Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2025 Trade/FA Thread

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Just looking at it, we have built a bloody great list, allowing us to gradually bring through players to the senior team only when they are ready.

CURRENT SQUAD

FB: Quaynor Frampton Maynard
HB: Houston Moore Howe
C: J.Daicos De Goey Crisp
HF: Schultz Mihochek McCreery
FF: Hill McStay Elliott
R: Cameron N.Daicos Pendlebury

I: Sidebottom Perryman Membrey Long Hoskin-Elliott

Reserves: Cox Lipinski Mitchell Markov Harrison Johnson Sullivan

Future: Allan West Ryan Jiath Cochrane Hayes Steene Smit

Draft: McGuane McCarthy Saxena


KEY OBSERVATION/THOUGHTS
-
I think the strong performances of our 2024 draftees (very bullish on all 3 of West, Cochrane and Hayes) and the sudden improvement of our father-son/NGA academy prospects (McGuane/McCarthy looking like to top 25-30 picks, and Saxena into top 40) really is a game changer and allows us to be more aggressive with list management in the near-term.
If the 2025 crop keeps tracking as they have started off the year, come 2026 we could have a really strong core group of young players consisting of:
  • High prospect: West, Cochrane, Hayes, McGuane, McCarthy, Saxena, Jiath, Allan,
  • Solid: Ryan, Harrison, Parker, Steene, Smit
  • Unlikely: De Mattia, Dean

And this does not include the obvious in Daicos, Long and potential recruitment of Condon (who if anyone follows the NBA, knows that around half of 2nd round NBA draft picks dont even get a contract/ get onto a roster, and only 10% become long-term NBA players).

NEAR-TERM NEEDS
  • Full-Back (more dependable partner for Moore - I am bullish on Cochrane, but seems like like a rebounding tall (e.g. Ridley)
  • Second Gun Mid (give Nick a midfield partner for the next 10 years, reducing the workload on him)
  • Intercept Defender (to replace Howe - Miles Bergman would be amazing but unlikely, likely will be filled by Perryman)

POTENTIAL TRADE BAIT
- Lipinski, Allen, and De Goey (love him and would only move if it helped us make a big move like a Butters/Reid, however its starting to get annoying having a player who is a) constantly injured, and b) not fit, even when playing). I think most of us see De Goey playing fit as a "bonus" rather then the standard, which is ok now, but prob not be sustainable in 2026 and 2027, particularly if Pendlebury/Sidebottom's performance begin to decline.

BEST STRATEGY FOR THE NOW AND FUTURE
  • Trade for Rowell/Butters (Both young, and I think these 2 are the safest bet for a reliable partner for Nick over the next 8-10 years, Reid is another option, but I think abit risky considering his current output. Would likely require 2 x future first round picks, otherwise try and package up a future first with a combination of 2nd round picks (a player like Lipinski would be worth a lot to a team like North or West Coast or Allan for West Coast).
  • Look around the league and try and poach the best kpd that is gettable or not currently getting a game (Worrel, Chapman, Aleer, Blanck, Serong).

A really long-winded post, but overall very happy with how the club's list management over the last few years. Think we are well placed to to complete in the near-term, whilst having enough talent to gradually come into the squad, as we drip feed our older players into retirement (2025: Mitchell, Cox, 2026: Pendlebury, Howe, 2027: Mihochek, Sidebottom).
 
Last edited:
Hardcore clickbait this week - our “2028 vision”? Come off it’
Those two should just stick to discussing the kids rather than having shifted to clickbait and thinking they're list managers.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Those two should just stick to discussing the kids rather than having shifted to clickbait and thinking they're list managers.
That and Twomey's awful "reform" proposals to make the draft even more compromised than it already is. Think they've drunk their own bathwater a little
 
Bont against the Saints was just a god, I’m sorry but if they offered him for Josh then I’d take it in a heartbeat. Bont has the opportunity to be the greatest bulldog to ever play if he can manage to get one more premiership
 
That and Twomey's awful "reform" proposals to make the draft even more compromised than it already is. Think they've drunk their own bathwater a little
I don't think they've got a choice if they're trying to make it all year round. Change the name of the show to draftable and have it only run from August -November. Done.
 
Bont against the Saints was just a god, I’m sorry but if they offered him for Josh then I’d take it in a heartbeat. Bont has the opportunity to be the greatest bulldog to ever play if he can manage to get one more premiership
I think Whitten still has an almost mythological grip on that title, but Bont is pretty bloody good.

But if you mean offered Bont for Josh Daicos, I'd probably have to disagree - keeping the Daicos family as a whole happy and at Collingwood is crucial. I don't want us to make Nick consider the huge $ he'll be offered by sending his brother to Footscray.
 
I think Whitten still has an almost mythological grip on that title, but Bont is pretty bloody good.

But if you mean offered Bont for Josh Daicos, I'd probably have to disagree - keeping the Daicos family as a whole happy and at Collingwood is crucial. I don't want us to make Nick consider the huge $ he'll be offered by sending his brother to Footscray.
I've heard a fair few pundits call Bont the greatest ever dog.
 
Why the **** does Riley Beveridge look like a 30yo toddler with that stupid haircut
Someone needs to tell him that whilst the show isn't on tv, it's not on radio either, and we can see him.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Don't need Ben King.
A midfielder and a great defender will do.
By the end of 2026 we're potentially looking at losing Mihocek and Membrey. I think having their replacements (hopefully West pans out) secured is a good idea
 
Bont against the Saints was just a god, I’m sorry but if they offered him for Josh then I’d take it in a heartbeat. Bont has the opportunity to be the greatest bulldog to ever play if he can manage to get one more premiership
He's an unrestricted free agent so we wouldn't have to trade anything. I doubt he leaves though.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

These all look gettable but are they any better than Frampton?

Howard OOC
Francis UFA
Laverde UFA
Silvagni UFA
McDonald UFA
 
These all look gettable but are they any better than Frampton?

Howard OOC
Francis UFA
Laverde UFA
Silvagni UFA
McDonald UFA
I think Laverde, Silvagni & Francis would be more Howe-ish types - 3rd tall floaters, rather than able to man the full-back spot.
 
I think Laverde, Silvagni & Francis would be more Howe-ish types - 3rd tall floaters, rather than able to man the full-back spot.
And McDonald probably too old going forward, that leaves the only one you have to give something up for, which I'm sure we are trying to avoid with Mcguane McCarthy Saxena and possibly Lonie and Kerr needing points.
 
And McDonald probably too old going forward, that leaves the only one you have to give something up for, which I'm sure we are trying to avoid with Mcguane McCarthy Saxena and possibly Lonie and Kerr to pay for.

I don't think that's an issue for us. A Membrey, Mitchell type move to fill a short term gap in positional depth.

He was very good against Freo the other night.
 
I don't think that's an issue for us. A Membrey, Mitchell type move to fill a short term gap in positional depth.

He was very good against Freo the other night.
Its one thing to get someone thats close to 30, but another thats 33yrs in september.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom