Opinion 2024 Player X vs Y vs Z

[rocker_oz33]

Wouldn't that give Coffield more opportunities and JS?

Bowey out for 8 weeks ...
Coffin field....has Bevo .

I'll waiting on them this week.... hoping for someone better ...

 

[Nelso]

Wouldn't that give Coffield more opportunities and JS?

More chance of Coffield being dropped than Hore.

Bowey being out for 2 months helps Hore's job security.

Coffield is more chance of breaking down with injury than Hore as well.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

More chance of Coffield being dropped than Hore.

Bowey being out for 2 months helps Hore's job security.

Coffield is more chance of breaking down with injury than Hore as well.

Just need him to hold until round 6. After that he's gone and Roberts/Sexton/Mckercher can be moved back as required.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Just need him to hold until round 6. After that he's gone and Roberts/Sexton/Mckercher can be moved back as required.

Unsure if Julia hangs around that long TBH .

 

[tufftiger]

Would like some opinions on this trade for a SC Draft league.

Sheezel & Petracca for Bont & Flanders

Got me scratching my head!

 

[Petrify]

Unsure which 2 to field out of T.Berry vs Sexton vs Reid. Thoughts? Feel like there's a strong case to be made for all 3

 

[JY5165]

hogan v fyfe v billings

bear in mind, fyfe billings leaves cash in hand for other options next week

 

[TempletonTheRat]

hogan v fyfe v billings

bear in mind, fyfe billings leaves cash in hand for other options next week

Fyfe is not on the bubble - the other two are

 

[Scythe]

Unsure which 2 to field out of T.Berry vs Sexton vs Reid. Thoughts? Feel like there's a strong case to be made for all 3

Reid and Sexton have the better roles. Berry's went over 60 four times in 28 games of footy – in a best-18 week, go for the picks with more upside (Berry played great last week, but he's more a safe 50-60 type).

 

[LuvtheKangas]

Unsure which 2 to field out of T.Berry vs Sexton vs Reid. Thoughts? Feel like there's a strong case to be made for all 3

Agree. Perhaps leave Berry on the bench because the disappointment of missing points if he goes large again is offset by the big $ he'll be making you.

 

[JY5165]

Fyfe is not on the bubble - the other two are

fyfa has a really good matchup coming up though?

 

[Geead]

Who's got the best Job Security in order: C.Dean vs T.Pink vs M.Hore

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Who's got the best Job Security in order: C.Dean vs T.Pink vs M.Hore

Well Dean got dropped......

 

[Gresham2King]

Who's got the best Job Security in order: C.Dean vs T.Pink vs M.Hore

Certainly not Charlie Dean

 

[Geead]

Certainly not Charlie Dean

View attachment 1934760

Lol i just saw now swap him for B.Uwland in this conversation

 

[Gresham2King]

Lol i just saw now swap him for B.Uwland in this conversation

Probably Hore with Bowey out for a while, think I'll aim to get him next week

 

[Geead]

Probably Hore with Bowey out for a while, think I'll aim to get him next week

Yeah, i ask cos I've got Gibcus & Reid lol Can probably hold for a week, also got Harmes who im already thinking of dumping for Billings

 

[Gresham2King]

Yeah, i ask cos I've got Gibcus & Reid lol Can probably hold for a week, also got Harmes who im already thinking of dumping for Billings

Had the same issue in Harmes, I traded to T. Berry which allowed me to go Gibcus to McKercher who I originally wanted to fade

 

[Geead]

Had the same issue in Harmes, I traded to T. Berry which allowed me to go Gibcus to McKercher who I originally wanted to fade

THANK YOU! T.Berry actually a better choice for me too - gives me flexibility to go from Gibcus to Zilliams next week and have a free look at Pink & Hore this week

Edit: Now knowing my luck Harmes will score 100+ when he comes back

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I'm struggling here ....do I

Trade Wines to Heeney .....maybe 15 point better ave and cash gen

OR

Trade Sam Berry to a sharp / T. Berry ....and then Fisher to Heeney, thus retaining Wines

Wines seems the more reliable and better bye .....but Sam Berry will make more cash, but likely be a 80-85 ave

Help please

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

I'm struggling here ....do I

Trade Wines to Heeney .....maybe 15 point better ave and cash gen

OR

Trade Sam Berry to a sharp / T. Berry ....and then Fisher to Heeney, thus retaining Wines

Wines seems the more reliable and better bye .....but Sam Berry will make more cash, but likely be a 80-85 ave

Help please

Why would you trade Berry? He's priced at 41 and scored 80. He'll make you as much as TBerry and saves you the trade.

Heeney is all about what you think Sydney are going to do with Parker and Adams. Do they push Heeney out after their bye? If you think so is he worth the trade?

 

[JuddgementDay]

I'm struggling here ....do I

Trade Wines to Heeney .....maybe 15 point better ave and cash gen

OR

Trade Sam Berry to a sharp / T. Berry ....and then Fisher to Heeney, thus retaining Wines

Wines seems the more reliable and better bye .....but Sam Berry will make more cash, but likely be a 80-85 ave

Help please

"Trade Wines to Heeney .....maybe 15 point better ave and cash gen" - how does that work out when considering the additional bye?

 

[WaynesWorld19]

"Trade Wines to Heeney .....maybe 15 point better ave and cash gen" - how does that work out when considering the additional bye?

Not having Grundy helps .....and I won't have to worry about Naicos, as his scores are easily countered by Rookies

 

[Judd_Magic]

Fyfe or Mckercher?

 

[TempletonTheRat]

Fyfe or Mckercher?