Game Day 2025 Jack Dyer Medal

[voorhees]

great to see Benny miller grabbing 4th after his positive season.
Banks and Campbell also great to see there names up high.
congrats to Hopper and hoping he can continue to stay healthy and add even more in 26'

 

[cairo tiger]

who gives these votes???

 

[tony__montana]

Good to see 5 of the top 12 are our next gen - Miller, Seth, Banks, Ross, Mansell. Need a handful more to step up next year before the 24 draftees start stamping themselves

 

[Truetiger]

who gives these votes???

the coaching staff

 

[SunshineBoy]

who gives these votes???

Kate Sheehan

 

[Dr Tigris]

Well done TT

Good to see some of the younger guys stepping up in the rankings. Would like to see Campbell take another step up. Could be a special.

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

How many votes did Robey get?

 

[Muddiemoose]

Good to see 5 of the top 12 are our next gen - Miller, Seth, Banks, Ross, Mansell. Need a handful more to step up next year before the 24 draftees start stamping themselves

Bit disappointed in Ross honestly

Given his age and experience he should really be getting a lot more consistency in his performances

His contract is up at the end of next year, if we don’t see that improvement I wouldn’t be shocked if he is moved on

 

[Dr Tigris]

How many votes did Robey get?

All of them

 

[Coach_Required]

Bit disappointed in Ross honestly

Given his age and experience he should really be getting a lot more consistency in his performances

His contract is up at the end of next year, if we don’t see that improvement I wouldn’t be shocked if he is moved on

Yeah, can easily see him being pushed out. Especially with all the younger guys coming through.

 

[Drunken Wookie]

Yeah, can easily see him being pushed out. Especially with all the younger guys coming through.

hes in that group with dow and sonsie imo, theyve had ample time and development poured into them to reach their potential. at some point you've got to draw a line and say this is their ceiling, its highly unlikely they progress any further, if their current output isn't cutting it toodle-oo.

 

[PeteTiger69minus4]

if nobody exceeds 50 "votes" maybe don't award one?

 

[Muddiemoose]

Yeah, can easily see him being pushed out. Especially with all the younger guys coming through.

At the very least you push him to half forward or the wing instead of trying to invest starting mid mins into him

He’s alright in those other roles and can play a role, but just not as good as I thought he could of been initially

 

[baazzaa]

weird how our midfield is packed with such guns and yet our clearance differential and inside-50 differential is so abysmal.

i'd chalk this up mostly to midfielder bias, given our defence is demonstrably far superior to our midfield it seems a no-brainer that our best players are in defence. imo vlastuin and miller both easily had better years than any midfielder.

 

[PeteTiger69minus4]

Damn imagine thinking that you played well in a game and then getting rekt by the match committee not giving a vote

they prob give you a 1.

love to see the votes for each game

it's a good system in theory

Dusty got 89 in 2017...

 

[PeteTiger69minus4]

Well... that's the Jack Dyer medal done & dusted for 2025.

Congrats to the top 6 and ofc congrats to Tim Taranto, PS should message Kaneo about Taranto not being in the top 150 players, math doesn't make sense only 18 clubs and he polled 20 Brownlow votes and is now 3x B&F, twice since coming to Richmond.

to be fair the way Taranto was playing, especially his disposal, when Cornes made the criticism, he wasn't in the top 1500

 

[PeteTiger69minus4]

At the very least you push him to half forward or the wing instead of trying to invest starting mid mins into him

He’s alright in those other roles and can play a role, but just not as good as I thought he could of been initially

he can kick a long goal. why not....

 

[CLFC23]

weird how our midfield is packed with such guns and yet our clearance differential and inside-50 differential is so abysmal.

i'd chalk this up mostly to midfielder bias, given our defence is demonstrably far superior to our midfield it seems a no-brainer that our best players are in defence. imo vlastuin and miller both easily had better years than any midfielder.

our midfield is not stacked. we have 2 decent mids and then nothing after that.

 

[juss]

Vlastuin robbed again, easily a better player than Taranto

 

[tony__montana]

Bit disappointed in Ross honestly

Given his age and experience he should really be getting a lot more consistency in his performances

His contract is up at the end of next year, if we don’t see that improvement I wouldn’t be shocked if he is moved on

Yeah agree- think he’s reached his ceiling now and over the next few seasons will be pushed out to a bottom 6-8 player in our best 22 - at best.

 

[tropicaltiger]

who gives these votes???

tiger imposter faxes them into the club every monday morning at 10:20 sharp.

 

[Daka]

Vlastuin robbed again, easily a better player than Taranto

I agree, but am not surprised Taranto won.

It's a shame Vlastuin gets no credit.