List Mgmt. 2025 List Management

[serial_thrilla]

 

[Johnny Dalmas]

As also someone who wants him, my read is completely different. Both parties are keen for the break-up and any public reasoning is rubbish. Pick 11 is actually overs going off the North board, we'd get some good salary (hes overpaid) chucked in and a pick back

Yes. I would start at #12 for Simpkin and #23.

Remember everyone North foolishly traded their first this year (currently #3) in 2024 and so right now they only enter the draft at #23. For a club in North's position that is terrible.

They need a mid-1st rounder like #12 way more than a midfielder they are pushing out of their midfield.

 

[Cobbler]

You should see the garbage he sends me in my dms.

Straight lie.

Just post it here for all to see?

 

[Madas]

Can easily get all 3 just between our first three picks with some change

They sound like the kind of trades Geelong would do
I like the sound of them
No one that’s overpriced and all just under the radar

 

[Lach72]

Yes. I would start at #12 for Simpkin and #23.

Remember everyone North foolishly traded their first this year (currently #3) in 2024 and so right now they only enter the draft at #23. For a club in North's position that is terrible.

They need a mid-1st rounder like #12 way more than a midfielder they are pushing out of their midfield.

North are pushing a midfielder out of their midfield…we have a better midfield than North

 

[Piggy Smalls]

NOD has been a very difficult player to get a handle on as to his trajectory towards becoming a solid AFL player.

He is capable of kicking a goal from the 50 metre arc at times and some very lack lustre stuff at other times.

Has had some injury concerns but he needs to get some consistency soon. It's hard to predict how his career is going to be over the next few seasons. At his best he is in our best team.

He always looks off balance and ungainly to me. I'm not sure his ceiling is much higher than the best he's already shown.

 

[Lach72]

He always looks off balance and ungainly to me. I'm not sure his ceiling is much higher than the best he's already shown.

Starting to feel that way.

He seems to be kicking with his ankle more these days. Spraying them everywhere.

I wouldn’t mind him getting some more time as an inside mid. He’s shown a little bit there

 

[Madas]

He always looks off balance and ungainly to me. I'm not sure his ceiling is much higher than the best he's already shown.

Need to weed out the hot and cold players and the ones that don’t stand up in big moments
Loved NOD a few years ago but his constant injuries and form recovery time aren’t fitting the window
Good depth though and he’s hungry for a chance

 

[what a game]

I won’t be surprised if Nod doesn’t end up at port this year ?

 

[Lach72]

I won’t be surprised if Nod doesn’t end up at port this year ?

Port have 27 and 46. Don’t think we could get 27 for him, hasn’t shown enough

 

[CaseySibosadoHOF]

I kinda rate that he's backing himself to compete for spots enough that he's not interested in getting free games for shit teams (North/Essendon). I thought they'd be more attractive prospects to him.

 

[Cobbler]

McVee - out of contract (~pick 42)
Jai Serong - out of contract. 10 games in 4 years (~pick 69 or an upgraded pick)
Simpkin - 4 years left (~pick 12 maybe future picks back our way)

This is what these guys ‘should’ cost.

McVee I can understand going for 32.

Serong shouldn’t be worth anything.

Simpkin, well he won’t come here, so no point really talking about him.

 

[Bud]

Simpkin is not very good.. another Will Brodie

17

Will Brodie

Age

27

Ht

190cm

Wt

89kg

Pos.

Mid

Career

Season

Last 5

D

19.0

5star

K

8.2

3star

HB

10.8

5star

M

3.1

3star

T

4.9

5star

CL

4.1

5star

D

14.0

3star

K

4.0

1star

HB

10.0

5star

M

3.0

3star

T

1.0

2star

CL

3.0

4star

D

13.8

4star

K

7.4

3star

HB

6.4

4star

M

3.2

4star

T

5.4

5star

CL

2.8

5star

.. no way a first rounder.. he is no Petracca

 

[Docker82]

Simpkin is not very good.. another Will Brodie.. no way a first rounder.. he is no Petracca

Another Will Brodie? What an absolute joke.

Solid B Grader at worst.

Brodie isn't even a C Grader

 

[Lach72]

Anyone got the points chart?

Gold Coast have 6, 7 (Flanders) 14, 17 and 34
They have Petracca to get in plus Uwland, Patterson likely top 5/10 and Addinsall top 20-30


We have 11, 32, 42, 51.

I’m wondering if Gold Coast can get Petracca for one of 6/7 and a future first would 11 be enough to get us 14 and 34? Would we want that?

 

[Docker82]

McVee - out of contract (~pick 42)
Jai Serong - out of contract. 10 games in 4 years (~pick 69 or an upgraded pick)
Simpkin - 4 years left (~pick 12 maybe future picks back our way)

This is what these guys ‘should’ cost.

McVee I can understand going for 32.

Serong shouldn’t be worth anything.

Simpkin, well he won’t come here, so no point really talking about him.

McVee should be worth pock 42?

He's a bloody good player who I'd have zero hesitation handing over pick 20 for if we actually had that selection.

Out of contract doesn't mean you can offer half the player's value. It means that Melbourne cant tell us to 'go get pick 20 or go **** yourselves'.

The trade drops to late 20s at worst given he's out of contract. Freo and Melbourne will work together for a fair deal - They'll be no screwing each other over.

 

[Dirty_banchez]

When the Simpkin to freo news going break ?

When Jammo or CTD post it. It sounds like Essendon are looking at him to replace Merrett.

 

[Docker82]

Anyone got the points chart?

Gold Coast have 6, 7 (Flanders) 14, 17 and 34
They have Petracca to get in plus Uwland, Patterson likely top 5/10 and Addinsall top 20-30


We have 11, 32, 42, 51.

I’m wondering if Gold Coast can get Petracca for one of 6/7 and a future first would 11 be enough to get us 14 and 34? Would we want that?

Struggling to see where you're going here tbh.

Care to explain the logic why we'd even consider this?

 

[Sherriff Incorporated]

McVee should be worth pock 42?

He's a bloody good player who I'd have zero hesitation handing over pick 20 for if we actually had that selection.

Out of contract doesn't mean you can offer half the player's value. It means that Melbourne cant tell us to 'go get pick 20 or go **** yourselves'.

The trade drops to late 20s at worst given he's out of contract. Freo and Melbourne will work together for a fair deal - They'll be no screwing each other over.

McVee's worth our second and one of our thirds easily in my opinion.

 

[Lach72]

Struggling to see where you're going here tbh.

Care to explain the logic why we'd even consider this?

Gives us that bit more for McVee and /or an extra pick for Rodriguez.

 

[BettercallSaul]

When Jammo or CTD post it. It sounds like Essendon are looking at him to replace Merrett.

I was wondering if this might happen especially with Brad Scott being his former coach?

 

[Piggy Smalls]

Serong is worth about the same in trade as Reidy IMO. Has Reidy nominated a club? Straight swap?

 

[Cobbler]

Anyone got the points chart?

Gold Coast have 6, 7 (Flanders) 14, 17 and 34
They have Petracca to get in plus Uwland, Patterson likely top 5/10 and Addinsall top 20-30


We have 11, 32, 42, 51.

I’m wondering if Gold Coast can get Petracca for one of 6/7 and a future first would 11 be enough to get us 14 and 34? Would we want that?

179 points in GCs favour.

Not sure that’s enough for them to consider.

I’d like to move pick 12 in some way.

There’s not much I find interesting in this years draft. Was keen on Farrow but McVee now covers that positional need. No guarantee we’d get him at 12 too.

 

[CaptainWorpedo]

Out-of-contract Hawks young gun makes call on new AFL home amid five-club race

Out-of-contract young gun makes call on new AFL home amid five-club race

www.foxsports.com.au

Seems down to Sydney or Freo for Jai. The Fox article indicates Hawks won’t stand in his way. Looks most likely that a trade for primary list spot will be required. A later pick - prob one we receive from either Brodie or Reidy would get the job done.

So no he won’t be at Hawthorn next year.

Hawks don’t normally stand in a players away, especially when they’re not best 22 or 23 now.

We gave Hilly away to you guys back in the day.

I hope Jai does well where ever he goes seems like a great fella.

 

[Lach72]

179 points in GCs favour.

Not sure that’s enough for them to consider.

I’d like to move pick 12 in some way.

There’s not much I find interesting in this years draft. Was keen on Farrow but McVee now covers that positional need. No guarantee we’d get him at 12 too.

Yeah it’s interesting.

I’d Gold Coast are desperate for points and get a second round this year somehow should we do this?

12 for that Gold Coast second and Future first?

Shift one for McVee. Take Rodriguez or similar with the other?

They have no academy kids next year.

We could then have two firsts next year.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Serong is worth about the same in trade as Reidy IMO. Has Reidy nominated a club? Straight swap?

Serong is much better than Reidy, he'll cost a little bit more.