List Mgmt. 2025 Trade Thread

[CaptainRisky]

Hmm, not so sure about that. They'll tell us we're not a top 4 team, probably not a top 6 team and likely not a top 8 team. It could get ugly fast.

Don't be so negative

 

[ScrappyDo]

Don't be so negative

It's not a competition..

 

[phantom13]

I can see why from a completely external POV someone might think Henry is gettable TBH but it does smack of zero effort journalism.

Seems weve got TDK and Aleer all but signed and NAS looks more likely to leave than stay (ITKs aside it doesnt look great).

ROMA would have to be considering his options.

Our first has to stay IMO, if we can get something in that mini Pou range and then still snag Fincher id say its a bloody good period (pending any other bolters)

 

[Rash]

I thought the word was Butters wanted back to Victoria for a similar reason that NAS might want to. Family. Thought that was a pretty solid rumour. As a free agent Port couldn’t do that much about it. Even a restricted one.

But apparently only wants to go to Geelong or the dogs because he is from Bacchus Marsh.

Butters has not shown any indication he wants to leave, its just victorian media barracking for it.

Superstar Victorian born player who is interstate(a pre-agent)= headline.

 

[Moquo]

Butters has not shown any indication he wants to leave, its just victorian media barracking for it.

Superstar Victorian born player who is interstate(a pre-agent)= headline.

That's great news!

 

[Joffaboy]

Butters has not shown any indication he wants to leave, its just victorian media barracking for it.

Superstar Victorian born player who is interstate(a pre-agent)= headline.

I have contacts at his old club ( Darley) and while Bacchus Marsh is a hole, apparently it is paradise compared to Adelaide.
Wants out

 

[MightySaintas]

Butters has not shown any indication he wants to leave, its just victorian media barracking for it.

Superstar Victorian born player who is interstate(a pre-agent)= headline.

Thank God for that
Means we can rule you out for Naz

 

[Rash]

Thank God for that
Means we can rule you out for Naz

Get ready for disappointment then (if he requests port)

 

[MightySaintas]

Get ready for disappointment then (if he requests port)

You can't buy a Ferrari for $20 you twat just because that's all you've got in the pocket of your stubbies

 

[Rash]

You can't buy a Ferrari for $20 you twat just because that's all you've got in the pocket of your stubbies

Your correct, but these days clubs recieve wayy unders for star players, we have been on the receiving end of this, im sure u guys have too. 3x 1st is fair, but i think you guys will end up accepting 2x 1st and a player equivalent of 1 first round pick.

 

[Joffaboy]

Get ready for disappointment then (if he requests port)

Can you **** off from our board. Nobody invited you over here, your team is as shit as ours, you don't have a coach and we beat you this year.
You get ready for disappointment you feckless f**k stick.

 

[Tom12]

Your correct, but these days clubs recieve wayy unders for star players, we have been on the receiving end of this, im sure u guys have too.

No top 5 player at 22 has requested a trade, this is a one of one situation.

 

[Rash]

No top 5 player at 22 has requested a trade, this is a one of one situation.

2 weeks ago he wasn't a top 5 player objectively. after 2 incredible weeks i dont think that propels him into top 5. by the end of the season he might be. its not clear cut top 5 player itl.

 

[Dard Ball Get]

Your correct, but these days clubs recieve wayy unders for star players, we have been on the receiving end of this, im sure u guys have too. 3x 1st is fair, but i think you guys will end up accepting 2x 1st and a player equivalent of 1 first round pick.

Apt name.

 

[Tom12]

2 weeks ago he wasn't a top 5 player objectively. after 2 incredible weeks i dont think that propels him into top 5. by the end of the season he might be. its not clear cut top 5 player itl.

That's true, but it's evolved and he clearly is now.

 

[Rash]

That's true, but it's evolved and he clearly is now.

to be a clear cut top5 itl, you'd imagine nas would be top 5 in coaches votes. not much competition at the saints (sinc, romarshall excluded)

 

[heynow85]

2 weeks ago he wasn't a top 5 player objectively. after 2 incredible weeks i dont think that propels him into top 5. by the end of the season he might be. its not clear cut top 5 player itl.

Go back to your own board, nobody cares what you think.

 

[saxond74]

to be a clear cut top5 itl, you'd imagine nas would be top 5 in coaches votes. not much competition at the saints (sinc, romarshall excluded)

Time to trot on I would’ve thought!!

 

[Moquo]

Get ready for disappointment then (if he requests port)

Get ready for disappointment then (if he requests port)

 

[billings2paddy]

2 weeks ago he wasn't a top 5 player objectively. after 2 incredible weeks i dont think that propels him into top 5. by the end of the season he might be. its not clear cut top 5 player itl.

He is in the convo for top 3
Ahead of Butters at the same age

 

[Rash]

And Butters has been ordinary this year so 2 top 10 picks plus him as steak knives

If he was ordinary he wouldn’t be so high in coaches votes (he’s missed first 3 games)

He’s above nas whilst playing 3 less games.

 

[heynow85]

If he was ordinary he wouldn’t be so high in coaches votes (he’s missed first 3 games)

Why are you still here?

 

[Holy Hunter Clark]

If he was ordinary he wouldn’t be so high in coaches votes (he’s missed first 3 games)

He’s above nas whilst playing 3 less games.

When

 

[Moquo]

If he was ordinary he wouldn’t be so high in coaches votes (he’s missed first 3 games)

He’s above nas whilst playing 3 less games.

Is Butters on 2 mil p/a?

 

[billings2paddy]

If he was ordinary he wouldn’t be so high in coaches votes (he’s missed first 3 games)

He’s above nas whilst playing 3 less games.

But is older and hit his ceiling
NAS hasn't hit his ceiling