Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. 2025 Trade/FA Thread

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
To crush that last bit of hope some people might have, the team is clearly fractured over the list management. Checkers, Elliott and McCreery likely all gone next year.
reportedly-disgruntled-magpie-beau-mccreery-liking-news-v0-m7mimm0zzohf1.jpeg
You're effin ridiculous hahahah - completely meaningless
 
Trade a few players for Rowell.
Maybe package McCreery (if he really does want to go live in Queensland) and a future pick. This would only be feasible of Rowell indicates he wants to move back to Victoria EVEN though he just signed 2 more years.... it just makes his value go up from Suns perspective.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Pies can't get Butters and aren't confident of Rowell in 2 years then Oliver would be a good option.

Motivated and in a new environment still only 28.

Huge upgrade on Long and Mitchell.
I was on the butters train, until i realised we need a lot of midfield depth, so we are better off investing all those draft picks needed for any butters trade in the draft.

We have to go all in and target “top end “ mids ( mids from 1-5) to pair with naicos. So trade whoever we have to , to make that happen.We have a generational player on our hands, to not surround him with top end talent is egregious.

Have to go all in on west coasts picks, and try to get 1 in the (1-5) range and another in the 5-15 range. Yes i am aware you can always find a gun mid later in the draft, but given our recent drafting history, I would much rather have our picks in near the top end where we have a greater chance of selecting a gun mid.
 
Trade a few players for Rowell.
Maybe package McCreery (if he really does want to go live in Queensland) and a future pick. This would only be feasible of Rowell indicates he wants to move back to Victoria EVEN though he just signed 2 more years.... it just makes his value go up from Suns perspective.
Talented players like rowell will not want to come to Collingwood given the huge list turnover that is going to happen over the next year .
We have to head for the draft.
 
No chance we’d get pick 1 for them both
We could. Bobby hill alone is worth two picks in the early 10’s, which when combined is fairly close to a top 2 pick.

Carlton did something similar to get pick 3 last year.
They gave up owies,12 and 14 for pick 3.
Hill is worth more than those , which negates the need to add in any sweetener.

Cameron is worth a pick in the early 10’s.
Baker was valued at pick 14, so go figure.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Zero excuses this week. If he doesn’t play it’s officially alarm bells.

If I'm not mistaken (if we discount limited VFL mins and coming on as sub vs Brisbane) Bobby's last proper game of football was June 21 vs the Saints. :(

I think we need to roll the dice if he's available but if they said he's not ready again it wouldn't be too far fetched.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

We could. Bobby hill alone is worth two picks in the early 10’s, which when combined is fairly close to a top 2 pick.

Carlton did something similar to get pick 3 last year.
They gave up owies,12 and 14 for pick 3.
Hill is worth more than those , which negates the need to add in any sweetener.

Cameron is worth a pick in the early 10’s.
Baker was valued at pick 14, so go figure.

Realistically, they’ll get pick 2 for Oscar Allen, if they split that pick into 2x top 10 picks, that’s enough for Cameron and Bobby.
 
Realistically, they’ll get pick 2 for Oscar Allen, if they split that pick into 2x top 10 picks, that’s enough for Cameron and Bobby.
If Richmond got pick 6+21 for Daniel Rioli then that that’s way unders for both
Eagles gave teen pick for Baker. Let that sink in - Baker.
 
I’m hoping that Hill’s value will be seen somewhere between Shai Bolton and Daniel Rioli.
Huge returns in a strong draft.
This draft isn’t as strong so the value of like for like picks is automatically less. If we can’t get a good deal for him picks/players wise this year, I’d be looking at a future first
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top