2025 Rolling ALL-Australian Team

JHF1870 · May 10, 2025

Mr Meow said:
I cany carry 4 tall forwards in my team. We are slow enough as it is.

I think Treacey, Thilthorpe, Gunston, Elliot, Dangerfield, Greene with Higgins on bench

Mr Meow · May 10, 2025

JHF1870 said:
I think Treacey, Thilthorpe, Gunston, Elliot, Dangerfield, Greene with Higgins on bench

It was an over 30s team.

JHF1870 · May 10, 2025

Mr Meow said:
It was an over 30s team.

Lol. Didnt notice

WalshistheGOAT · May 11, 2025

6 games 25 goals

JHF1870 · May 11, 2025

WalshistheGOAT said:
6 games 25 goals

Doesn't make the cut of 75% games

JHF1870 · May 11, 2025

Here's my forward list, with Hipwood +2 goals so far

Extrapolating this, it's going to be hard to pick the 2-3 players. I'm inclined to think 2 key talls is all you can take, with one on the bench.

I'd be happy with King, Hogan and Thilthorpe.

Player	Total1	Avg	Goal	M.50	S.INV	C MArk
Ben King	307.00	38.38	27	28	47	11
Jesse Hogan	323.50	53.92	25	25	45	13
Riley Thilthorpe	436.50	48.50	23	27	61	16
Josh Treacy	366.50	40.72	22	24	56	15
Darcy Fogarty	301.00	37.63	21	20	47	8
Nick Larkey	286.50	35.81	20	20	48	7
Mitch Georgiades	355.50	39.50	20	31	59	14
Jeremy Cameron	404.50	44.94	20	19	65	9
Charlie Curnow	303.50	37.94	18	20	45	14
Mabior Chol	321.00	35.67	17	21	48	16
Taylor Walker	382.00	42.44	17	15	62	11
Eric Hipwood	297.50	37.19	16	18	42	5

Small Forwards, I'd take Greene, Dangerfield and Elliot, maybe Zac Bailey on the bench

Row Labels	Average of Goals	Sum of Total	Average of Total2
Toby Greene	1.89	447	49.67
Patrick Dangerfield	1.89	412	45.78
Ben Keays	1.78	387	43.00
Jamie Elliott	2.44	381.5	42.39
Shai Bolton	1.13	377	47.13
Zac Bailey	1.88	348	43.50
Rhylee West	1.56	345.5	38.39
Kade Chandler	1.00	342.5	38.06
Daniel Rioli	0.63	338.5	42.31
Sam Powell-Pepper	1.33	329.5	36.61

hawkman · May 11, 2025

JHF1870 said:
Here's my forward list, with Hipwood +2 goals so far

Extrapolating this, it's going to be hard to pick the 2-3 players. I'm inclined to think 2 key talls is all you can take, with one on the bench.

I'd be happy with King, Hogan and Thilthorpe.

Player Total1 Avg Goal M.50 S.INV C MArk
Ben King
307.00
38.38
27
28
47
11
Jesse Hogan
323.50
53.92
25
25
45
13
Riley Thilthorpe
436.50
48.50
23
27
61
16
Josh Treacy
366.50
40.72
22
24
56
15
Darcy Fogarty
301.00
37.63
21
20
47
8
Nick Larkey
286.50
35.81
20
20
48
7
Mitch Georgiades
355.50
39.50
20
31
59
14
Jeremy Cameron
404.50
44.94
20
19
65
9
Charlie Curnow
303.50
37.94
18
20
45
14
Mabior Chol
321.00
35.67
17
21
48
16
Taylor Walker
382.00
42.44
17
15
62
11
Eric Hipwood
297.50
37.19
16
18
42
5

Small Forwards, I'd take Greene, Dangerfield and Elliot, maybe Zac Bailey on the bench

Row Labels Average of Goals Sum of Total Average of Total2
Toby Greene
1.89
447
49.67
Patrick Dangerfield
1.89
412
45.78
Ben Keays
1.78
387
43.00
Jamie Elliott
2.44
381.5
42.39
Shai Bolton
1.13
377
47.13
Zac Bailey
1.88
348
43.50
Rhylee West
1.56
345.5
38.39
Kade Chandler
1.00
342.5
38.06
Daniel Rioli
0.63
338.5
42.31
Sam Powell-Pepper
1.33
329.5
36.61

Gunston?

crows dude · May 11, 2025

Worrell Thilthorpe Dawson Rankine from crows at this stage

JHF1870 · May 11, 2025

hawkman said:
Gunston?

Ill look later. Must have missed his name on my filters.

RCAB · May 11, 2025

JHF1870 said:
Doesn't make the cut of 75% games

What a stupid rule.

JHF1870 · May 11, 2025

RCAB said:
What a stupid rule.

IT was a joke

Progressive Aggresion · May 11, 2025

I've done full squads the last few times but I think this time I will put together my first team for the year so far:

FB - Nick Haynes (CAR) - Jacob Weitering (CAR) - Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera (STK)

HB - Dayne Zorko (BRI) - Sam Taylor (GWS) - Connor Rozee (POR)

C - Andrew Brayshaw (FRE) - Zach Merrett (ESS) - Ed Richards (WBD)

FOL - Max Gawn (MEL) - Bailey Smith (GEL) - Nick Daicos (COL)

HF - Jack Higgins (STK) - Jesse Hogan (GWS) - Patrick Dangerfield (GEL)

FF - Jamie Elliot (COL) - Ben King (GCS) - Riley Thilthorpe (ADE)

INT - George Hewett (CAR) - Daniel Rioli (GCS) - Matthew Kennedy (WBD) - Jack Gunston (HAW)

Saintsone · May 11, 2025

ItsAllAboutMe said:
B - Weitering, Taylor, Wilkie
HB- Nasiah, Moore, Weddle
C- Bailey Smith, Rowell, Ed Richards
HF- Rankine, Cameron, Higgins
F- Watson, King, Thilthorpe
R-TDK, Neale, Daicos

I - Brayshaw, Anderson, Dangerfield, Libba, Sidebottom..

Watson.?. Thought Jobe had retired. Surely you can’t mean the kid that plays at Hawthorn

Rustin Cohle · May 11, 2025

Progressive Aggresion said:
FB - Nick Haynes (CAR)

He’s had like three good games. People were basically saying he should retire after the first month of the season he was that bad.

Good on him for finding some form but putting him in the AA team is insane. There’s probably 20 defenders more worthy.

TennisPlayerAndy · May 11, 2025

Curtis’ bullshit suspension has him completely forgotten.

Averaging 2.6 goals a game….

Progressive Aggresion · May 11, 2025

Rustin Cohle said:
He’s had like three good games. People were basically saying he should retire after the first month of the season he was that bad.

Good on him for finding some form but putting him in the AA team is insane. There’s probably 20 defenders more worthy.

Callum Wilkie and Josh Weddle would be others that could easily be swapped in for the same position but I am admittedly biased to recent form at times.
It's also the fact that Haynes leads the league for marks and has more intercept possessions than the other 2 I mentioned.

JHF1870 · May 11, 2025

TennisPlayerAndy said:
Curtis’ bullshit suspension has him completely forgotten.

Averaging 2.6 goals a game….

He needed to punch his opponent

raskolnikov · May 12, 2025

Progressive Aggresion said:
I've done full squads the last few times but I think this time I will put together my first team for the year so far:

FB - Nick Haynes (CAR) - Jacob Weitering (CAR) - Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera (STK)

HB - Dayne Zorko (BRI) - Sam Taylor (GWS) - Connor Rozee (POR)

C - Andrew Brayshaw (FRE) - Zach Merrett (ESS) - Ed Richards (WBD)

FOL - Max Gawn (MEL) - Bailey Smith (GEL) - Nick Daicos (COL)

HF - Jack Higgins (STK) - Jesse Hogan (GWS) - Patrick Dangerfield (GEL)

FF - Jamie Elliot (COL) - Ben King (GCS) - Riley Thilthorpe (ADE)

INT - George Hewett (CAR) - Daniel Rioli (GCS) - Matthew Kennedy (WBD) - Jack Gunston (HAW)

The Nick Haynes whose head Carlton supporters have been calling for all year?

Fadge · May 12, 2025

raskolnikov said:
The Nick Haynes whose head Carlton supporters have been calling for all year?

Nah, he's good now...

SSSSSS · May 12, 2025

Skipper_ said:
B: Michalanney - Taylor - Idun
HB Ash - Weitering - Wanganeen-Milera
C: Crisp - Brayshaw - Dempsey
HF: Humphrey - Cameron - Neal-Bullen
F: Dangerfield - Thilthorpe - Higgins
R: Xerri - Richards - Merrett
I/C: Blakey - Smith - Daicos - Bailey

Cameron of the Jeremy or Charlie variety are nowhere near AA form at the moment.

Sector 7G · May 12, 2025

raskolnikov said:
The Nick Haynes whose head Carlton supporters have been calling for all year?

Not all year - just after round 1 and 2. Has been excellent since then.

I wouldn't have him in my AA team yet.

Juddernaut08 · May 12, 2025

Rustin Cohle said:
He’s had like three good games. People were basically saying he should retire after the first month of the season he was that bad.

Good on him for finding some form but putting him in the AA team is insane. There’s probably 20 defenders more worthy.

Blues fan here - and this is 100% accurate.

He's had 3 blinders, but started very poorly. If he's truly shaken off the rust and can both stay fit and in this form, he'll come into consideration by around round 13 or so.

WalshistheGOAT · May 12, 2025

Silvagni has had a better season than Haynes. Neither would be in the team and very likely not the squad either.

Pistol Night · May 12, 2025

WalshistheGOAT said:
Silvagni has had a better season than Haynes. Neither would be in the team and very likely not the squad either.

Credit where it’s due. Haynes has wound back the clock after looking cooked early on

Daka · May 12, 2025

Fadge said:
Nah, he's good now...

Nick Vlastuin everyday over Haynes.

Rd 15 Reviews + Club Forums »

Rd 16 + Club Forums »

2025 Rolling ALL-Australian Team

Premium Platinum

Brownlow Medallist

Premium Platinum

Brownlow Medallist

Premium Platinum

Premium Platinum

Hall of Famer

Norm Smith Medallist

Premium Platinum

Premiership Player

Premium Platinum

All Australian

Team Captain

Flat Circle

Game #6 Klay

All Australian

Premium Platinum

Hall of Famer

Hall of Famer

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Premium Platinum

2025 Rolling ALL-Australian Team

Similar threads

Log In or Create New Account