Trades 2025 Round 18 Trades

[JuddgementDay]

I've decided to pull the trigger right before the game last night and went TDK to Nank, that's all I could have afforded in one trade.

Let's see how that works out

 

[Deliverance]

because he’s 30 next year? Thought that’d be pretty obvious lol

30s not that old for a ruck. Caminiti, King, Keeler and TDK/Roma is a tall slow forward line.

 

[DT_35]

30s not that old for a ruck. Caminiti, King, Keeler and TDK/Roma is a tall slow forward line.

Caminiti plays backline. Does King ever play? And there’s rumours Marshall could leave if TDK comes which would net a 1st rounder probably from Geelong

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

30s not that old for a ruck. Caminiti, King, Keeler and TDK/Roma is a tall slow forward line.

It's a big brain moneyball move from St Kilda. TdK on massive money as they have no stars to pay and trade out Roma for another draft pick.

 

[Deliverance]

Caminiti plays backline. Does King ever play? And there’s rumours Marshall could leave if TDK comes which would net a 1st rounder probably from Geelong

Oh yeah, if Marshall is not on the list, completely different story as I referenced originally.

 

[Falchoon]

30s not that old for a ruck. Caminiti, King, Keeler and TDK/Roma is a tall slow forward line.

I wouldn't be planning a forward line around Keeler and Caminiti.

Caminiti has found his role, 2nd tall defender, Keeler's a 5 year project at best.

 

[Wojcinski]

I've got Oliver at M8 with 5 trades and a couple of mooing rooks. Only 8k ITB so would need to do 2 trades to **** clarry off (probably for Brayshaw or Libba)

My head tells me to wait a few weeks and trade him out before SC finals but my heart hates him and wants him out ASAP

what do

edit* I'm 23/23 premos if you include Oliver as a premo

 

[THECHIEFTON]

But it's the role that Marshall is perfect for, with an emphasis on forward.

Anyone who watched our game last week knows that we are crying out for a CHF, and yet we have one.

I thought he said he wanted to stay as the #1 ruck?

 

[JT_the_Man]

Ended up going Johnson and Carroll to Xerri and Shanahan.

7 trades + a boost, McCarthy currently at M8 the only one who I don't envision as a keeper, although I have a handful of frauds who I hope come good.

(Please drop Pittonet Carlton)

 

[Seppo]

Pulled the trigger on Bolton who was F6 foing some DPP shuffles and slotting Mills into Flex.
Means i have to toss a coin between Cadman and J.Martin and sucks Mcarthy is now Def cover, but a good problem to have.

4 trades left, 1 boost and only a few $ left in the bank.

 

[Deliverance]

Caldwell to Libba.

 

[Jiska]

3 trades. Don’t care. Only 3 weeks of SC left. Time to spend.

Pedlar (now can’t get a gig) for Shanahan
Long for Rozee



Judd_Magic

1 trade left.

 

[Axly]

What's Shanahan's JS like?
Want to build some cash for next week.
So can either ditch Campbell Gray and bench McCarthy or ditch Z.Johnson early this week and put McCarthy in Flex.
Allows me to potentially grab Rowell/Anderson next week and a rookie.
Or i could just holding tight... hmm..

 

[Sherman41]

What's Shanahan's JS like?
Want to build some cash for next week.
So can either ditch Campbell Gray and bench McCarthy or ditch Z.Johnson early this week and put McCarthy in Flex.
Allows me to potentially grab Rowell/Anderson next week and a rookie.
Or i could just holding tight... hmm..View attachment 2365729

Hopefully Shanahan has decent JS. I got him so I could move TDK on to Brayshaw.

 

[Chucks]

Have I done my VC loophole correctly? Want to keep bonts score as captain, so have chucked Simpson on my field and put the skipper on him (with Warner as emergency)

Is that done correctly?

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Have I done my VC loophole correctly? Want to keep bonts score as captain, so have chucked Simpson on my field and put the skipper on him (with Warner as emergency)

Is that done correctly?

 

[Deliverance]

Who is the best option for TDK if you already have Xerri and can't afford Grundy?

B

Did you get him? Not s bad return for his price.

 

[Jiska]

Have I done my VC loophole correctly? Want to keep bonts score as captain, so have chucked Simpson on my field and put the skipper on him (with Warner as emergency)

Is that done correctly?

Yes that is correct, however you should use Rucks instead, that way you can have Shanahan covering if a late out to a forward.

Also, wrong thread which is why you didn’t get a timely reply

Game Day - Rd 18 2025 Discussion - MND YeoGabbaGabba vs Scythe

Ok, so... Discuss.

www.bigfooty.com

 

[Jiska]

3 trades. Don’t care. Only 3 weeks of SC left. Time to spend.

Pedlar (now can’t get a gig) for Shanahan
Long for Rozee

View attachment 2365289

Judd_Magic

1 trade left.

Imagine using a roughie on Rozee for a 52

 

[Choppers]

With JHF out for the season......I can go

JHF > Rankine 1 trade left
OR
JHF and TDK > Bolton and Cameron....zero trades left.....hmmmmm!

 

[Scythe]

With JHF out for the season......I can go

JHF > Rankine 1 trade left
OR
JHF and TDK > Bolton and Cameron....zero trades left.....hmmmmm!

First one IMO. Even if Cameron puts 20 points per week on TDK from here, if you were to cop another season-ending injury at any point over the next 3-4 weeks (likely), you'd be better off with the extra trade.

That, and Bolton is a dreadful own. Can't believe how many went there.

 

[Choppers]

First one IMO. Even if Cameron puts 20 points per week on TDK from here, if you were to cop another season-ending injury at any point over the next 3-4 weeks (likely), you'd be better off with the extra trade.

That, and Bolton is a dreadful own. Can't believe how many went there.

Thanks but just realised I posted in the wrong thread.....R18 done and dusted.......doesn't time fly when you're having fun...

 

[Scythe]

Thanks but just realised I posted in the wrong thread.....R18 done and dusted.......doesn't time fly when you're having fun...

Good reminder for me to lock this one, lol.