Opinion 2025 Fantasy - Player X vs Y vs Z

[Exambolor]

When I say I'm 'comfortable' with Hollands, it's more that he's got runs on the board, albeit a small sample size, in meaningful games without kick ins. I think his ceiling is higher than Peatling's. It would be nice to see him take the odd kick in though.

Gotcha. Yeah I agree, you need him to be more Nic Martin last year like to have full confidence.

Just nervous if he gets stints back on the wing and his scoring lowers. (With NOD for instance Freo's game plan suits wingers so you can be confident they score decently) or they abandon the experiment at some point and he gets moved/dropped, which is absolutely possible

 

[Barrybran]

Gotcha. Yeah I agree, you need him to be more Nic Martin last year like to have full confidence.

Just nervous if he gets stints back on the wing and his scoring lowers. (With NOD for instance Freo's game plan suits wingers so you can be confident they score decently) or they abandon the experiment at some point and he gets moved/dropped, which is absolutely possible

100%. And Nic Martin he is not.

 

[happy_eagle]

Petracca vs JHF

 

[samFFC]

Petracca vs JHF

JHF easily IMO
Clear F1 or 2 this year, plenty of value, less injury concern.

Not saying don’t get Trac but there are plenty similar value options in mids.

 

[Wels Eicke]

English & Hollands
Or
De Koning (Carl) & Rankine

Have concerns over all of them.

 

[bettingonbetts]

English & Hollands
Or
De Koning (Carl) & Rankine

Have concerns over all of them.

Second easy

 

[RustyShacklefordFalcon]

Stuck on M2, last pick.

Petracca, Horne-Francis or Libba?

 

[happy_eagle]

SDK (D5) + JHF/Petracca (M4)
or
Freijah (D5) + W.Ashcroft (M4)
or
Rivers (D3) + Hollands/Peatling (M6)
or
Holmes (D2) + O'Driscoll (M6)

 

[Barrybran]

Stuck on M2, last pick.

Petracca, Horne-Francis or Libba?

JHF. I actually like Libba in this scenario as, while he has the hardest run of the three to start, he'll be the undisputed #1 until Bont/Treloar return. I've gone with JHF though because I don't think Libba will necessarily outperform JHF, or at least by enough to warrant selecting him over someone with forward status.

 

[Barrybran]

SDK (D5) + JHF/Petracca (M4)
or
Freijah (D5) + W.Ashcroft (M4)
or
Rivers (D3) + Hollands/Peatling (M6)
or
Holmes (D2) + O'Driscoll (M6)

#4

Rivers looks like the fifth midfielder, so he's out. Chris Scott said yesterday that SDK could be a very good defender, and with Geelong now not playing opening round, that's a watch. Freijah + Ashcroft could work but both are down the pecking order.

 

[Milo Cyrus]

Sam Davidson vs Bevo'd by half time R1.

 

[kozi]

Clark, W Ashcroft, basement rook

vs

Dawson, SDK, NOD

 

[GrandGazza]

Stewart/Sicily & Sanders
or
Petracca & SDK

 

[Barrybran]

Clark, W Ashcroft, basement rook

vs

Dawson, SDK, NOD

Depends on the rookie

Stewart/Sicily & Sanders
or
Petracca & SDK

Depends on Chris Scott

 

[Trav 20]

My team is pretty much finished, but the more you look at it the more you're tempted by changes.

Perryman and Finn O'Sullivan (who may get a bit of time across half-back)

Or

Freijah and O'Driscoll

I currently have O'Driscoll in M7 and Freijah in F5, so it would mean Perryman in F5 and O'Sullivan in M7 (Ashcroft 8).

 

[powerrrrrrrrrrrr]

SDK (D5) + JHF/Petracca (M4)
or
Freijah (D5) + W.Ashcroft (M4)
or
Rivers (D3) + Hollands/Peatling (M6)
or
Holmes (D2) + O'Driscoll (M6)

I’ve currently got option 2.

Don’t like not getting a preview of SDK.

Lost interest in Rivers.

Don’t think Holmes scores great when playing midfield so need to see his role again first.

I can see Freijah going 80-85 (especially early) making cash for an upgrade.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

My team is pretty much finished, but the more you look at it the more you're tempted by changes.

Perryman and Finn O'Sullivan (who may get a bit of time across half-back)

Or

Freijah and O'Driscoll

I currently have O'Driscoll in M7 and Freijah in F5, so it would mean Perryman in F5 and O'Sullivan in M7 (Ashcroft 8).

Perryman and Finn O'Sullivan

 

[DukeX]

Sheezel + Knevitt + Sanders
vs
Clark + FOS + Rankine

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Sheezel + Knevitt + Sanders
vs
Clark + FOS + Rankine

Clark + FOS + Rankine

IMO the combined points will be greater than the the alternative

 

[Pure Grunt]

Last conundrum … I hope
Gawn/Xerri & Sheldrick
Vs
Briggs & Cerra

 

[Tex Danger]

Sheezel Short Roberts Perryman PriorTrainor (127k)

Vs

Short Roberts Perryman Freijah DeKoning Prior (367k)

 

[matty lloyd the champ]

Last conundrum … I hope
Gawn/Xerri & Sheldrick
Vs
Briggs & Cerra

Briggs' early bye means he really needs to outscore your other ruck options by a fair bit to make up losing 40+ points in his bye week. I don't see that happening.

 

[One Dimensional]

Draft question:

Who would you grab at pick 3?(Assuming Xerri and Sheez will be taken)

 

[Lukesera]

Draft question:

Who would you grab at pick 3?(Assuming Xerri and Sheez will be taken)

Daicos

 

[bettingonbetts]

Sheezel Short Roberts Perryman PriorTrainor (127k)

Vs

Short Roberts Perryman Freijah DeKoning Prior (367k)

Top by a mile