List Mgmt. 2025 Trade/FA Thread

[Pistol Night]

IF Elliot does leave who would take his spot in the AFL Team?

HH for starters

 

[gouki88]

IF Elliot does leave who would take his spot in the AFL Team?

Harrison

 

[satty]

Can anyone really see Jakob Ryan making it into the team next year?

Will parker, perryman and maybe TJ are ahead of him when it comes to backup small defenders.

Not sure if he will have any suitors,but can't see a future for him at Collingwood.

 

[BillyElliott]

Surely Buller gets nicknamed 'Mount'.

I'm shocked Dees didn't go after him.

 

[BillyElliott]

IF Elliot does leave who would take his spot in the AFL Team?

Wash your mouth out Dave. He's not leaving.

You said it was a done deal the other day.

 

[SchuPie]

Can anyone really see Jakob Ryan making it into the team next year?

I’m going to back him in

 

[No SPIN]

No way I want the Chef for 1.4m x 2 years, no way

It’s tough - because if he keeps in the flag race for a few more years then it’s worth serious consideration. Over paying will seem irrelevant if we achieve success.

 

[shizzle]

Buller looks like he's got some solid dukes on him, can play deep forward or that link up player outside 50

 

[Jen2310]

Can anyone really see Jakob Ryan making it into the team next year?

Will parker, perryman and maybe TJ are ahead of him when it comes to backup small defenders.

Not sure if he will have any suitors,but can't see a future for him at Collingwood.

He's not small, he's a medium defender at 189cm. He's also 20; so lets not predict how someone might go next year. We'll give him the right to back himself in. With Howe in his last year, if he breaks in, you can move perryman into the midfield

 

[satty]

He's not small, he's a medium defender at 189cm. He's also 20; so lets not predict how someone might go next year. We'll give him the right to back himself in.

But seriously jen , whose spot is he going to take in the back line to become a full time starter?

 

[Jen2310]

But seriously jen , whose spot is he going to take in the back line to become a full time starter?

You can say that for any of our youngsters. If they develop and perform enough, they'll find the room. Like I said, rotate perryman into the midfield
Howe unlikely to play all games next year.

 

[No SPIN]

Can anyone really see Jakob Ryan making it into the team next year?

Will parker, perryman and maybe TJ are ahead of him when it comes to backup small defenders.

Not sure if he will have any suitors,but can't see a future for him at Collingwood.

I don’t think TJ is ahead of him and I’d back Ryan’s footy IQ over TJ.
Ryan has all the skills and attributes to make it. Just needs a good run with injury.

 

[satty]

You can say that for any of our youngsters. If they develop and perform enough, they'll find the room. Like I said, rotate perryman into the midfield

Parker seems to be ahead of Ryan when to comes to playing in the back line

 

[Jen2310]

Parker seems to be ahead of Ryan when to comes to playing in the back line

Well Ryan has been injured for the last 8 weeks, so its hard to say whether thats true or not.
I imagine Ryan would have played while Howe was injured, might be more a like for like.

 

[SchuPie]

I don’t think TJ is ahead of him and I’d back Ryan’s footy IQ over TJ.
Ryan has all the skills and attributes to make it. Just needs a good run with injury.

Agree w all of this

 

[No SPIN]

IF Elliot does leave who would take his spot in the AFL Team?

He’s a unicorn - plays tall and small, we have no direct replacement.

 

[No SPIN]

But seriously jen , whose spot is he going to take in the back line to become a full time starter?

You never build a list assuming your best 23 are available all season and you'll have no injuries.

 

[Gabbo64]

We may have one, maybe two non top 23 players on the weekend. Whoever improves or whoever we trade/recruit will be there to take the place of those entrenched in the team. It's the way it goes. If you have a guy like Ryan in the wings who's not quite ready to take the spot of a super star, you don't just throw him away. Especially at 20 years of age. Mark my words, we will be happy we kept him in years to come.

 

[gouki88]

But seriously jen , whose spot is he going to take in the back line to become a full time starter?

He’s definitely down the pecking order. A bit of a make or break year for him with his contract ending in 2026

 

[Gabbo64]

IF Elliot does leave who would take his spot in the AFL Team?

I reckon every team in the comp would want Elliot if they could get him. He walks into any team and makes them better.
We have him, why would we let him go.
He's staying buddy so relax and enjoy him at the pies next season as we attempt flag 18.

 

[well left]

What was the name of that West Aus KPD we nearly took in MSD that we still have interest in?

I thought the only other one we were interested in was Archer May.

 

[Scodog10]

I thought the only other one we were interested in was Archer May.

Speaking of May’s…

Traded - Steven May [traded with Kade Kolodjashnij to Melbourne for pick 6]

Question for the Dees supporters, does Kolodjashnij fit in your backline when Lever comes back? Though Salem stepped up this year so have Lever/Salem on the flanks. I guess KK to a back pocket? We have a lot of players competing for spots in the backline. May, Jetta, Hibberd and Salem will be...

www.bigfooty.com

I would have C4 up there as having the best mail on this site.

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

Speaking of May’s…

Traded - Steven May [traded with Kade Kolodjashnij to Melbourne for pick 6]

Question for the Dees supporters, does Kolodjashnij fit in your backline when Lever comes back? Though Salem stepped up this year so have Lever/Salem on the flanks. I guess KK to a back pocket? We have a lot of players competing for spots in the backline. May, Jetta, Hibberd and Salem will be...

www.bigfooty.com

I would have C4 up there as having the best mail on this site.

If that's true it's ****ing hilarious. I can't stand the Entrecote Throttler.

 

[Jen2310]

Ignore the title.
*Jack not Jake

 

[Horaceg]

I see a difference between Mihocek and most of those golden oldies. Gunston for instance plays old school forward footy hitting up at the ball carrier when most forwards are looking for it over the top these days. Mihocek doesn’t strike me as the type to suddenly bounce back with his extremely attritional playing style and I don’t suspect we’ll see a late career spike at say 35. I do wonder what Gardiner’s role has been in luring Buller across.

Back to the future, something in that