List Mgmt. 2024 National Draft - November 20-21

[Jen2310]

 

[Carlthetruth]

X - factor anyone

I wouldn't get to exited by Bailey McKenzie, not big enough for a KP and not nimble enough for a third tall or flank. He's also incredibly slow so I doubt clubs will bother.

 

[Obese Arachnid]

You can probably guess - you know, the ones who think they know everything and also think that anyone who disagrees with them is an idiot.

Still going to need more information.

 

[Fat Jesus]

Charlie Nicholls name alone screams superstar. Ask sr36

 

[sr36]

Charlie Nicholls name alone screams superstar. Ask sr36

Yep. My name based recruiting criteria has him number 1. It's a footballer's name. But I just read that he's friends with Camporeals twerps, so we may have to pass.

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Only 191cm though, so would just be a third tall at the next level.

I don't think it's reasonable to talk so definitively about the height limitations of an 18 year old - Maybe he's 191.5cm now, and he grows an inch, and then all of a sudden is 194cm.

Height limitation is erased at that point, but you've passed on him because he's too short. Charlie Curnow was 191cm when he was drafted and is 195cm now.

This kid has something about him, but I doubt he makes it to our selections.

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Yep. My name based recruiting criteria has him number 1. It's a footballer's name. But I just read that he's friends with Camporeals twerps, so we may have to pass.

What about his SA comrade Charlie West?

 

[manicpie]

I don't think it's reasonable to talk so definitively about the height limitations of an 18 year old - Maybe he's 191.5cm now, and he grows an inch, and then all of a sudden is 194cm.

Height limitation is erased at that point, but you've passed on him because he's too short. Charlie Curnow was 191cm when he was drafted and is 195cm now.

This kid has something about him, but I doubt he makes it to our selections.

you like ,Vinnie?

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

you like ,Vinnie?

Seems like a talent. That clip in the video of him sticking one hand out and reeling in the mark is just not something your average dud footballer does all that often. Particularly not in the course of kicking a casual 6.

 

[The Phantom]

Bailey kicked 6 in the GF, would need a bit of development but has some tricks

That’s the sort of performance Hine rates.

 

[satanshoof101]

I wouldn't get to exited by Bailey McKenzie, not big enough for a KP and not nimble enough for a third tall or flank. He's also incredibly slow so I doubt clubs will bother.

I am pretty excited, hope he comes to us, the later he does the better. He is a great mark, which I think is rarer than people realise and I am sure he could apply that to the back line as well if needed.

 

[JuniorB]

Charlie Nicholls name alone screams superstar. Ask sr36

That first video was a mixed bag - a smothered kick, a dropped sitter and a couple of missed shots on goal, along with some good marks.

 

[sr36]

What about his SA comrade Charlie West?

Maybe. Although he'd sound more like a footballer if his parents called him Scotty.

 

[JuniorB]

That’s the sort of performance Hine rates.

Yeah, he drafted a kid who kicked 10 in a GF.

 

[loki04]

Strangely enough many of the Coleman contenders most years haven’t got premiership medallions to their name

In contention for Coleman (or on track) and flagged without going too far back:

2024 J.Daniher Flag 51.54 (wildly inaccurate kicking)
2022 J.Cameron Flag 65.37.
2019 T.Lynch Flag 63.31.
2018 J.Kennedy Flag 43.20 from 14 games (injuries).
2017 Flag J.Reiwoldt 54.37.

Its a bit of a strange myth being purported these days. Almost ignoring the impact to suite a narrative style posts.

 

[manicpie]

In contention for Coleman (or on track) and flagged without going too far back:

2024 J.Daniher Flag 51.54 (wildly inaccurate kicking)
2022 J.Cameron Flag 65.37.
2019 T.Lynch Flag 63.31.
2018 J.Kennedy Flag 43.20 from 14 games (injuries).
2017 Flag J.Reiwoldt 54.37.

Its a bit of a strange myth being purported these days. Almost ignoring the impact to suite a narrative style posts.

You can add tim Membrey next year

 

[Harry O]

I wouldn't get to exited by Bailey McKenzie, not big enough for a KP and not nimble enough for a third tall or flank. He's also incredibly slow so I doubt clubs will bother.

Carl - a draft strategy you would use given our current selections ?
You seem certain of who is no good. Would you go best available in the 40-55 range or target talls regardless

 

[celestial]

Didn't Scharenberg have navicular issues during his draft year ? If so , think we probably will steer clear of Noah Mraz.

 

[manicpie]

Didn't Scharenberg have navicular issues during his draft year ? If so , think we probably will steer clear of Noah Mraz.

good player Mraz but terrible kicking apparently

 

[sr36]

good player Mraz but terrible kicking apparently

If they read this board they'll never again pass on a key back with terrible kicking. That was Aaron Naughton.

 

[JOELY]

Cal Twomey's Phantom Form Guide October extra: The 10 next best

AFL.com.au's draft guru Cal Twomey looks at the players who were unlucky to miss being in October's Phantom Form Guide

www.afl.com.au

I would be quite interested in Kayle Gerreyn. My type of forward.

 

[sr36]

I would be quite interested in Kayle Gerreyn. My type of forward.

Reads well.

Realistically, if we we're going kpf at our pick range, we've got the prototypes in the team - the kind who slip down the draft order.

McStay - a big bloke who contests and can clunk a mark, but isn't athletically impressive.

Checkers - undersized but competes in the air and has a ground level game to go with it.

I really don't want the guy who blitzed them in the combine sprints.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

In contention for Coleman (or on track) and flagged without going too far back:

2024 J.Daniher Flag 51.54 (wildly inaccurate kicking)
2022 J.Cameron Flag 65.37.
2019 T.Lynch Flag 63.31.
2018 J.Kennedy Flag 43.20 from 14 games (injuries).
2017 Flag J.Reiwoldt 54.37.

It’s a bit of a strange myth being purported these days. Almost ignoring the impact to suite a narrative style posts.

I should change my post from “ often” to “as often as not”.

just depends on what time series you look back over.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Reads well.

Realistically, if we we're going kpf at our pick range, we've got the prototypes in the team - the kind who slip down the draft order.

McStay - a big bloke who contests and can clunk a mark, but isn't athletically impressive.

Checkers - undersized but competes in the air and has a ground level game to go with it.

I really don't want the guy who blitzed them in the combine sprints.

Checkers ground level game is close to best in the business for a key forward. The number of goals he kicks from less than ten metres using brawn brains ( EDIT, add the word pace) and an immovable centre of gravity is an underrated feature of his game. Anybody who can replicate the strength that checkers has in his thighs and glutes with skill to match is worth looking at

 

[Apex36]

Didn't Scharenberg have navicular issues during his draft year ? If so , think we probably will steer clear of Noah Mraz.

Yes. They were fixed in his first year with us and he never had issues again, much the same as when Josh Thomas had the same surgery.

I seriously doubt that Scharenbergs completely separate knee issues will put them off drafting anyone with navicular issues.

 

[Matt_352]

I do agree Charlie Nicholls sounds like a future afl star just going off the name lol. Happy with any of Nicholls, Sims, Stumph, Gerreyn with one of our picks. Don't see how Sims lasts. Like the look of Kennedy as hopefully a late gem mid. Dennis is the draftee I am most invested in. Very impressed with what I have seen.