Opinion 2024 Player X vs Y vs Z

[weltschmerz]

Jordon, or Roberts and pocket the extra cash?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Jordon, or Roberts and pocket the extra cash?

Roberts easy.

 

[weltschmerz]

Roberts easy.

Figured so too, it balances my side a bit better. Just a bit of fomo when you can't have every player who catches the eye.

 

[hugemcluggage]

McKercher vs Budarick?
(Draft league)

 

[cbrendan]

Stewart & Serong vs Ryan or Houston & Dawson

 

[Jiska]

Gibcus vs Zilliams

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Gibcus vs Zilliams

Zilliams in a canter .....will get better with each match ....80 ave IMO

Gibcus ....9 disposals today ....huge SC / DT disparity ...he's a 50-60 ave player

 

[JuddgementDay]

Daicos (RD0) vs Stewart

 

[Significant]

McKercher vs Budarick?
(Draft league)

McKercher

Stewart & Serong vs Ryan or Houston & Dawson

Houston and Dawson

Gibcus vs Zilliams

Both - if Gibcus can do that off 9 disposals, God help us when he actually starts finding more ball!

Daicos (RD0) vs Stewart

Baby Daics. Erry day.

 

[Jiska]

Both - if Gibcus can do that off 9 disposals, God help us when he actually starts finding more ball!

8 contested would seem unusual for role. Only getting 9 disposals considering how often the ball was down there is of concern. Suppose it’s worth the 27k upgrade from Dean tho.

 

[marcmurphy3]

Green and Steele vs Butters & Miller

 

[Significant]

Green and Steele vs Butters & Miller

Flip a coin?

 

[Dundalis]

Green and Steele vs Butters & Miller

If Miller stays fit in that role, he's outscoring Steele comfortably IMO.

 

[kyri]

Harley Reid vs Zac Williams?

 

[MacStradbroke]

Harley Reid vs Zac Williams?

Williams

 

[Ken Tea]

Wines (m6) Lazzaro vs Rankin (m3) Jye Clark (on field m8)

 

[Veer Right]

Reid vs Phillips vs Pink vs Coffield vs Howes

Which two of the above to start on field and why?

 

[VainGlorious]

Wines (m6) Lazzaro vs Rankin (m3) Jye Clark (on field m8)

I don’t mind the Wines pick if he’s playing pure inside mid. He should be good for 100 most weeks and doesn’t have a bye until round 13, which Port share with Freo.

Also like all 3 of Lazz, Clark and Rankine.

Rankine in particular, as he’s only in 5% of teams. Wines in 9%

Flip a coin mate.

 

[VainGlorious]

Reid vs Phillips vs Pink vs Coffield vs Howes

Which two of the above to start on field and why?

Howes definitely, not too sure on the rest of them.

 

[VainGlorious]

Wines, Rankine and rookie under $150k

V

N.Martin, Fisher, rookie forward under $200k

M5, M6, F3

Cheers kents

 

[Ken Tea]

Wines, Rankine and rookie under $150k

V

N.Martin, Fisher, rookie forward under $200k

M5, M6, F3

Cheers kents

I like the Martin pick, if gets off the chain i might grab him.

If Fisher kicks off like the other previous Roo chip scabs he's a lock, could always downgrade to him from Rankin I guess.
1st one.

 

[The Golden Glenferrie]

Sam Berry vs Colby McKercher

I am leaning towards the history of Berry (trending upwards and beyond) vs young Colbs.

 

[keithrichards]

Steele vs Touk

 

[Ken Tea]

Steele vs Touk

Touk, but all depends on your bye structure.

 

[cbrendan]

Steele vs Touk

If not for the early byes it would be Touk by a mile. Even with the byes I'd still take Touk over Steele.

(I have both)