List Mgmt. 2025 Trade/FA Thread

[Dtennent94]

Hey Pies,

Just wondering where the board sits with Bobby Hill (don’t need to discuss the details) and Darcy Cameron potentially heading back to WA?

WCE have put a big contract to Cameron which is the only reason he’s likely to consider leaving but have absolutely no idea about Hill staying or going.

We’ve got the Hawks draft picks this year so goodluck tonight.

To get both of these guys, the Pies would settle for nothing less than Harley Reid or an early R1 being involved.

Ed Allan could also come into calculations if any of this eventuates.

 

[satty]

Because his actions over the past 8 weeks are becoming a distraction. A lot is happening with him, including this latest stunt having an enforced week off. And it is now costing the team.

Think I have a better chance of find Amelia Earhart’s plane than finding your brain.

 

[eaglevision]

To get both of these guys, the Pies would settle for nothing less than Harley Reid or an early R1 being involved.

Ed Allan could also come into calculations if any of this eventuates.

I don’t want Hill, we have heaps of small forwards coming through our NGA. Freo will be after him hard if he wanted to leave.

The value of Cameron is more what I’d be interested in discussing.

 

[ksardog]

I don’t want Hill, we have heaps of small forwards coming through our NGA. Freo will be after him hard if he wanted to leave.

The value of Cameron is more what I’d be interested in discussing.

what do you think he is worth?

 

[Exambolor]

I don’t want Hill, we have heaps of small forwards coming through our NGA. Freo will be after him hard if he wanted to leave.

The value of Cameron is more what I’d be interested in discussing.

At the bare minimum if DC were to leave, we’d expect a high first rounder minimum, a pick in the 20s just wouldn’t suffice for a Top 4 ruck in the comp.

I’d imagine the Eagles would be reluctant to part with Pick 1 or 2 this year, but on the other hand they need good vets and they haven’t had the greatest track record with list management

If you gave up Pick 3 for Owies, they should be giving that for a talented player

 

[satty]

Hey Pies,

Just wondering where the board sits with Bobby Hill (don’t need to discuss the details) and Darcy Cameron potentially heading back to WA?

WCE have put a big contract to Cameron which is the only reason he’s likely to consider leaving but have absolutely no idea about Hill staying or going.

We’ve got the Hawks draft picks this year so goodluck tonight.

Well we would only entertain a bobby trade if he requested it, and we wouldn’t stand in his way given his circumstances. Having said that, we will be tough but fair when it comes to his negotiations because he is a game changer who simply doesn’t grow on trees. He by himself is worth a top 10 pick and then some.

His age is another reason as to why his trade value will be very high.

Now if you want cameron who is a top 5 ruck and someone who is still in the peak of his powers, it will also cost a pick that is very close to the top 10.

Before you say that is a high price for a ruck, he isn’t just a ruck, he is one of the best if not the best intercepting ruck in the competition.

Now if you want both combined - well it is either harley reid and some change or pick 2 and something else.

 

[Peters_Nuts]

Hey Pies,

Just wondering where the board sits with Bobby Hill (don’t need to discuss the details) and Darcy Cameron potentially heading back to WA?

WCE have put a big contract to Cameron which is the only reason he’s likely to consider leaving but have absolutely no idea about Hill staying or going.

We’ve got the Hawks draft picks this year so goodluck tonight.

Hey mate,

Would be shattered to lose both. I'm not going to speculate on Bobby though if he chooses to leave due to personal reasons, I can't see the Pies playing hard ball with him though would expect a fair trade.

Cameron we would play hard ball and ask for a lot back. Not sure what that would entail though I imagine it would be a first round pick + another high pick (we may throw in late picks). History suggests we should get Gold Coast involved to get some value!

 

[eaglevision]

what do you think he is worth?

Not too keen on coming onto someone else’s board and saying this is what your player is worth TBH, you guys would know his output better than me. 30yo at the start of next season and going on ruck trade precedent where do you roughly see it landing?

 

[Peters_Nuts]

Not too keen on coming onto someone else’s board and saying this is what your player is worth TBH, you guys would know his output better than me. 30yo at the start of next season and going on ruck trade precedent where do you roughly see it landing?

I think it would be the Hawthorn pick + another 2nd round pick to be honest, which gets pushed back as it is due to F/S and NGA selections.

Based on Fly's preference on players over picks, I think we'd get another team involved so we get a player back as the only players I'd be keen on personally from West Coast (aside from Reid which is a pipe dream) are Hewett, Shanahan, Archer Reid and maybe Ginbey though they're all important for West Coast's future.

 

[ksardog]

At the bare minimum if DC were to leave, we’d expect a high first rounder minimum, a pick in the 20s just wouldn’t suffice for a Top 4 ruck in the comp.

I’d imagine the Eagles would be reluctant to part with Pick 1 or 2 this year, but on the other hand they need good vets and they haven’t had the greatest track record with list management

If you gave up Pick 3 for Owies, they should be giving that for a talented player

they could always split that pick, say with Essendon for their first pick and later pick
current standings
pick 1 and 14 for Essendon 4 and comp pick for Draper (7)

 

[ksardog]

Not too keen on coming onto someone else’s board and saying this is what your player is worth TBH, you guys would know his output better than me. 30yo at the start of next season and going on ruck trade precedent where do you roughly see it landing?

the worst that could happen that you could be laughed at, big deal
would need to be a top 10 pick at a minimum
second best intercept ruck behind Gawn, would have to be in the top 3 for general rucks
would probably mean more to us than WC considering how low you lot are on the ladder while we are competing for flags

 

[eaglevision]

the worst that could happen that you could be laughed at, big deal
would need to be a top 10 pick at a minimum
second best intercept ruck behind Gawn, would have to be in the top 3 for general rucks
would probably mean more to us than WC considering how low you lot are on the ladder while we are competing for flags

Based on the suggestions here I think we’re a little bit apart. If it happens and based on our list boss I suspect it will land on the Hawks 1R, which I expect to be pick 10 before FA.

 

[stormskye]

Based on the suggestions here I think we’re a little bit apart. If it happens and based on our list boss I suspect it will land on the Hawks 1R, which I expect to be pick 10 before FA.

You will talk unders on your board, overs will be talked about on here. That’s just the nature of supporter trade talk. There’s not really any room for being objective.

 

[nickyds35]

Cameron and Hill is easily worth Pick 2.

Would be disappointed with anything less.

 

[eaglevision]

IF Bobby went to Freo would there be any interest in Liam Ryan

31

Liam Ryan

Age

29

Ht

181cm

Wt

76kg

Pos.

Fwd

Career

Season

Last 5

D

11.3

3star

K

8.6

3star

HB

2.7

2star

M

3.0

3star

T

2.0

4star

G

1.3

5star

D

9.9

3star

K

8.0

3star

HB

1.9

1star

M

3.3

3star

T

1.6

3star

G

1.3

5star

D

11.4

3star

K

9.0

4star

HB

2.4

3star

M

3.8

4star

T

1.8

4star

G

1.6

5star

?

 

[Anzacday]

IF Bobby went to Freo would there be any interest in Liam Ryan?

I’ve always liked him, he’d have to get fitter though.

 

[Peters_Nuts]

IF Bobby went to Freo would there be any interest in Liam Ryan?

Respectfully, absolutely not.

 

[manicpie]

Based on the suggestions here I think we’re a little bit apart. If it happens and based on our list boss I suspect it will land on the Hawks 1R, which I expect to be pick 10 before FA.

Cameron is contracted, we'd be after pick 1. You're not just getting the best ruckman, you'll be get a real leader. Someone who would drive standards and make the younger blokes stand taller.

 

[Dtennent94]

Based on the suggestions here I think we’re a little bit apart. If it happens and based on our list boss I suspect it will land on the Hawks 1R, which I expect to be pick 10 before FA.

If Hawks miss finals or bomb out in an Elim, this would probably be fair. Not sure if the Pies would rate any of the potential draftees at pick 10-15 all that highly though. Supposed to be a shallow draft.

 

[eaglevision]

I’ve always liked him, he’d have to get fitter though.

One year younger than Cameron. What does a Ryan for Cameron swap look like if Hill left, no doubt this board feels extra pick(s) are needed?

 

[YouBeauty]

IF Bobby went to Freo would there be any interest in Liam Ryan?

He plays for West Coast not Freo

 

[eaglevision]

He plays for West Coast not Freo

Aware of that. He’d be a replacement in seperate trades

 

[manicpie]

Aware of that. He’d be a replacement in seperate trades

Big no for Ryan

 

[Peters_Nuts]

One year younger than Cameron. What does a Ryan for Cameron swap look like if Hill left, no doubt this board feels extra pick(s) are needed?

I think you'd be hard pressed to find anyone who thinks that's a fair trade without including picks, especially if Bobby was leaving too.

Cameron is arguably our most important player after Daicos. We would demand a lot and Ryan doesn't cut it.

 

[eaglevision]

I think you'd be hard pressed to find anyone who thinks that's a fair trade without including picks, especially if Bobby was leaving too.

Cameron is arguably our most important player after Daicos. We would demand a lot and Ryan doesn't cut it.

I wasn’t implying an extra pick was unreasonable if that’s the way it was taken