List Mgmt. 2025 List Management discussion - part 2

[stavro#4]

If young players like Nas, who are not free agents, can just go anywhere they want , what's the limit? You might as well just do away with the draft entirely and just sign up promising young players. Of course that will turn it into a game of have and have-nots which was always the issue.

Mate 0 chance a player of this quality gets past North or Richmond.

 

[Captain Paddy]

Did you get in some jerking of the gurking?

Friday 12:30. I reckon go back near the ride on mowers again, that worked out pretty well last week

 

[_Maximus_12]

Friday 12:30. I reckon go back near the ride on mowers again, that worked out pretty well last week

Do us a favour. Turn a mower on and stick your hands under it so you can’t type any more.
Cheers

 

[SaintJunior]

I reckon weve probably gotta get past getting our panties in a bunch over an article pumping up Logan Morris and pointing out that of the 18 current clubs were the only ones who didnt speak to him.

Whether you think thats poor list management work or whether you couldnt care (im in the latter basket for the record) its such a ****ing easy story and easy angle for them we probably have to just cop that one on the chin, not piss and moan that the big bad media is coming for us again.

Or we could call it out for what it is , a Brisbane journalist with an agenda.

 

[SainterinSydney]

Do us a favour. Turn a mower on and stick your hands under it so you can’t type any more.
Cheers

He would still find a way

 

[Train12]

Another Southampton and St Kilda fan? Never thought I would see the day up the saints x2!

Full saints die hard here mate
Southampton
New Orleans
St Kilda
Sucker for punishment I know

 

[sauce_head]

To suggest no other club would take him in the PSD is absolute nonsense. Any club with a pick before port would take NAS. Worst case, he signs doesn’t like it and tries to engineer a trade in 12 months time. Then the club gets 3 first rounders. Alternately he is stuck there on his contract terms. Every club in the comp would take that chance, if they had the cap available (which the bottom clubs do) The PSD is quite simply not going to happen.

Luke Ball went at pick 30. He got to Collingwood because he nominated them and the terms were favourable. Another club is not going to take NAS on the same basis. If Port finish below us on the ladder then they can leverage this point in trade negotiations, assuming he wants to go there which is far from established.

 

[Yawkey way]

In other news. meltdown on the Carlton board might be worth reading.

This will be funny.

 

[stavro#4]

Luke Ball went at pick 30. He got to Collingwood because he nominated them and the terms were favourable. Another club is not going to take NAS on the same basis. If Port finish below us on the ladder then they can leverage this point in trade negotiations, assuming he wants to go there which is far from established.

Melbourne wanted Ball and were spooked because he wouldn’t talk with them.

Again, Nas is a very different sports car here. If he hits either draft. He is gone in the top 3 picks.

 

[Sully111]

Imagine if Nas nominated Adelaide... we couldn't work out a deal... he went to the PSD.... and Port took him... getting their man and pissing off their arch enemy.

 

[billings2paddy]

Luke Ball went at pick 30. He got to Collingwood because he nominated them and the terms were favourable. Another club is not going to take NAS on the same basis. If Port finish below us on the ladder then they can leverage this point in trade negotiations, assuming he wants to go there which is far from established.

Easy fix don't let port finish below us

 

[Yawkey way]

My boy stavros is the type of guy to have $50 on Nas leaving and $50 on Nas staying.

Whichever way it goes he will burn the losing ticket and only show off the winning on on IG

It’s a win win

 

[Sainter62]

Another Southampton and St Kilda fan? Never thought I would see the day up the saints x2!

that's me too

 

[AaronSCHQ]

Not much of an update, and could be a bit of just guess work mixed with some things being heard. But Theo Doropoulos on MMM has reported on JB & Billy show that it’s still up in the air with 3 clubs involved.

He said (paraphrased):
-Adelaide in it but would be third in the race
-Port would be slightly ahead of Adelaide
-St.Kilda would still be confident they’re at the front of the pack
-Nas himself doesn’t know what he’s doing
-Signature held off as stocks continue to rise each week

As I said, could be just made up from the vibe or this could be directly from sources.

 

[Dr Spaceman]

In other news. meltdown on the Carlton board might be worth reading.

But they’re getting Hinkers as well so all good

 

[Linton Street Saint]

I think something that hasn't really been taken into consideration up until this point is the AFL having final say on trades.

With the rattling of cage that Bassat and Lyon have done so far I strongly believe in the current landscape and public sentiment there is no way they allow anything to go through with the optics that we have been thoroughly screwed over by the vagaries of their own system.

They're if not anything else, self interested.

 

[Yawkey way]

How about we try and win some games instead of wanting to be the leading first nations team or whatever you want to call it , that means bugger all and as much as it gets you all wet I'm not sure Nas is all that concerned about it

I have no idea why we would want that or how you’d achieve it other than by pure chance. If you’re recruiting and drafting the best available which is surely the case then how does it happen.

 

[Holy Hunter Clark]

Do us a favour. Turn a mower on and stick your hands under it so you can’t type any more.
Cheers

Friday 12:30. I reckon go back near the ride on mowers again, that worked out pretty well last week

Your time to shine Mowman

 

[Captain Paddy]

Reckon that's a bit harsh.

100% of people should have seen through it.

I thought he was just having a laugh.

I know I'm on my own a bit because there's a "people should be able to post what they know" sentiment here, but people have just been making shit up. It's wild.

If people genuinely believed it then I've got some premium oxygen to sell them as well

 

[PoppedCorn]

the only thing tom morris can break is probably wind and even then he would shit himself

 

[SaintJunior]

In other news. meltdown on the Carlton board might be worth reading.

Fantastic news for the rest of the competition

 

[Captain Paddy]

So did people actually show up to training expecting an announcement?

The circle jerk had record numbers

 

[Saints TV]

So when there’s been zero leaks and the media knows absolutely nothing… key figures at the club are going to leak information to a fan podcast and general supporters at a function?

Absolutely, no brainer there. Bassdog where you at mate

 

[MUFASA12]

Just had a thought… I want silvagni to pack his bags at the same time as nas if he ends up leaving, his job is to manage the list and our best assets, clearly hasn’t.

 

[SainterinSydney]

Just had a thought… I want silvagni to pack his bags at the same time as nas if he ends up leaving, his job is to manage the list and our best assets, clearly hasn’t.

I think SOS will be out the door if he stuffs this up. RTB may even be finished with us and leave when his contract ends in 2027.