List Mgmt. 2025 List Management

[serial_thrilla]

 

[rgauci]

I know it's all posturing and the deal for ah chee to ADE will get done. But would you give pick 20 for him? I think I would.

Absolutely not, he’s a fringe / role player. Save the salary cap coin for a difference maker.

 

[BurnedScones]

If only we could be losing all game and then hit our finisher out of nowhere.

We did have quite a lot of John Cena booking this year actually

 

[Taylor]

I'd rather take the first round pick to the draft, take Rodriguez at that pick #20 and watch Essendon melt over not being able to pick him at the very next pick.

 

[Lach72]

Saints royally ****ed that kid.

He’s now having to sign a deal at GWS on less money because they’ve adjusted their payments AND brought in Laverde.

Apparently the deal GWS can give Aleer is 200-250k.

So it’s safe to say the Saints have ****ed the kid to the tune of about 1-1.5 million bucks over the life of the deal.

That’s disgusting

 

[2big2strom]

Absolutely not, he’s a fringe / role player. Save the salary cap coin for a difference maker.

I forgot about the salary aspect of it, good point. He's definitely better than a fringe player though

 

[Purple Suit]

Finally a big bodied mid.

 

[Paracleet]

I forgot about the salary aspect of it, good point. He's definitely better than a fringe player though

'Better than a fringe player' doesn't scream giving up a pick that high justifcation to me. The michael prior rule applies here.

 

[freo_leo29]

If i was north I wouldn't have pulled out til the trade period was over


Should be taking him for free in the psd on like 500k

They won't cop the blame because it came up late

 

[Taylor]

Maybe North have run out of money?

 

[Lach72]

Maybe North have run out of money?

That’s just fantastic…the fact that they are so full of spuds and could nbe in that position is amusing to say the least

 

[kuhni]

Saints royally ****ed that kid.

He’s now having to sign a deal at GWS on less money because they’ve adjusted their payments AND brought in Laverde.

Apparently the deal GWS can give Aleer is 200-250k.

So it’s safe to say the Saints have ****ed the kid to the tune of about 1-1.5 million bucks over the life of the deal.

That’s disgusting

Why don't the roos or Bulldogs want him? They have no KPDs and he is decent.

 

[2big2strom]

'Better than a fringe player' doesn't scream giving up a pick that high justifcation to me. The michael prior rule applies here.

yeah fair enough, he is also 28 already. I think I'm just wanting some sweet dopamine hit but realistically, I am very happy overall with our list profile and keeping the boys together

 

[Taylor]

That’s just fantastic…the fact that they are so full of spuds and could nbe in that position is amusing to say the least

They might have signed LDU with a massive front loaded bonus in 2026 to get him across the line and now can't find a spare $500k to bring in a player for next year without backloading their deal - and players don't like back ended deals at new clubs.

More so after Collingwood shifted players signed to them when the bill came around.

 

[Purple Suit]

They might have signed LDU with a massive front loaded bonus in 2026 to get him across the line and now can't find a spare $500k to bring in a player for next year without backloading their deal - and players don't like back ended deals at new clubs.

More so after Collingwood shifted players signed to them when the bill came around.

North should have banked cash like Saints did. They have been terrible for the longest time out of anybody so I would be shocked if they can't afford a player. Wanting to spend the money on him is a different scenario.

 

[Taylor]

Callum Ah Chee

4

Callum Ah Chee

Age

28

Ht

182cm

Wt

80kg

Pos.

Fwd

Career

Season

Last 5

D

12.8

3star

K

7.0

3star

HB

5.9

4star

M

3.0

3star

T

2.9

4star

G

0.5

3star

D

11.1

3star

K

7.7

3star

HB

3.4

2star

M

3.1

3star

T

2.7

4star

G

0.1

3star

D

9.4

3star

K

4.4

2star

HB

5.0

4star

M

2.4

3star

T

3.0

5star

G

0.8

4star

is the Lion's;
8th player for score involvements (4.8)/ 8th player for Freo is Voss (5.2)
5th for shots at goal (2.3)/ 5th player for Freo is Amiss (2.5)
8th in goals per game (0.9)/ 8th player for Freo is Dudley (0.9)
=2nd in goal assists per game (0.8)/ =2nd for Freo is Reidy/Reid (1/0.9)

He'd be very useful in terms of team scoring by the look of it.

Murphy Reid is arguably a similar style player, similar impact but far more growth.

I think we can move Reid into a more involvement role and slot in a young player with good disposal and use who can win their own ball and run all day.

 

[eastfreo75]

Callum Ah Chee is the Lion's;
8th player for score involvements (4.8)/ 8th player for Freo is Voss (5.2)
5th for shots at goal (2.3)/ 5th player for Freo is Amiss (2.5)
8th in goals per game (0.9)/ 8th player for Freo is Dudley (0.9)
=2nd in goal assists per game (0.8)/ =2nd for Freo is Reidy/Reid (1/0.9)

He'd be very useful in terms of team scoring by the look of it.

Murphy Reid is arguably a similar style player, similar impact but far more growth.

I think we can move Reid into a more involvement role and slot in a young player with good disposal and use who can win their own ball and run all day.

Pretty average.

 

[Taylor]

Pretty average.

I think it shows the contribution to scoring of the Lions midfield over ours.

When listing the Fremantle and Lions mids by average goals scored, Brisbane hold 7/10 of the top. Bolton at 2, Young at 3, Brayshaw at 9.

Sum of the averages of the top ten:

Brisbane 4.4 (0.63 per player)
Freo 2.3 (0.76 per player)

They overwhelm us with contributors, and our second best barely played.

 

[Lach72]

Saints royally ****ed that kid.

He’s now having to sign a deal at GWS on less money because they’ve adjusted their payments AND brought in Laverde.

Apparently the deal GWS can give Aleer is 200-250k.

So it’s safe to say the Saints have ****ed the kid to the tune of about 1-1.5 million bucks over the life of the deal.

That’s disgusting

Even more so that they brought in Liam Ryan and that crab Silvagni.

 

[Alfonz]

Absolutely not, he’s a fringe / role player. Save the salary cap coin for a difference maker.

Harsh. Ah Chee kicked 10 goals in the 2024 finals campaign and was voted internally by Brisbane as their joint player of the finals. Wasn't quite as good this year and played a different role on the wing, but he had very solid games in the prelim and GF and would have been somewhere around the 10-12th best player across those final 2 games. Proven track record in big finals and I would pay pick 20 for him without thinking of the salary cap ramifications (which is a very valid point).

On top of the salary, his age is also a tad awkward at 28. Could be fine, but I have a feeling we might need a couple of years of prelim level output before going all the way, and by then he is 30+ and Rivers/Warner are FA targets end of 2027.

 

[go_the_dockers]

Harsh. Ah Chee kicked 10 goals in the 2024 finals campaign and was voted internally by Brisbane as their joint player of the finals. Wasn't quite as good this year and played a different role on the wing, but he had very solid games in the prelim and GF and would have been somewhere around the 10-12th best player across those final 2 games. Proven track record in big finals and I would pay pick 20 for him without thinking of the salary cap ramifications (which is a very valid point).

On top of the salary, his age is also a tad awkward at 28. Could be fine, but I have a feeling we might need a couple of years of prelim level output before going all the way, and by then he is 30+ and Rivers/Warner are FA targets end of 2027.

I think he is 15th to 20th player on Brisbane list. I think he is a good role player.

A future 2nd is pretty close to fair value.

 

[Taylor]

Just to throw that wasp nest into the living room..

 

[David Bubb]

 

[go_the_dockers]

Just to throw that wasp nest into the living room..

Maybe get him and hollands over as train on players?

They could even stay together to save cash What could go wrong

Seriously, he is an extremely talented player. Are we mature enough off field to take risks on players like this?

 

[go_the_dockers]

That looks like a pretty good offer to me.

 

[go_the_dockers]

Haha