Opinion 2024 Player X vs Y vs Z

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Flanders and Billings
versus
Owens and Phillipou

Anything else leading you guys go one way or the other?

(Later one is better for the bye sitch, but on the other hand, I'm getting a bit worried that a considerable majority of my draft team is currently made up of just Saints, North, Dogs, Dockers and Cats players)

Sexy Ned Flanders and thrillings.

Billings is not a lock imo, need to see how he gets used by Melbourne. I'm not interested in mid priced second year players like Pou either, so maybe biased. Flanders a reasonable chance on being F1, but with the early bye I can see why some wouldn't start him.

 

[Makeshift Park]

Sexy Ned Flanders and thrillings.

Billings is not a lock imo, need to see how he gets used by Melbourne. I'm not interested in mid priced second year players like Pou either, so maybe biased. Flanders a reasonable chance on being F1, but with the early bye I can see why some wouldn't start him.

Its a tricky one. I feel like Flanders will be a force to be reckoned with, but having Round 3 AND Round 12 as byes is such a dissuasive factor for SC.

So long as Billings has the JS, its not hard to see him averaging 80+ and thereby achieve 150k, based on his history.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Its a tricky one. I feel like Flanders will be a force to be reckoned with, but having Round 3 AND Round 12 as byes is such a dissuasive factor for SC.

So long as Billings has the JS, its not hard to see him averaging 80+ and thereby achieve 150k, based on his history.

View attachment 1880670

Not a huge sample, but averages well at the MCG too.

 

[olds]

N.Daicos (def) and Walsh (mid)
vs
N.Daicos (mid) and Sinclair (def)

 

[Flandersss]

N.Daicos (def) and Walsh (mid)
vs
N.Daicos (mid) and Sinclair (def)

Daicos & Walsh

 

[MacStradbroke]

Not a huge sample, but averages well at the MCG too.

View attachment 1880672

Trending beautifully Flanders, but Dimma question marks (similar with Touk).

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Trending beautifully Flanders, but Dimma question marks (similar with Touk).

This 100% Dimma will have his own thoughts on the list and also how he wants them to play.
With the early bye and question marks over roles I'm not keen on starting any Suns players and Flanders is $500k so even if he does start like a house on fire he won't rise too much in price.

 

[rocker_oz33]

This 100% Dimma will have his own thoughts on the list and also how he wants them to play.
With the early bye and question marks over roles I'm not keen on starting any Suns players and Flanders is $500k so even if he does start like a house on fire he won't rise too much in price.

Miller a first choice mid ...
Flanders will do what he can to please dimmer .

But that early bye kinda sux

 

[Northernsoul74]

Gawn and Butters vs English and Touk.

 

[Flandersss]

Gawn and Butters vs English and Touk.

English & Touk

 

[rocker_oz33]

Flanders dpp kinda handy as forwards suck.

Early bye with GWS (green).

Hard having Miller, Flanders and Green ..

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

This 100% Dimma will have his own thoughts on the list and also how he wants them to play.
With the early bye and question marks over roles I'm not keen on starting any Suns players and Flanders is $500k so even if he does start like a house on fire he won't rise too much in price.

Touk is under priced, he won't be tagging. Should beat his price easily, it's just how many early bye players do you want.

Flanders more appealing due to being one of the few attractive picks in the forwards.

Trending beautifully Flanders, but Dimma question marks (similar with Touk).

That stat line was for Billings - averages 88 over 14 games at the MCG. Wide open spaces might suit him. Should play high half forward with Hunter and langdon being their wingers. Fingers crossed he goes 80+

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Flanders dpp kinda handy as forwards suck.

Early bye with GWS (green).

Hard having Miller, Flanders and Green ..

I'm off Green, can't pay that much when he misses two of the first twelve rounds. Plenty of similar priced options will play all 12.

Touk has the same byes, but much cheaper.

 

[rocker_oz33]

I'm off Green, can't pay that much when he misses two of the first twelve rounds. Plenty of similar priced options will play all 12.

Touk has the same byes, but much cheaper.

Yes .
Pros and cons of SC .

Green plays big % of mid time .

How does the less % of Miller and co where to they play when not in the guts .
But they will be fresher and not burnt out like under mount DEW.

Guess the cheapest option might be the right option...for now .

Woof.

 

[shockmaster]

Sinclair vs Houston?

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Touk is under priced, he won't be tagging. Should beat his price easily, it's just how many early bye players do you want.

Flanders more appealing due to being one of the few attractive picks in the forwards.


That stat line was for Billings - averages 88 over 14 games at the MCG. Wide open spaces might suit him. Should play high half forward with Hunter and langdon being their wingers. Fingers crossed he goes 80+

Touk is well underpriced he averaged 124& 120 in 2021,2022 and last year had 5 scores over 100 at 115 until D*head Dew decided he would be a great tagger and then in the same game got injured. I know Dimma will let him off the leash but the early bye is a put off.

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Sinclair vs Houston?

Always go with the player with a Mullet

 

[rocker_oz33]

Touk is well underpriced he averaged 124& 120 in 2021,2022 and last year had 5 scores over 100 at 115 until D*head Dew decided he would be a great tagger and then in the same game got injured. I know Dimma will let him off the leash but the early bye is a put off.

When too league games start ....?
Early bye wouldn't be much of a worry

 

[Flandersss]

Sinclair vs Houston?

Sinclair

 

[Flandersss]

Always go with the player with a Mullet

He cut it off

 

[shockmaster]

Sinclair

Any idea on his role for 2024? Seems to score better staying in defence

 

[Flandersss]

Any idea on his role for 2024? Seems to score better staying in defence

Agreed mate. Think we will look to play him mid id say 60/40 favouring defence

 

[rocker_oz33]

He cut it off

 

[Flandersss]

Serong v Green v LDU

 

[marcmurphy3]

Serong v Green v LDU

LDU > Serong > Green