down forever, Im fighting the fight with him.

 

[The Golden Glenferrie]

Do we think piggy will get back to his best?
One of the best mids when up and about.
Is it more than just preseason and nose beers.?

If I trade him, he will come good. If I hold him, he will continue to be shit.

Schrodinger's Trades

 

[rocker_oz33]

If I trade him, he will come good. If I hold him, he will continue to be shit.

Schrodinger's Trades

Pros and cons of SC.

Head or gut.

 

[The Golden Glenferrie]

Pros and cons of SC.

Head or gut.

Head says trade. Gut says hold.

 

[Plugger35]

Bailed on Piggy Oliver a fortnight ago to Woah Errol. At the time it cost $62k, today would cost $165k.

It’s good for your mental health to not be relying on Piggy this year.

I did the same thing, I'm still stuck with Touk though and I don't have enough trades left to upgrade him to a proper premo mid.

 

[Scythe]

Do we think piggy will get back to his best?
One of the best mids when up and about.
Is it more than just preseason and nose beers.?

Certainly not this year. So, so far off the pace at the moment.

He should improve next year, but I have doubts about him reaching the level of years past.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Certainly not this year. So, so far off the pace at the moment.

He should improve next year, but I have doubts about him reaching the level of years past.

Piggy and tracc both cheap next year.
You prob not want both.

 

[VainGlorious]

What are people doing with Oliver?

HOLD and hope he improves?

Or TRADE him out?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

View attachment 2031622

View attachment 2031624

So you held him for his bye, THEN traded him out?

 

[VainGlorious]

So you held him for his bye, THEN traded him out?

Got me Zerrett, I avoided his 35, plus moved up into the top 1k last week

 

[VainGlorious]

Got me Zerrett, I avoided his 35, plus moved up into the top 1k last week

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Got me Zerrett, I avoided his 35, plus moved up into the top 1k last week

Could of been top 500 if you traded him on his bye

Nice rank kentie

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Got me Zerrett, I avoided his 35, plus moved up into the top 1k last week

A friend of mine VainGlorious said to say Wrong thread D*ckhead post in the trades

 

[VainGlorious]

A friend of mine VainGlorious said to say Wrong thread D*ckhead post in the trades

View attachment 2031821

Yeah ya dickhead VainGlorious

Wait a sec…

 

[stevebbb]

Can't tell if picking up JHF was a success or not. $434k for a 97 average.

Trading him out at his bye when he was $546k was the play, but I couldn't trade out a bloke with a 4-rd-avg of 111, when I had other issues to fix.

Let's see what he does against the Saints at Marvel this weekend, but I think I'll be luxury upgrading him.

Only 51% CBAs last round. I wonder if he's a chance at FWD DPP in a few weeks.

Anybody planning on holding him at M8?

I have Jackson at F7. I think I can loop Jackson and JHF by moving Flanders/Heeney/Zorko between MID/FWD. I wonder if that's the play...

 

[VainGlorious]

I have Jackson at F7. I think I can loop Jackson and JHF by moving Flanders/Heeney/Zorko between MID/FWD. I wonder if that's the play...

There you go

In answer to whether or not a 97 average is ok for $434k, it absolutely is ok. 6 tons, 2 90’s and 3 80’s is perfectly reasonable imo.

JHF + $60-$70k gets you a Serong/Butters type though, which from memory you are yet to obtain?

Breakeven of 140 this week.

 

[stevebbb]

There you go

In answer to whether or not a 97 average is ok for $434k, it absolutely is ok. 6 tons, 2 90’s and 3 80’s is perfectly reasonable imo.

JHF + $60-$70k gets you a Serong/Butters type though, which from memory you are yet to obtain?

Breakeven of 140 this week.

Got Serong.

5 trades left, only $6k itb. Might 1 down/1 up and turn him into the best of the best.

High BE isn't ideal, but we'll reassess next week.

 

[VainGlorious]

Got Serong.
.

No need to brag mate, I’m already jealous enough of Serong/Butters owners.

5 trades left, only $6k itb. Might 1 down/1 up and turn him into the best of the best.

High BE isn't ideal, but we'll reassess next week.

Sounds like a good plan.

He may come out and surprise you with a 120.

 

[Lindsay_Gilbee]

Sanders saying Treloar has been the standout in training. In 0% of teams. If you wanna try get a jump on other teams he could be one to look at, especially with no bye early on.

Sucks when you don’t go with your gut cos you’re worried you’re being bias..