Trades 2025 Round 16 Trades

[Crimson Azure]

Can’t decide between which rookie liddy or Butler

I just took Liddy but am thinking of Butler too as both named on field but don't know if Butler will get an extended run.

 

[True Blue Saint]

Dewar being out is annoying. Was making nice $$ and on track to be a comfortable upgrade in the Flex for me

 

[team_dog]

I just took Liddy but am thinking of Butler too as both named on field but don't know if Butler will get an extended run.

I was thinking that to with butler with hawks depth, liddy less competition 20 min to decide

 

[Pathetic Pittman]

Bergman now named in the followers. gonna roll the dice. have enough trades and money to sideways to whitfield anyways next week if it goes pear shaped

good call

 

[Kadog]

Gonna convert Neale into Mills and Rankine (Roughie time!). Was looking at Moore but scared off with reports of minor hammy.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Going to take a risk and go Neale/Roberts to Dawson/Mills. 4 trades left so will be looking to hold for a while after this week.

Will have to hold Cerra and hope last night was just a blip.

 

[Ollie1981]

Hi Legends - 1 trade already done so far A.Clarke -> Liddy. Just want to get you thoughts in the below trade please.
9 trades, 3 boosts & $180,300 in the shed.
E.Hewett -> S.Darcy
L.Pedlar -> S.Butler
Or can you recomend something better?

 

[speedy]

Which rookie has better job security, Clarke or Johnson?

 

[St Steady]

Hi Legends - 1 trade already done so far A.Clarke -> Liddy. Just want to get you thoughts in the below trade please.
9 trades, 3 boosts & $180,300 in the shed.
E.Hewett -> S.Darcy
L.Pedlar -> S.Butler
Or can you recomend something better?

View attachment 2353216

i would consider neale to serong/brayshaw (i actually made that trade this week, still tossing up between the two freo guys which to take)

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Hi Legends - 1 trade already done so far A.Clarke -> Liddy. Just want to get you thoughts in the below trade please.
9 trades, 3 boosts & $180,300 in the shed.
E.Hewett -> S.Darcy
L.Pedlar -> S.Butler
Or can you recomend something better?

View attachment 2353216

Can you afford Pedlar/Kako + bank to Darcy/Butler?

Hewett probably goes up this week.

 

[Caztheconquerer]

At this stage will probably go roberts to mills leaving 4 trades. Will decide on Neale as the round goes on

 

[catstragic]

leaves me 150 K in the bank and five trades. Next week Kaka becomes SP Mccarthy giving me 280 k to turn Flynn into Xerri leaving me with 3 trades for injuries.

 

[MrChristo]

Going to take a risk and go Neale/Roberts to Dawson/Mills. 4 trades left so will be looking to hold for a while after this week.

Will have to hold Cerra and hope last night was just a blip.

Man, that is super dooper DOOPER sideways.
One extra score this week of course, but one Neale 150 and a Mills 70 or two...(Or sore foot...)

I'm genuinely not convinced you're better off.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Man, that is super dooper DOOPER sideways.
One extra score this week of course, but one Neale 150 and a Mills 70 or two...(Or sore foot...)

I'm genuinely not convinced you're better off.

Fair. Counter-points

Have you seen Dawson's draw? He's on the Brownlow hunt too.
Roberts has lost his role to....Mills. I don't want the bloke playing on the opposite wing to Gulden. Mills is injury prone though I'll concede.

 

[JuddgementDay]

View attachment 2353258View attachment 2353259

leaves me 150 K in the bank and five trades. Next week Kaka becomes SP Mccarthy giving me 280 k to turn Flynn into Xerri leaving me with 3 trades for injuries.

Trading Sinclair out is quite desperate - but, I like the overall plan

 

[jdwood]

I’ve traded Neale/Pedlar for Bont/Butler.

Think I’ll hold Washy as he just doesn’t carry the tag risk.

 

[Pathetic Pittman]

Which rookie has better job security, Clarke or Johnson?

The consensus seems to be Clarke safer

 

[MrChristo]

Fair. Counter-points

Have you seen Dawson's draw? He's on the Brownlow hunt too.
Roberts has lost his role to....Mills. I don't want the bloke playing on the opposite wing to Gulden. Mills is injury prone though I'll concede.

I've talked Dawson up so year as a top 4-5 mid, so no argument there.

Genuinely interested in how this plays out. Just feel like I'd prefer to be a bit more trade-conservative, but good luck!

(I guess my main reluctance is that I don't see Mills averaging over 95, but if it funds another upgrade then it can't hurt, right?!)

 

[catstragic]

Trading Sinclair out is quite desperate - but, I like the overall plan

I don't really want to trade Sinc but its the only way I can afford to turn Flynn into a proper super premo and have any trades left. I do not want to have a b grader like Marshall Vs Gawn/Xerri/Grundy in the finals.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

I've talked Dawson up so year as a top 4-5 mid, so no argument there.

Genuinely interested in how this plays out. Just feel like I'd prefer to be a bit more trade-conservative, but good luck!

(I guess my main reluctance is that I don't see Mills averaging over 95, but if it funds another upgrade then it can't hurt, right?!)

It's possible I'll regret it. Taking risks rarely works for me in SC, but it's just a game in the end.

Mills is great value imo if he stays on the park.

And I just can't watch Neale anymore. Should never have got him (which doesn't justify the trade). I skipped him last year worrying about age regression, but for some reason got him this year.

 

[AN1611]

In the end have decided to boot neale - Darcy or Macrae? Or anyone else under 520k worth a shout?

 

[Deliverance]

It's possible I'll regret it. Taking risks rarely works for me in SC, but it's just a game in the end.

Mills is great value imo if he stays on the park.

And I just can't watch Neale anymore. Should never have got him (which doesn't justify the trade). I skipped him last year worrying about age regression, but for some reason got him this year.

 

[MrChristo]

Mills is great value imo if he stays on the park.

You know who he potentially makes a viable (value!) option?
He seems to free up the Lizard (which is why I feel that Mills will have down games)...
...in the 3 games Mills has played Blakey has averaged 118.

(Not that I'd expect anyone to trade him in at this point, but interesting... )

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

You know who he potentially makes a viable (value!) option?
He seems to free up the Lizard (which is why I feel that Mills will have down games)...
...in the 3 games Mills has played Blakey has averaged 118.

(Not that I'd expect anyone to trade him in at this point, but interesting... )

I had the Lizard last year, love him but I can't go there again.

 

[Pathetic Pittman]

I had the Lizard last year, love him but I can't go there again.

we still talking about footy?