Opinion 2024 Player X vs Y vs Z

[JuddgementDay]

Serong vs Dawson + 70k

Dawson for me, $70K gives you more flexibility

Dawson this week or never

Serong will be around this price

 

[Jiska]

Bye dependent .....Dawson is back, and is great value ....but Serong has that R13 bye

Both Bye weeks are fine for my structure.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Both Bye weeks are fine for my structure.

Then fixture dependent .....is it fair to suggest FREO have the better short term run ? ......ADEL's fixture still tough the next few weeks

FWIW .... I have both Serong and Dawson

 

[keithrichards]

Serong & Rarcia
vs
Dawson & Rodgers + $40k

 

[Borgan]

Rowell vs Merrett vs Dawson

 

[JuddgementDay]

Serong & Rarcia
vs
Dawson & Rodgers + $40k

Dawson & Rodgers + $40k

Dawson is better value & Rodgers less sub chance

 

[keithrichards]

Dawson & Rodgers + $40k

Dawson is better value & Rodgers less sub chance

My thinking too

 

[SavDog23]

Walsh vs Dawson

Dawson suits my byes better, has a nice run coming up that could have some big scores in it, is he gonna be a top 10 mid tho? Also gives me a player in tonights game.

Walsh should feast against a weaker pies midfield this week, but would mean I'd have 8 or 9 premos out at that RD14 bye, he has a great post bye fixture so would bring him in then. Will Cerra back also take away some scoring?

 

[Judd_Magic]

Walsh vs Dawson

Dawson suits my byes better, has a nice run coming up that could have some big scores in it, is he gonna be a top 10 mid tho? Also gives me a player in tonights game.

Walsh should feast against a weaker pies midfield this week, but would mean I'd have 8 or 9 premos out at that RD14 bye, he has a great post bye fixture so would bring him in then. Will Cerra back also take away some scoring?

Walsh easily imo.

Will be a top 8 mid, Dawson won't be.

Doubt Cerra will affect Walsh. It's not Crouch and Dawson we are talking about here.

 

[Veer Right]

Deciding who to bring in between

Serong V Richmond

or

NMartin V WC

I will be bringing both in but for this week whos the safer bet to score better?

Pickett tag Serong?

Any solid advice gimps?

 

[JuddgementDay]

Deciding who to bring in between

Serong V Richmond

or

NMartin V WC

I will be bringing both in but for this week whos the safer bet to score better?

Pickett tag Serong?

Any solid advice gimps?

Serong will give you a C option. NMartin won't/ shouldn't

 

[Judd_Magic]

Deciding who to bring in between

Serong V Richmond

or

NMartin V WC

I will be bringing both in but for this week whos the safer bet to score better?

Pickett tag Serong?

Any solid advice gimps?

Serong mate.

I reckon he goes 140 + against Richmond this week.

 

[No eye deer]

Steele to Dawson this week and Merrett next week or..
Steele to Merrett this week and Trac next week?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Deciding who to bring in between

Serong V Richmond

or

NMartin V WC

I will be bringing both in but for this week whos the safer bet to score better?

Pickett tag Serong?

Any solid advice gimps?

I'm worried Martin will be thrown fwd again, like last week .....that's my only concern with him

 

[Judd_Magic]

Steele to Dawson this week and Merrett next week or..
Steele to Merrett this week and Trac next week?

Tough one.

I'm going Steele > Rowell this week and Dempsey > Merrett next week.

Depends who you like more out of Dawson and Petracca. I reckon Trac has more chance of being a top 8 mid than Dawson but that's just me.

 

[No eye deer]

Tough one.

I'm going Steele > Rowell this week and Dempsey > Merrett next week.

Depends who you like more out of Dawson and Petracca. I reckon Trac has more chance of being a top 8 mid than Dawson but that's just me.

Yeah, leaning towards Trac myself.
I like Rowell too, but Merrett has just been so damn dependable for my team over the last few seasons.
Bombers have a nice run coming up as well.

 

[VainGlorious]

Hai kents!

Would love some input please.

Keep Grundy @ R2 + $449k for upgrades next week

OR

Keep Meek @ R2 + $550k for upgrades next week.



Meek could potentially become English in round 9 as well.

Thanks in advance,

Veiny xo

 

[SavDog23]

Hai kents!

Would love some input please.

Keep Grundy @ R2 + $449k for upgrades next week

OR

Keep Meek @ R2 + $550k for upgrades next week.



Meek could potentially become English in round 9 as well.

Thanks in advance,

Veiny xo

What upgrades would you be looking at over the next 1-2 weeks for each scenario?

Without knowing the upgrades, I'd say keep Grundy as he should score big, while Meek is up against English and will probably struggle.

 

[VainGlorious]

What upgrades would you be looking at over the next 1-2 weeks for each scenario?

Without knowing the upgrades, I'd say keep Grundy as he should score big, while Meek is up against English and will probably struggle.

Keep Grundy.

Upgrade Roberts to Serong/Butters
Zilliams to Stewart

Keep Meek.

Roberts to Tracc
Zilliams to stewart
Meek to English in a couple.

I think.

 

[SavDog23]

Keep Grundy.

Upgrade Roberts to Serong/Butters
Zilliams to Stewart

Keep Meek.

Roberts to Tracc
Zilliams to stewart
Meek to English in a couple.

I think.

Still think keep Grundy, Butters has cats/north/hawks next 3 weeks so should go on a tear with no Rozee around.

Petracca with the RD14 bye gonna be tough if you have too many premos missing already.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Keep Grundy.

Upgrade Roberts to Serong/Butters
Zilliams to Stewart

Keep Meek.

Roberts to Tracc
Zilliams to stewart
Meek to English in a couple.

I think.

There's going to be cheap options .
But I think we to start to look at byes players that suit .
Imo.

 

[VainGlorious]

Still think keep Grundy, Butters has cats/north/hawks next 3 weeks so should go on a tear with no Rozee around.

Petracca with the RD14 bye gonna be tough if you have too many premos missing already.

That’s what I’m leaning towards mate.

It’s essentially:

Grundy (who I started) Butters/Serong, and Stewart

V

English (from Meek) Tracc and Stewart.

Meek doesn’t appear to be a keeper whereas Grundy has the history and a 108 average for a $482k starting price.

As far as byes go, I’m missing roughly 4-5 premos for each bye as it stands, so I’m equally as ****ed for 12,14,15. Lol

 

[rocker_oz33]

Still think keep Grundy, Butters has cats/north/hawks next 3 weeks so should go on a tear with no Rozee around.

Petracca with the RD14 bye gonna be tough if you have too many premos missing already.

I like to get butters but I'll see where the chips fall at the end of the round .

Wanna up grade .
Roberts and caddie .
Will have to workout a good combo.

I got a POD mid in mind .

 

[Jiska]

Zerrett vs Bont vs Serong

 

[rocker_oz33]

Zerrett vs Bont vs Serong

We haven't seen the best of Bont yet .
These are very good options ...no clear winner