List Mgmt. 2025 AFL Draft - Draft Analysis

[Richorules]

Have been set on Cumming since the champs. Very happy if we end up with him. He has the agility and fast feet out of stoppage we need. He can dodge tackles and create something out of nothing. Very few on our list have those traits and the few that do don't have the class to match.

Out of the rumoured 4 - Cumming, Roby, Grlj, Taylor. He's my number #1.

Roby next. But he has some risk with the lack of exposure and the concerning sprint time. I caught up with his games and he has smarts, decent burst (not amazing ) and goal kicking that is valuable. His upward running style and gait kind of reminds me of Harvey Langford without the elite kicking. But he's an easily selection over the Sharp and Greeves types. You don't take one paced inside mids this high in the modern game.

I will say this, at some point Richmond has to take the risk on the electric outside player with class like a Grlj type even if they lack the accumulation and inside game. And hope they develop it. Max Holmes had no contested game as a junior. If they take one of those two hopefully it's the right one. I have Roby slightly ahead as he has more tools in his game and overall probably more talent.

Xavier Taylor last. I hope he goes to Essendon. You need to seriously special as a mid sized defender to be worth a top 5 pick. The positional and list value just ain't there.

So in summary, Cumming at all costs and then let's see. If the Essendon trade up deal is there I'm taking Cumming and that trade to have 3 1sts instead of 2 and then happily taking whatever is left over.

Take Kondogiannas at 38 mid defender

 

[Yappie dribbles]

Taylor grilj kellaway are who we are taking we are bluffing the other sides

This is our draft haul

We will take kickett or scherri as a rookie which ever is still available

 

[Muddiemoose]

Taylor grilj kellaway are who we are taking we are bluffing the other sides

This is our draft haul

We will take kickett or scherri as a rookie which ever is still available

The oracle has spoken.

 

[tigs2010]

Still reckon Taylor might end up with us in the late mail edition.

 

[Muddiemoose]

Still reckon Taylor might end up with us in the late mail edition.

When does he tend to drop that?

 

[tigs2010]

When does he tend to drop that?

Tonight I think

 

[dean33]

Calculating has set this board into full melt mode come Wednesday night, with everyone expecting robey and cumming now only to watch us draft 2 players we need to google to find out who they are.
Blair playing everyone off a break.

 

[Bojangles17]

Comforted to hear that the giesch has tuned in this time with some intent after ignoring the smart money for Murphy last year as it looks like we should secure cumming who is bang on what we need , tough quick and can accumulate, hellooooo like no one else like it on our list
Get it done

 

[voorhees]

all things seem to be pointing towards Robey..
adding more talent as we go along with his size and highlights.
keep building tige's

 

[tigers12]

Robey and sharp for me
Sharp looks like a round 1 lock player and contested best and we need that

 

[sc2001]

Robey and sharp for me
Sharp looks like a round 1 lock player and contested best and we need that

Sharp, Taranto and Hopper makes the worlds slowest midfield with the worst outside game to go along with it

 

[We are back baby!]

Comforted to hear that the giesch has tuned in this time with some intent after ignoring the smart money for Murphy last year as it looks like we should secure cumming who is bang on what we need , tough quick and can accumulate, hellooooo like no one else like it on our list
Get it done

Grjl is the Murphy Reid of this draft

 

[captain cotch 9]

As much as i love XT I think it makes the most sense to take Cumming and Robey.

 

[sportshow]

Robey and Cummings please .... wake me up only when done ....

(ok .... X Taylor would be acceptable over Cummings too)

 

[Richorules]

As much as i love XT I think it makes the most sense to take Cumming and Robey.

Then Kondo, Kickett, Kellaway

 

[sc2001]

Grjl is the Murphy Reid of this draft

You might be right, but if Murphy Reid played for the eagles, kangas or us he wouldve sucked last year. Got drafted by a good team and they got his role right, same will probably happen with Grlj if he goes to the hawks doesnt mean we wiffed not taking them.

 

[bc27]

There’s a bit of Matty Rowell in Cumming.

Cumming looks like he will become an extractor in time, but with a little more athleticism that can allow him to do some damage on the outside aswell. Has strength and explosiveness that is ideal for modern footy.

 

[Cotchy9]

There’s a bit of Matty Rowell in Cumming.

Cumming looks like he will become an extractor in time, but with a little more athleticism that can allow him to do some damage on the outside aswell. Has strength and explosiveness that is ideal for modern footy.

Had the same thought. Similar kicking style and burst from the contest

 

[Grrr]

If we don’t draft Robey and Cumming I am sending Twomey death threats.

Just do it chicken.

 

[We are back baby!]

what are cummings combine results speed, agility etc we need speeed

Cumming was a 2.98s 20m sprint ... he ran faster in the SA testing at the start of the year ... his agility is poor ... he is explosive in a straight line especially over the first 5 metres

 

[THE THIN MAN]

Don’t know why but I see a lot of Dunkley in him

 

[Wavvey]

WC have pick 1+2 and are somehow going to pick the 2 worst players in the top 10 LOL

 

[Wacky Tiger]

WC have pick 1+2 and are somehow going to pick the 2 worst players in the top 10 LOL

 

[Rubber Hips]

 

[_RT_]

When the late mail phantom due?

Likely about 24 hours before the draft

* - Just catching up with thread