Trades 2025 Round 16 Trades

[toxic]

Who to keep

Carroll or Fonti??

Cant believe Carroll was dropped, he ran, he kicked well on his left. Voss is tanking and they'll lose by 10+ goals tonight - SUFFER to them

I'm leaning to keeping Fonti, it's only for Def cover

 

[AN1611]

Tossing up between the two sets of trades and would love some help:

Bolton, Carroll and Johnson to Darcy, Mills and Liddy

Neale, Carrol and Keeler to JHF/Darcy, Mills and Butler

Both leaves me with 22 "premos" and 4 trades

 

[BOMBERBLITZ]

Not sure I understand the urgency to trade Helmet. Already had his bye, five-round average of 97.8 (11th amongst all forwards), still getting kick-ins and his role appears secure, 11th highest average and 7th highest total points amongst all forwards on the season.

Like, if you were going up to a guaranteed 110+ guy I'd get it, but feels a bit unnecessarily sideways. If you've got trades to burn, I'd probably be bye-flipping somebody instead.

Honestly I never considered little Helmet a "keeper".

Yes he's been great from an SC scoring prospective. Well and truly exceeded expectations...

He's mad $208.7K and now has a breakeven of 110 at his Season PEAK price, so surely starts losing cash.

Sam Darcy (FOMO) looks more of an unstoppable scoring threat and has a low breakeven of only 19 so it's now or never...

Yes I have the trades (13) and trading Caleb to Darcy nets a bit of cash to also enable Kako to Macrae...

This Bye is OK for me with 22 playing (19 Premos)

I do appreciate the input and hope it doesn't backfire!

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Who to keep

Carroll or Fonti??

Cant believe Carroll was dropped, he ran, he kicked well on his left. Voss is tanking and they'll lose by 10+ goals tonight - SUFFER to them

I'm leaning to keeping Fonti, it's only for Def cover

Dropping a few fringe players won't do anything, Voss is a dead man walking.

Fonti playing so best keep him I guess.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Tossing up between the two sets of trades and would love some help:

Bolton, Carroll and Johnson to Darcy, Mills and Liddy

Neale, Carrol and Keeler to JHF/Darcy, Mills and Butler

Both leaves me with 22 "premos" and 4 trades

Butler is probably a better rookie, handy forward cover too.

 

[Zim^zuM]

Trading Roberts and Bolton out. Hall to Liddy to unlock cash. Have 23 non rookie starters before I trade. 3 trades will leave me with 4 left. Have a boost still somehow.

NWM/Darcy vs Mills/Anderson?

I could do 4 trades but feel uneasy being left with 3. But I could trade pedlar to may and get Anderson in instead of Darcy and still get NWM instead of Mills.

 

[EA100]

Option 1: Carroll & Bolton > McCarthy & Darcy


Option 2: Carroll, Clarke & Johnson > McCarthy, Liddy & Darcy

Torn between these two options atm..

 

['51 Bewick]

10 trades left and need to replace Bice plus add a premo Flex. Not sure which way to go.
I'll probably use 3 trades this week to get S. Darcy or JHF or J. Macrae to replace Bice as my Flex.
Then 2 Rookie downgrades and 1 Rookie upgrade to get a decent defender.
That will leave me 4 trades for injuries. It would be much easier if Bice found form.

 

[BOMBERBLITZ]

Seems JHF VS Macrae is a big dilemma for many this week...

 

[JT_the_Man]

Sims to Blakiston, simply a cash play.

Have 19 playing, still need to bring in McCarthy. Butler or Liddy worthwhile / have JS?

 

[Faz 2000]

Seems JHF VS Macrae is a big dilemma for many this week...

Thinking of abandoning hope with Lachie Neale and getting both because I can't decide which one is right. Does fix/finish my forward line nicely.

 

[Pathetic Pittman]

I could do 4 trades but feel uneasy being left with 3.

 

[JT_the_Man]

Honestly tempted to go Campo to Liddy for the marginal cash gain and cover.

 

[No eye deer]

I'm torn between Liddy and Allan.
Allan great with his DPP, but won't be making any cash in a hurry. Sub risk, peanut coach.
Liddy with a few good games could make a hundred grand and help to try and finance the elusive Flex player.
Bench is
Clark, Gray
______ Kako, Johnson
Boyd
Pedlar, Simpson.
McCarthy Flex. Completed side (Sort of...) 73K in the kitty. 8 trades after trading.
Also thinking about Pedlar to Butler.
Nelso, Port fans, Do we think Liddy will string a few together?

 

[Test Tickle]

I'm torn between Liddy and Allan.
Allan great with his DPP, but won't be making any cash in a hurry. Sub risk, peanut coach.
Liddy with a few good games could make a hundred grand and help to try and finance the elusive Flex player.
Bench is
Clark, Gray
______ Kako, Johnson
Boyd
Pedlar, Simpson.
McCarthy Flex. Completed side (Sort of...) 73K in the kitty. 8 trades after trading.
Also thinking about Pedlar to Butler.
Nelso, Port fans, Do we think Liddy will string a few together?

Liddy is in Ports best 23.

 

[Macka1203]

still don’t know whether to trade bergman, whitfield or roberts

 

[Nelso]

I'm torn between Liddy and Allan.
Allan great with his DPP, but won't be making any cash in a hurry. Sub risk, peanut coach.
Liddy with a few good games could make a hundred grand and help to try and finance the elusive Flex player.
Bench is
Clark, Gray
______ Kako, Johnson
Boyd
Pedlar, Simpson.
McCarthy Flex. Completed side (Sort of...) 73K in the kitty. 8 trades after trading.
Also thinking about Pedlar to Butler.
Nelso, Port fans, Do we think Liddy will string a few together?

Liddy should get a decent run at it.

Not going to set the world on fire but he is a better option than serial underachievers like Mead.

 

[keithrichards]

Brings me to full premo and 6 trades left.

No bont however



EDIT - might grab Liddy this week and May next

 

[Macka1203]

View attachment 2352277
still don’t know whether to trade bergman, whitfield or roberts

Bergman now named in the followers. gonna roll the dice. have enough trades and money to sideways to whitfield anyways next week if it goes pear shaped

 

[Faz 2000]

I’ve boosted to go…

Neale, Carroll, Gray, Kako
for
Macrae, Hornet, McCarthy, Butler

I’m still not at a full side. Sigh. But some trades to go.

 

[crowsarethebest]

JHF or Darcy?

 

[No eye deer]

Liddy is in Ports best 23.

Liddy should get a decent run at it.

Not going to set the world on fire but he is a better option than serial underachievers like Mead.

 

[Crimson Azure]

Will Sam Butler keep getting games? Or Ramsden?

 

[SC fish]

Boxshall still not named seals his fate. Hello McCarthy

 

[team_dog]

Can’t decide between which rookie liddy or Butler