Game Day 2025 Round 5 Discussion ...Carnage

[Jiska]

Don't stop in Ararat you'll get attacked by people with two heads.

Just got through. Was nervous when we had to stop at a a red light but made it out okay.

 

[Plugger35]

Everybody should have davidson who has a very high ceiling and rankine still only score like 70 last week.

Davidson is my F6, my forward bench options to replace Rankine if he doesn't play are Kako or Max Hall, neither are great options.

 

[SC fish]

Just got through. Was nervous when we had to stop at a a red light but made it out okay.

Wave to me as you pass by Mount Barker

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Davidson is my F6, my forward bench options to replace Rankine if he doesn't play are Kako or Max Hall, neither are great options.

I think Kako will do well this week against the Demons he is due for a spike game.

 

[No eye deer]

I’m really scared of what Rankine does tonight if he plays. Got a crazy idea of putting E on him.

Yeah I’m going to swing JHF to the mids, Hewett fwd and loop Rankine with Davidson.
It’s the only way of looping anyone for me anyway, as all my mid rookies play after Hewett anyway.

 

[stevebbb]

Knevitt and Lindsay holders rewarded (sub pending)

stevebbb melts incoming

I got Lindsay, happy days

Knevitt is a spud, he'll be starting sub or subbed off

 

[Silky23]

 

[stevebbb]

Line em up! We need plenty of debutants this week, rookies are fattening up nicely, they'll be ready to cull soon.

 

[vanders]

Eyre Peninsula is gods country. Bloody awesome people. Had some of my best nights in country pubs speaking and drinking with strangers. Prime agricultural land. Lincoln has the most millionaires per capita in Australia.

Used to live on the Eyre Peninsula, beautiful part of the world

 

[Jiska]

Lindsay confirmed IN

This is #fakenews

He’s been confirmed “available” for selection. Nowhere does it say he’ll actually be selected. I assume he will be as clearly best 22.

 

[SELFCONFESDAFLNERD]

Hoping Campo is still out so i can loop Knevitt. Obviously im assuming Knevitt will not be sub. If Lyndsay is selected i'll be stoked i held him as well.

 

[Scythe]

This is #fakenews

He’s been confirmed “available” for selection. Nowhere does it say he’ll actually be selected. I assume he will be as clearly best 22.

Goodwin said he'll be playing in his press conference.

 

[SC fish]

Goodwin said he'll be playing in his press conference.

I'll probably bench him and play Hall, this week at least

 

[Jiska]

Goodwin said he'll be playing in his press conference.

Excellent news.

 

[NSWCROW]

Ffs, can we get a game at Unley next year please ??

 

[Judd_Magic]

Is it worth getting Clay Hall over Tsatas?

I'm just worried about Halls job security.

Is he going to stick around for the next 4-5 weeks?

 

[Ingy]

Y'all can brag that you held Lindsay, but with that single-figure score in his rolling average, he's gonna be a bloody great downgrade target for the rest of us in two weeks.

Which is why I traded him out

 

[AN1611]

Y'all can brag that you held Lindsay, but with that single-figure score in his rolling average, he's gonna be a bloody great downgrade target for the rest of us in two weeks.

Which is why I traded him out

Can pick him up in a few weeks for low 200s I reckon

 

[Jiska]

Y'all can brag that you held Lindsay, but with that single-figure score in his rolling average, he's gonna be a bloody great downgrade target for the rest of us in two weeks.

Which is why I traded him out

Not much of a downgrade target at 240k. Wasn’t about cash gen for me, it was about having a rookie I could field with confidence who would score well.

Can pick him up in a few weeks for low 200s I reckon

2 x 80 and he’s 241k in two weeks

 

[weltschmerz]

Y'all can brag that you held Lindsay, but with that single-figure score in his rolling average, he's gonna be a bloody great downgrade target for the rest of us in two weeks.

Which is why I traded him out

Running out of trades is what I'm worried about.

 

[Nelso]

Ffs, can we get a game at Unley next year please ??

Not going to happen. It can only hold 6k and a 3rd of the ground is blocked off from spectator access.

 

[Deliverance]

Y'all can brag that you held Lindsay, but with that single-figure score in his rolling average, he's gonna be a bloody great downgrade target for the rest of us in two weeks.

Which is why I traded him out

Think I'd rather have the two trades it will cost to get him in and out of the team again.

 

[Deliverance]

Is it worth getting Clay Hall over Tsatas?

I'm just worried about Halls job security.

Is he going to stick around for the next 4-5 weeks?

Yes, check their expected rises in cash. Kelly just got dropped. Hall is as close to a must have as you can get.

 

[Ingy]

Think I'd rather have the two trades it will cost to get him in and out of the team again.

This doesn't factor in the utility gained via the guy you traded in when you traded him out, and the guy you trade out when you trade him back in.

If it was the same guy, you'd have an amazingly good point.

It never is though

 

[Deliverance]

This doesn't factor in the utility gained via the guy you traded in when you traded him out, and the guy you trade out when you trade him back in.

If it was the same guy, you'd have an amazingly good point.

It never is though

Yep, nothing ever happens in a vacuum in SC. Lindsay holders would have also gained utility trading last week, to Bice/Maric types.