List Mgmt. 2025 Trade/FA Thread

[Pistol Night]

Mitch Cleary revealing on Gettable that Dan Houston has changed managers.

Prob means nothing footy wise. Maybe he wants someone to better promote him to off field avenues

 

[nickyds35]

I could definitely see us making a move/wanting to make a move like this. We need to maximise having Daicos as much as possible.

Agreed - Butters is the safest sidekick to Daicos for the next decade. Doesnt really have a weakness.

Reid is too high risk, Rowell im not sure his style of play will be conducive into his 30's.

 

[rdangelo]

That's a big turnover.

Yeah but 6 of the guys I listed haven't played a game this year and we're going to have some retirements/players ask to be traded, it always happens. Unless we want to keep deadwood like Johnson and Macrae expect 10 changes.

 

[DopeMaster]

Hill + Allan for WC pick 2 (Allen compo)

Pick 2 + F1st to Port for Butters

Port 2nd WC 3rd back to Pies for points

Who says no?

 

[Fat Jesus]

Hill + Allan for WC pick 2 (Allen compo)

Pick 2 + F1st to Port for Butters

Port 2nd WC 3rd back to Pies for points

Who says no?

Me.

 

[manicpie]

Hill + Allan for WC pick 2 (Allen compo)

Pick 2 + F1st to Port for Butters

Port 2nd WC 3rd back to Pies for points

Who says no?

If both players want to leave then it's a good deal. If it's Collingwood driven then it's a no

 

[AmericanMustard]

Mitch Cleary revealing on Gettable that Dan Houston has changed managers.

“This is a result of a player who desperately wanted to get to Carlton last year but unfortunately his team couldn’t get the job done”

- Sam Edmund tomorrow. Probably

 

[BEEG]

Pies lost Cameron which i don't think happens.

Moyle would be the number 1 choice, looked great last year.

I'm not massive on over paying rucks, Pies could cash in potentially with Eagles and then get Moyle cheap.

 

[Pistol Night]

Pies lost Cameron which i don't think happens.

Moyle would be the number 1 choice, looked great last year.

I'm not massive on over paying rucks, Pies could cash in potentially with Eagles and then get Moyle cheap.

Look at the ruckman from the last 3 premiership sides. Even during the Cats, Hawks, Tigers runs they had serviceable big men rather than superstars

 

[sr36]

Hill + Allan for WC pick 2 (Allen compo)

Pick 2 + F1st to Port for Butters

Port 2nd WC 3rd back to Pies for points

Who says no?

WC says no. Hill + Allan doesn't get you pick 2. And th AFL too - I doubt Allen gets them a level 1 compo pick.

 

[Carlthetruth]

Hill + Allan for WC pick 2 (Allen compo)

Pick 2 + F1st to Port for Butters

Port 2nd WC 3rd back to Pies for points

Who says no?

The Weagles say no because that's insane from their end.

 

[Pleasedontfail11]

WC says no. Hill + Allan doesn't get you pick 2. And th AFL too - I doubt Allen gets them a level 1 compo pick.

Would need to at least add Cameron to the deal to get it done. Allan at best is a pick in the 20s. Hill is worth a pick about 12-18. It's not enough for pick 2.

 

[sr36]

Would need to at least add Cameron to the deal to get it done. Allan at best is a pick in the 20s. Hill is worth a pick about 12-18. It's not enough for pick 2.

I don't think you'd get a 20s pick for Allan - no idea about Bobby - range he'd be valued at would vary a lot by club I think.

 

[Exambolor]

Glenn Macfarlane reporting on the Midweek Tackle tonight that Bobby is very close to a contract extension which is great news…

 

[jmac70]

Would need to at least add Cameron to the deal to get it done. Allan at best is a pick in the 20s. Hill is worth a pick about 12-18. It's not enough for pick 2.

Let’s just keep Cameron and Hill, and get a pick in the 20s for a VFL player.
Amazing result.

 

[Pleasedontfail11]

Let’s just keep Cameron and Hill, and get a pick in the 20s for a VFL player.
Amazing result.

Will be pick 40 on draft night after all the academy picks.

 

[BillyElliott]

Glenn Macfarlane reporting on the Midweek Tackle tonight that Bobby is very close to a contract extension which is great news…

Good. We can put to REST all the Bobby trade talk.

 

[Pleasedontfail11]

I don't think you'd get a 20s pick for Allan - no idea about Bobby - range he'd be valued at would vary a lot by club I think.

It's a best pick but you are right he is more a pick in the 40s. He would need to consistently play like he did against Melbourne to get that sort of pick.

 

[Magland]

If Cameron and Allan got you Moyle and Butters you'd be way ahead and much younger.

 

[Bianconeri]

Defence is a great way to learn to read the play. He'll be fine

What do people mean by fine? A lot of people said that about Macrae, Begg, Bianco, Ruscoe and McMahom so I’m not sure that’s a good thing.

 

[manicpie]

What do people mean by fine? A lot of people said that about Macrae, Begg, Bianco, Ruscoe and McMahom so I’m not sure that’s a good thing.

He showed a bit last year. Not so much this year. He'll be fine in the sense that he'll develop quite well. He could end up being delisted but I just reckon he could be good in time

 

[Bogsey]

With our lack of picks, the NGA and F/S we have coming this off-season, i believe we're going to be using some of our future picks to try to purchase more points to pick up who we need.
We need to be looking at attacking FA pretty hard.

 

[Jen2310]

With our lack of picks, the NGA and F/S we have coming this off-season, i believe we're going to be using some of our future picks to try to purchase more points to pick up who we need.
We need to be looking at attacking FA pretty hard.

Definitely will need to dig into future picks, just need to find a buyer. But they'll work through it.

 

[magpies42]

The dogs are in a bit of strife with JUH’s salary, and that according to rumours some dogs players won’t play with him.

Is this an opportunity for us to take on part of his salary and get a first round pick that we then offload to trade in a top end mid?

Would only really work if we feel like we can resurrect JUH’s career.

 

[Jen2310]

The dogs are in a bit of strife with JUH’s salary, and that according to rumours some dogs players won’t play with him.

Is this an opportunity for us to take on part of his salary and get a first round pick that we then offload to trade in a top end mid?

Would only really work if we feel like we can resurrect JUH’s career.

Red flags everywhere.
I think his only chance at resurrecting his career is outside victoria. Thats if he decides he wants to make the sacrifices to be a professional footballer. ATM, that's questionable.