List Mgmt. 2025 AFL Draft - Draft Analysis

[cairo tiger]

what are cummings combine results speed, agility etc we need speeed

 

[SA_Tiger11]

what are cummings combine results speed, agility etc we need speeed

He’s quick

 

[Cherki]

So that Pies bloke wasn’t talking shit about us being interested in the milky menace.

 

[cairo tiger]

He’s quick

so am I I want data

 

[prodigy]

so am I I want data

Lol no you're not

 

[Coach_Required]

Beggars fan playing the victim. Shock horror:

Probably will ask for another PP now.

 

[Drunken Wookie]

what are cummings combine results speed, agility etc we need speeed

he def aint slow 2.971 but not lightning either

 

[Lsta062]

Who are the gun mids? Seems like the club reckons there aren’t any of note.

Robey and Cumming have great potential rotating through IMO

 

[RockJobster0312]

Can anybody work out what pick our #38 becomes ?
and also what number it is in the open draft

Impossible to know obviously with so many possible bids.

But I did a quick mock and had it at 34 with 11 bids before (Uwland, Dean, Patterson, Annable, Kyle, Murray, Carmichael, Ison, Williams, King and Sweid) and 1 not matched (Addinsall).

 

[tigerdan]

I don't buy the line of it being a routine visit just to see Cumming's family. Seems like our guys place a high value on character and family environment, I don't see our meticulous team leaving it that late to go and do that.

Surely we were there to tell him we're gonna take him.

Plus the bit where he says "not sure how you guys knew that we were doing that".

You don't go up to Mildura if you don't have to.

 

[THE_GUN]

There is going to be alot of nice players left at our #38 which is looking like #33/#34 according to Twomeys draft
Pou , BOB , LeRay, Greeves , NHH, Ludowyke , Dalton , Holmes , Onley , Allen , Kickett , Ainsworth , Rodriguez

 

[Toadvine]

There is going to be alot of nice players left at our #38 which is looking like #33/#34 according to Twomeys draft
Pou , BOB , LeRay, Greeves , NHH, Ludowyke , Dalton , Holmes , Onley , Allen , Kickett , Ainsworth , Rodriguez

Jeez maybe we take Kickett in the rookie draft the way things are shaking out. Can we even use pick 68?

 

[THE_GUN]

Jeez maybe we take Kickett in the rookie draft the way things are shaking out. Can we even use pick 68?

We could take kickett at #68 if still available which would come into around #57.#58 and if Kellaway gets passed and rookie listed

 

[T4P]

reading twomey's draft, it sounds like he's pretty much guessing for our picks: 'this is where it gets interesting', 'four players in its sights for two picks', 'the bombers will be waiting to see who gets through from richmond's picks'. love it.

 

[wormy]

Dream draft:
Robey, Cumming, 38 Pou, 68 Kickett

 

[We are back baby!]

I got the impression the Grlj isn’t going to be in our sights unless we split and we’re taking best available.

That's a mistake. Grjl is the Murphy Reid of this year's draft

 

[Damo80]

What’s our list position again? 4 + 1 rookie, or 4 total available spots? I’m sure the club is all over it, but is there a scenario where Kellaway gets a bid and we’ve already filled our primary list, meaning we can’t match. Would be unfortunate.

 

[RockJobster0312]

Plus the bit where he says "not sure how you guys knew that we were doing that".

You don't go up to Mildura if you don't have to.

With my wife being from there I’d second that last statement.

That said, we met with Xavier Taylor recently as well as Robey last week.

So I’m not sure it’s the definitive call most are assuming.

 

[Wrenny]

What’s our list position again? 4 + 1 rookie, or 4 total available spots? I’m sure the club is all over it, but is there a scenario where Kellaway gets a bid and we’ve already filled our primary list, meaning we can’t match. Would be unfortunate.

We can be flexible, 5 lists spots.

All depends on when/if the Kellaway bid comes at.

Can go 3 picks in ND, 2 Rookies.
Or 4 picks in ND, 1 Rookie.

 

[THE THIN MAN]

Not impressed by cumming tbh. Not sure why not considering sharp hes the safest pick. Gotta nail some meat and bone mids

 

[THE_GUN]

While its looking food with Robey & Cumming which is what i was wanting/hoping to get
I genuinely believe cal is having a foot in each door by selecting Cumming first then Robey

#7 - Cumming
#8 - Robey
#9 - Taylor

I still think its very possible we take Taylor and Roby gets to the Bombers and thats why he has them where he has so if that eventuates, he doesn't look far off the mark

 

[RobsJourney]

While its looking food with Robey & Cumming which is what i was wanting/hoping to get
I genuinely believe cal is having a foot in each door by selecting Cumming first then Robey

#7 - Cumming
#8 - Robey
#9 - Taylor

I still think its very possible we take Taylor and Roby gets to the Bombers and thats why he has them where he has so if that eventuates, he doesn't look far off the mark

We apparently met with Robey’s family “again” last week, so we seem keen.

 

[tigs2010]

We apparently met with Robey’s family “again” last week, so we seem keen.

Twomey has fallen for the old Bone Allan fly over to see the family Friday before the draft again...

 

[KrispyKreme]

View attachment 2478833

All that matters

Hasn’t been draft night yet

 

[Michaels]

For anyone interested, I went back over the accuracy of the top picks in these mocks from Cal.

2020:
1st pick only correct

2021:
first 9 of 9 correct

2022:
first 11 / 11 correct

2023:
first 7 / 7 correct

2024:
first 10/10 correct

last 4 years he has knocked it out of the park and it is going to take an out of the blue year for him to not be on the money, especially when talking about the top 5 picks.

Not to say it can't happen of course!

But recent history suggests its more likely that he is correct.

what is also interesting is the sharp turn of events from 2020 - 2021. I'm not sure if his status in the AFL circle rose dramatically in that time and was maybe granted a bit more info / access than previous?