Opinion 2024 Player X vs Y vs Z

[rf04]

Daicos & Ginbey or Steele & Guthrie (plus $40k)?

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Zilliams & Flanders vs Sheezle & Lazzaro

 

[shockmaster]

Zilliams & Flanders vs Sheezle & Lazzaro

Zilliams & Flanders

 

[Flandersss]

Zilliams & Flanders vs Sheezle & Lazzaro

Zilliams & Flanders

 

[Flandersss]

Stewart v Sheezel
LDU v Petracca
Macrae v Dusty

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Stewart v Sheezel
LDU v Petracca
Macrae v Dusty

 

[buttox]

Stewart v Sheezel
LDU v Petracca
Macrae v Dusty

Sheezel more room for improvement. Stewart will slow down at some stage.
Ldu depending on how many r0 premos you have. Either works. Petracca if you are ok with the extra bye.
Macrae easily dusty fell of the cliff years ago and starts seasons slow.

 

[buttox]

Daicos & Ginbey or Steele & Guthrie (plus $40k)?

Daicos and Steele the only viable sc picks there.
Daicos is better

 

[rf04]

Daicos and Steele the only viable sc picks there.
Daicos is better

Yeap, hear that. Will look to keep Steele and maybe swap Guthrie and Fyfe for Daicos and a rookie. Was aiming to trade Daicos in after round 5 bye, but seems popular thinking by many to pick him from the start. Him and Gawn would be the only non rookie Round 0 starters, so no huge risk there. Still feel Guthrie might be a good earner and stepping stone, but with risk attached.

 

[adammania9]

Daicos & Ginbey or Steele & Guthrie (plus $40k)?

Daicos and Wardlaw

 

[Lord De Goey]

Brayshaw v Parish

Leaning towards Parish with all the hype he’s been getting out of training. Brayshaw could drop off with Young and Fyfe getting more mid time but it kind of went under the radar that Brayshaw averaged 116 from round 10 onwards

 

[shockmaster]

Brayshaw v Parish

Leaning towards Parish with all the hype he’s been getting out of training. Brayshaw could drop off with Young and Fyfe getting more mid time but it kind of went under the radar that Brayshaw averaged 116 from round 10 onwards

I'm thinking about this one at the moment myself. Brayshaw feels like the more sensible choice with the better bye and likely better durability, but I'm more bullish on Parish this year from a scoring perspective

 

[adammania9]

Bont+Wardlaw vs Serong+N Martin

 

[kool kangas]

Coleman(Bris) vs Wardlaw....l will need to juggle my backs around for this to happen...

 

[MacStradbroke]

Coleman(Bris) vs Wardlaw....l will need to juggle my backs around for this to happen...

Coleman, it’s not completely unreasonable for him to stay in your team for the whole season.

 

[Northernsoul74]

Coleman, it’s not completely unreasonable for him to stay in your team for the whole season.

At nearly $400k Coleman would want to be a keeper.

 

[MacStradbroke]

At nearly $400k Coleman would want to be a keeper.

Extra trades, I think there’s a bit more wiggle room this year. If I could be guaranteed 8-10 weeks of good scores before regressing I’d take it in a heartbeat, the trick is when to jump ship.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Bont+Wardlaw vs Serong+N Martin

Serong and Martin

Warlord has exploding hammy's and a stinky price.

 

[Makeshift Park]

Weird question, but...

Fyfe vs Zilliams?

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Weird question, but...

Fyfe vs Zilliams?

 

[Makeshift Park]

View attachment 1906722

But if you could only have one… who and why?

 

[A Bit Dusty]

But if you could only have one… who and why?

Fyfe because he can still pump out tons has DPP and not many forward options.
There seems to be some decent defender rookies and Zilliams although cheap has red flags to start with but I will start him.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Fyfe because he can still pump out tons has DPP and not many forward options.
There seems to be some decent defender rookies and Zilliams although cheap has red flags to start with but I will start him.

Both fyfe and zillions are proven SC hos and both put out ...

 

[Makeshift Park]

Both fyfe and zillions are proven SC hos and both put out ...

When they are not impotent…

Which has been all but maybe a dozen weeks a year for the past five.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Ridley + Steele

VS

Sheezel + NMartin