Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2025 AFL Draft

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
I could be wrong, but reading through our autopsy threads and the general anger at Taranto, Dow, Hopper, Kmac etc., I think the general consensus is we need midfield help too ;)
Given this is such a massive need, this is why I'm against trading out especially with 2 top 3 picks likely to be ours this year and possibly a top 5 pick next year. We could very well have our midfield sorted for the next decade with those 3 picks & Kellaway plus Lalor Smillie Hotton & McAuliffe already on the list.
 
Haha we definitely do need help, but I will mention this. Straight from the mouth of someone who is very close to Harley is that he is staying put at west coast. So that I don’t believe will happen. This is ultimately why I think Duursma is going pick 1.

I get the theory, and I don’t have any confidence in WCE recent list management and recruiting decision making or how they’ve handled Harley, but picking Duursma seems a risk if you don’t have Harley signed up. If he takes off end of year seems pretty certain Will would bolt too when he could.

And I don’t know anything about Harley’s and Yaz’s personalities and their relationship, so take this with a grain of salt, but seems risky betting on two 20 year olds in relationship to leverage that connection between Yaz and Will to keep Harley happy. He’d want to be Trent Cotchin off the field if I was betting on him like that.

I also don’t think Harley will have made his final decision until season ends unless it’s stay long term. He has all the leverage with every club by saying nothing and his manager will know that.
 
Why ? they both fall into our picks range and are both the exact types we desperately need

Rodriguez , Grlj , Kellaway just about complete the midfield
I agree they are gettable but they are both rated later than our two picks, therefore, I can't see Richmond taking both. However, if we were able to get the three players you've mentioned by trading down one of our picks I'd be rapt.
 
I agree they are gettable but they are both rated later than our two picks, therefore, I can't see Richmond taking both. However, if we were able to get the three players you've mentioned by trading down one of our picks I'd be rapt.
Every club has their own ratings and things change in the next 3 months
specially after the combine. Apart from Essendon and maybe Hawks i cant see who we could trade with and that would be to move down and get a 2nd rounder which is not great and there are no standout players clubs would be clamoring for to give up a F1
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Grlj is going to be a gun. He is exactly what we need and will probably have a massive nationals
Will the Nationals elevate Grlj to a top 3/4 level? as that is the most likely draft positions we will find ourselves in.
His speed and evasiveness is what we're crying out for. Rodriguez also.

Rodriguez, Greaves and Grlj are my wants.
 
Will the Nationals elevate Grlj to a top 3/4 level? as that is the most likely draft positions we will find ourselves in.
His speed and evasiveness is what we're crying out for. Rodriguez also.

Rodriguez, Greaves and Grlj are my wants.
Grlj is already been spoken about in that range. It's only Fred who isn't, but he has the tools to elevate himself into that discussion. I'd like Sharp and Grlj personally. We need a big clearance inside bull who can hand it out to Lalor, Hotton, Smille etc.
 
Kellaway was named among the best for SA on the day, reward for his excellent work at the coalface. He was a big contributor to the dominance of the SA midfield, getting first hands on the ball at stoppage regularly or working hard to chain out as a receiver. He made excellent decisions, his hands were quick and slick, and he beamed a NSW player viciously from point blank range.

 
Last edited:
Will the Nationals elevate Grlj to a top 3/4 level? as that is the most likely draft positions we will find ourselves in.
His speed and evasiveness is what we're crying out for. Rodriguez also.

Rodriguez, Greaves and Grlj are my wants.
He’s been spoken about that range atm. If his nationals are good I don’t see why not. Kid has great work ethic.

We need a big clearance inside bull who can hand it out to Lalor, Hotton, Smille etc.

Only one option Dyson Sharp
 
Pretty sure we already have our Dyson Sharp.

Hopper, Prestia, McKauliffe, Sonsie, Dow, Smillie can only exclusicely play inside mid.

None are fast, none are currently playing particularly creatively, none can play other positions.

We need someone with speed and decision making to sepperate themselves and make plays outside the congestion.
 
SOUTH AUSTRALIA

F: Sam Cumming (North), Mitchell Marsh (West), Aidan Schubert (Central)

HF: Jesse Nye (South), Zane Peucker (Eagles), Cameron Nairn (Central)

C: Harley Barker (Sturt), Dyson Sharp (Central), Matt LeRay (Central)

HB: Luke Candy (Glenelg), Balyn O’Brien (Norwood), Jack Cook (Eagles)

B: Bryce Sanders (North), Noah Daw (Norwood), Jett Dahlitz (Sturt)



R: Sam Ainsworth (Norwood), Noah Roberts-Thomson (Sturt), Louis Kellaway (Sturt)

INT: Tim Alver (Glenelg), Blake Oudshoorn-Bennier (North), Elliott Duffield (South), Jim Kelly (Norwood), Kodah Edwards (South), Joshua Reichelt (Central)

tigs2010 looks like there is 2 BOBs to go with the 2 Lindsays
 

U18 National Championships fixture​

Sun, June 1: Allies v South Australia, 12pm AEST, Blacktown ISP
Sat, June 7: Western Australia v Vic Country, 10am AWST, Mineral Resources Park
Sun, June 8: South Australia v Vic Metro, 11.15am ACST, Alberton Oval
Sun, June 15: South Australia v Western Australia, 12pm ACST, Alberton Oval
Sun, June 29: Vic Country v South Australia, 10.30am AEST, Venue TBC (Victoria)
Sun, June 29: Allies v Western Australia, 1pm AEST, Venue TBC (Victoria)
Sat, July 5: Allies v Vic Country, 12.15pm AEST, Ikon Park
Sun, July 6: Western Australia v Vic Metro, 12pm AWST, Venue TBC (Western Australia)
Sun, July 13: Allies v Vic Metro, 10.30am AEST, Brighton Hones Arena
Sun, July 20: Vic Country v Vic Metro, 11am AEST, RSEA Park

All games will be streamed live on the AFL website and app. Squads listed at:
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Given this is such a massive need, this is why I'm against trading out especially with 2 top 3 picks likely to be ours this year and possibly a top 5 pick next year. We could very well have our midfield sorted for the next decade with those 3 picks & Kellaway plus Lalor Smillie Hotton & McAuliffe already on the list.
But will we be able to get someone the level of Reid in the draft? That’s the question I have.

Reid’s talented. He went number 1 for a reason, and not every draft has a player like him. If we can get a Reid/Callaghan in this draft, then take the picks to the draft. If not, then I’d go for Reid.

I haven’t been following this year’s draftees so can’t comment much on their quality, but it’d be a shame if we’re only considering the draft.
 
Given this is such a massive need, this is why I'm against trading out especially with 2 top 3 picks likely to be ours this year and possibly a top 5 pick next year. We could very well have our midfield sorted for the next decade with those 3 picks & Kellaway plus Lalor Smillie Hotton & McAuliffe already on the list.
That's a lot of mids. I think giving up 2 for Reid makes sense especially if we can get something back to get a running player.

Would have been nice to see how Smill and Taj looked before making the call
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

That's a lot of mids. I think giving up 2 for Reid makes sense especially if we can get something back to get a running player.

Would have been nice to see how Smill and Taj looked before making the call
If we could do something like 2 & 3 for Reid and Hawks R1, then I'd be more in favour of doing it, but doubt Matt Clarke is that generous
 
its not about the draft, but what we should be looking at is proaching some of the fitness guys from Collingwood. a whole bunch of them are over 30 and unfortunately still playing well. Elliott was stuffed 5 years ago and at 32 is killing it. same as Sidebottom and the like.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top