Opinion 2024 Player X vs Y vs Z

[Maybe Tomorrow]

As a Crow supporter ....I have Dawson at M1 over Laird

Laird just starting to slow down a bit (slight) .....and despite the experts saying Crouch impacts Dawson more ...I have the opposite view, it'll be Laird

Didn't Laird average more with Crouch in the team?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Didn't Laird average more with Crouch in the team?

Both Laird and Crouch are both first touch MIDS .....Dawson gets most points from 1st receive and transition

Dawson in his first year as a MID was probably tired, or carrying general soreness

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Both Laird and Crouch are both first touch MIDS .....Dawson gets most points from 1st receive and transition

Dawson in his first year as a MID was probably tired, or carrying general soreness

Is that a yes?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Is that a yes?

 

[TempletonTheRat]

both Laird and Dawson have proved they can score at high levels without midfield time. doubt Crouch impacts either of them imo

 

[Significant]

Bont and worst rookie ($123k - Darcy?)
vs
Laird and Billings
vs
Brayshaw and Fyfe

 

[buttox]

Bont and worst rookie ($123k - Darcy?)
vs
Laird and Billings
vs
Brayshaw and Fyfe

Bont for me

 

[JuddgementDay]

Yeo, LDU, Flanders
vs
Sheezel, Dawson, CMacD

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Yeo, LDU, Flanders
vs
Sheezel, Dawson, CMacD

Sheezel, Dawson, CMacD Easily

 

[JuddgementDay]

Sheezel, Dawson, CMacD Easily

Easily - why so?

I'm going around in circles - it's not an easy and clear decision for me

Yeo - is playing midfield
LDU - could be in for a huge year
Flanders - flavour of the month

CMacD - what can we expect from him?

 

[buttox]

Easily - why so?

I'm going around in circles - it's not an easy and clear decision for me

Yeo - is playing midfield
LDU - could be in for a huge year
Flanders - flavour of the month

CMacD - what can we expect from him?

CMAC is a much better pick than Yeo
Yeo is a trap the other 5 you mention are decent picks.

 

[JuddgementDay]

CMAC is a much better pick than Yeo
Yeo is a trap the other 5 you mention are decent picks.

Yeo is my ticket to NDaicos

 

[buttox]

Yeo is my ticket to NDaicos

Just take daicos.
Don't be too cute about it..
Daicos is a captain option. You will probably get his score more than 30 times this year.

 

[kool kangas]

l want to pick 2 players out of these 3...but l'm not sure which 2. Thoughts?

Butters
Serong
Rozee...

 

[VainGlorious]

l want to pick 2 players out of these 3...but l'm not sure which 2. Thoughts?

Butters
Serong
Rozee...

Butters & Serong

 

[kyri]

Coleman vs Wardlaw?

 

[Northernsoul74]

Coleman vs Wardlaw?

Different lines so probably depends on the x vs y ie Coleman and ? Vs Wardlaw and ? Rookies might made the decision for you.

 

[Rustymagoo]

Sorry because it has probably already been asked a hundred times but I am too lazy to look for it but Billings versus Jordan? Its the difference for me between Conway Twitty and Naismith on the Ruck Bench.

 

[Lord De Goey]

Sorry because it has probably already been asked a hundred times but I am too lazy to look for it but Billings versus Jordan? Its the difference for me between Conway Twitty and Naismith on the Ruck Bench.

I prefer Billings. Feel like he might have a more important role for the dees

 

[Rustymagoo]

I prefer Billings. Feel like he might have a more important role for the dees

Thanks, I prefer Jack because his cheaper cost allows me to bring in Twitty.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Sorry because it has probably already been asked a hundred times but I am too lazy to look for it but Billings versus Jordan? Its the difference for me between Conway Twitty and Naismith on the Ruck Bench.

Billings, reckon Jordon is mainly wing for Sydney.

 

[ubeaut]

And where will Billings play?

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

And where will Billings play?

HFF with a sprinkling of wing

 

[Jack Lindon]

Sheezel vs Young for D4 (don't want to start both of them)

 

[Flandersss]

Sheezel vs Young for D4 (don't want to start both of them)

Sheezel