Trades 2025 Round 11 Trades

[amazingjoshy]

Are people holding JHF or MaCrae if only trading 1 this week?

I've traded Macrae currently (to Bolton) and held JHF. May end up holding both yet though

 

[Jiska]

Are people holding JHF or MaCrae if only trading 1 this week?

I’m holding Macrae. I don’t have JHF but if I did I’d probably hold as well. We’re about to enter 5 weeks of best 18 so that makes it easier to hold.

 

[SC fish]

Are people holding JHF or MaCrae if only trading 1 this week?

I'm turfing both, to strengthen my team over the next few weeks

 

[No eye deer]

Got about 20 minutes to decide if I want Dawson or Green.
Dawson run home is tempting, but been burnt before
Green good for 105,110 every week, consistent

 

[Kedford]

Got about 20 minutes to decide if I want Dawson or Green.
Dawson run home is tempting, but been burnt before
Green good for 105,110 every week, consistent

I’ve gone Green, GWS have the best run home for inside mids according to DFS. Adelaide surprisingly according to the data have a tough run.

 

[Jiska]

Got about 20 minutes to decide if I want Dawson or Green.
Dawson run home is tempting, but been burnt before
Green good for 105,110 every week, consistent

Touk, Dunks, Anderson all the same price and better options IMO.

 

[No eye deer]

Touk, Dunks, Anderson all the same price and better options IMO.

Got Dunks.
Having trouble splitting the rest.
Probably just stick with Green.

 

[timtimtim]

Tom Green

12

Tom Green

Age

25

Ht

192cm

Wt

92kg

Pos.

Mid

Career

Season

Last 5

D

11.5

3star

K

4.3

2star

HB

7.3

5star

M

1.8

2star

T

2.3

4star

CL

2.8

4star

D

11.5

3star

K

4.3

2star

HB

7.3

4star

M

1.8

2star

T

2.3

3star

CL

2.8

4star

D

11.5

3star

K

4.3

2star

HB

7.3

5star

M

1.8

2star

T

2.3

4star

CL

2.8

5star

or Serong?

Both good draw coming up, byes are covered either way

Do we reckon Serong bounces back? 30K cheaper

 

[BOMBERBLITZ]

Tom Green or Serong?

Both good draw coming up, byes are covered either way

Do we reckon Serong bounces back? 30K cheaper

I think Serong is the best value.

 

[Scythe]

So, uh, about that.

Think I'm trading Macrae lol.

What changed your mind?

Impulse. Haven't made up my mind for sure yet, but seeing the percentages of the top teams trading him out has made me a bit edgy about it (plus Serong is great value at 529k for a replacement).

That, and Baz potentially missing next week could mean trouble with the bye if I hold Macrae.

Changed my mind again, holding Macrae lol

 

[Pure_Ownage]

In the end went Callaghan Bice Cleary for Sinclair Bolton Simpson.

Turf Roberts and Stone for bont and a rookie post bye.
I think I'll hold jhf and macrae this week and only trade them next week if prognosis looks bad.

 

[MrChristo]

I'm probably being short sighted, but pretty sure I'm set on Macrae to Jackson.

- Macrae is a potential worry as it is ( and I know others will disagree), but 4 sub 80 games in the last 6... Even if Hodor makes a miraculous recovery, Jackson still likely matches Macrae from here.

- Jackson is a decent VC shout this week.

- I'd have to field Spargo... [shudder]...for probably 2 weeks.

 

[Deliverance]

Are people holding JHF or MaCrae if only trading 1 this week?

Whatever I do will be wrong. This season:
Kept oliver, traded Petracca
Keep Serong, disaster
Trade Cerra out, he becomes a magician
Trade daicos in he turns to shit
Trade Miller in for 100 average
Held Roberts
Traded Flynn when he got dropped
Traded Humphrey out before his monster score
Went early on the rookie Hayes
Amongst other minor issues

I'm keeping both FYI, I suggest you Trade.

 

[EA100]

Macrae > Ash
Cleary > Bolton
Hewett > Simpson


Macrae > Ash
Bice > Noble
Hewett > Simpson

Which one you boys reckon? I’m so stumped. Noble can be any premium up to 543k.. so I’m short of Anderson grrr

 

[Jiska]

View attachment 2323601
Macrae > Ash
Cleary > Bolton
Hewett > Simpson

View attachment 2323602
Macrae > Ash
Bice > Noble
Hewett > Simpson

Which one you boys reckon? I’m so stumped. Noble can be any premium up to 543k.. so I’m short of Anderson grrr

How do you turn on dark mode?

Get Serong.

 

[EA100]

How do you turn on dark mode?

Get Serong.

It’s an extension I found through google chrome!

 

[JuddgementDay]

Whatever I do will be wrong. This season:
Kept oliver, traded Petracca
Keep Serong, disaster
Trade Cerra out, he becomes a magician
Trade daicos in he turns to shit
Trade Miller in for 100 average
Held Roberts
Traded Flynn when he got dropped
Traded Humphrey out before his monster score
Went early on the rookie Hayes
Amongst other minor issues

I'm keeping both FYI, I suggest you Trade.

Most of us are having that type of year - so whilst everyone is getting in Simpson for cash gen - I’m getting in Heeney

I’m so far back ranking wise, so why not play a bit differently hey

 

[Pure_Ownage]

I'm probably being short sighted, but pretty sure I'm set on Macrae to Jackson.

- Macrae is a potential worry as it is ( and I know others will disagree), but 4 sub 80 games in the last 6... Even if Hodor makes a miraculous recovery, Jackson still likely matches Macrae from here.

- Jackson is a decent VC shout this week.

- I'd have to field Spargo... [shudder]...for probably 2 weeks.

Jackson's scoring is entirely dependent on if Darcy plays though. I would trade macrae but not to Jackson I'd pick someone like rankine or Warner or heaven forbid Bolton if you don't have him. Jackson is only value if no hodor.

 

[Pure_Ownage]

View attachment 2323601
Macrae > Ash
Cleary > Bolton
Hewett > Simpson

View attachment 2323602
Macrae > Ash
Bice > Noble
Hewett > Simpson

Which one you boys reckon? I’m so stumped. Noble can be any premium up to 543k.. so I’m short of Anderson grrr

I like noble but why not Jordan Clark instead?

 

[Plugger35]

My trades locked and loaded with Cleary > Simpson and Max Hall > Bolton

Feel bad slaughtering one of my best cash cows Hall but the time had come.

 

[Deliverance]

Most of us are having that type of year - so whilst everyone is getting in Simpson for cash gen - I’m getting in Heeney

I’m so far back ranking wise, so why not play a bit differently hey

I'd imagine anyone outside the top 10k would have plenty of tough breaks. Gets to that point eventually. I've brought in PODs last few trades for fun.

 

[JuddgementDay]

I'd imagine anyone outside the top 10k would have plenty of tough breaks. Gets to that point eventually. I've brought in PODs last few trades for fun.

Vive La difference!

 

[SC fish]

Just got home has new recruit BolTON tonned up yet?

 

[jumperfan]

Just got home has new recruit BolTON tonned up yet?

He’s outscoring Simpson at least

 

[swindle]

Are people holding JHF or MaCrae if only trading 1 this week?

My trades with both, FYI I think holding Macrae over JHF is probably smarter but wanted to go against the crowd plus gave me a few a more $ (allowed both premo's below);