Opinion 2024 Player X vs Y vs Z

[WaynesWorld19]

Steele vs Mrouch

Steele seems a chance at being a keeper if fit, Crouch probably not. Have I answered my own question?

Crouch has to score 105+ to be worthwhile ....can he, Laird, and Dawson all go 100+ ......would be unusual

I'm sticking with Steele at this stage .....although Crouch has had an outstanding PS

 

[Pavlovs Cat]

I have Guthrie. Windhager is such an awkward price. Need to have big balls.

If a Sainter isnt sure....

 

[gutsroy]

Bont + Xerri vs J Steele+ Gawn?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Bont + Xerri vs J Steele+ Gawn?

Steele and Gawn

 

[JuddgementDay]

Fyfe vs Harmes

 

[Northernsoul74]

Fyfe vs Harmes

Harmes.

 

[buttox]

Fyfe and daicos vs HH and Jackson.

 

[54Dogs]

Crouch has to score 105+ to be worthwhile ....can he, Laird, and Dawson all go 100+ ......would be unusual

I'm sticking with Steele at this stage .....although Crouch has had an outstanding PS

Tend to agree. Hard to know if Crouch can push north of 70% CBAs and he'll struggle to be worth it without that.

This always caps his ceiling as well

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Fyfe and daicos vs HH and Jackson.

HH seems a bit of a nothing pick, especially with the early bye. Jackson will get cheaper with Hodor in the team I reckon.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Tend to agree. Hard to know if Crouch can push north of 70% CBAs and he'll struggle to be worth it without that.

This always caps his ceiling as well
View attachment 1899670

IF Crouch plays with those Kick to handball ratio, he'll be playing SANFL .......it's the very reason he's nt been able to get AFL games, the last 2 years

He's been asked to use his legs to drive thru the contest .....moving the ball fwd, primarily by foot

He's found it difficult to comply with the Coaches instructions ......but managed it in about 75% of his 2023 games

All coaches are demanding this .....Pedlar, Rankine, and Rachele, have demonstrated their ability to be direct

The future is in Crouch's hands now

 

[54Dogs]

IF Crouch plays with those Kick to handball ratio, he'll be playing SANFL .......it's the very reason he's nt been able to get AFL games, the last 2 years

He's been asked to use his legs to drive thru the contest .....moving the ball fwd, primarily by foot

He's found it difficult to comply with the Coaches instructions ......but managed it in about 75% of his 2023 games

All coaches are demanding this .....Pedlar, Rankine, and Rachele, have demonstrated their ability to be direct

The future is in Crouch's hands now

The fact that a potential premium could be playing SANFL another sound reason to stay away

 

[Lord De Goey]

Macrae + Roberts

V

Yeo + Billings

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Floating Doughnut ....who do you take?

M.Crouch v Wines v C.Guthrie

 

[Floating Doughnut]

Floating Doughnut ....who do you take?

M.Crouch v Wines v C.Guthrie

Crouch but not as a keeper , considered the other two greatly as stepping to Nicky but my boy has fixed his wicked ways
and the club will reward him for it, at least the 7 games needed.

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

Macrae + Roberts

V

Yeo + Billings

Macrae & Roberts if he looks good off Hb in preseason.

If not, the other one. But Yeo is risky as, probs be trading him out R2 haha.

 

[AFDogs]

Tom Powell vs Fyfe vs Billings

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Tom Powell vs Fyfe vs Billings

Wouldn't you just love to have a crystal ball lying around...

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Tom Powell vs Fyfe vs Billings

Billings the safer bet ....Fyfe the gamble that could pay off .....Powell, a trade-in option, role is not yet locked

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Billings the safer bet ....Fyfe the gamble that could pay off .....Powell, a trade-in option, role is not yet locked

Yet Billings has never been a safe bet...

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Yet Billings has never been a safe bet...

True .....hence using the word safer

He's getting good wraps in PS ....even being involved in CBA's .....of course that's not definitive ...at least he wasn't the water boy

 

[Better Loosen Up]

True .....hence using the word safer

He's getting good wraps in PS ....even being involved in CBA's .....of course that's not definitive ...at least he wasn't the water boy

Even back when he was at his peak he was probably in every second coaches never again list.

 

[JuddgementDay]

Tom Powell vs Fyfe vs Billings

LOL - I have all three of them

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Yet Billings has never been a safe bet...

Should be fine for 75+, that will make him $150k.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Should be fine for 75+, that will make him $150k.

It is tempting to swap him for Windsor and save $63k at least we get a couple of looks before we start him.

 

[Makeshift Park]

...and if we were to pick two of F Macrae, Windsor and Wilson?