List Mgmt. 2025 Trade Thread

[saxond74]

If he was ordinary he wouldn’t be so high in coaches votes (he’s missed first 3 games)

He’s above nas whilst playing 3 less games.

Why are you still here?

 

[stavro#4]

2 weeks ago he wasn't a top 5 player objectively. after 2 incredible weeks i dont think that propels him into top 5. by the end of the season he might be. its not clear cut top 5 player itl.

All I’ve heard from your board is that champion data said Houston was A tOp FiVe PlAyAaA.


Well it has NWM as the #2 rated player in the comp and in the top 5 for the last few months.

 

[stavro#4]

 

[Saintscomemarchingin]

Possible Round 1 team, 2026

B. Tauru Howard Hastie

H.B. Travaglia Aleer Sinclair

C. Wilson Phillipou Henry

H.F. Wood Caminiti Butler

F. Sharman King  Higgins

Foll. DeKoning Macrae Hall

l/C. Boxshall, Clark, Garcia, Owens, Hill-sub

Ins. Aleer, Butler, DeKoning, Hastie, Howard, King, Owens, Travaglia

Outs: Heath, Jones, Marshall, NWM, Steele, Stocker, Wilkie, Windhager

 

[gubby88]

Possible Round 1 team, 2026

B. Tauru Howard Hastie

H.B. Travaglia Aleer Sinclair

C. Wilson Phillipou Henry

H.F. Wood Caminiti Butler

F. Sharman King  Higgins

Foll. DeKoning Macrae Hall

l/C. Boxshall, Clark, Garcia, Owens, Hill-sub

Ins. Aleer, Butler, DeKoning, Hastie, Howard, King, Owens, Travaglia

Outs: Heath, Jones, Marshall, NWM, Steele, Stocker, Wilkie, Windhager

Wheres Harley Reid????

 

[Saintscomemarchingin]

Wheres Harley Reid????

& Miles Bergman

 

[Saintscomemarchingin]

If we got for next year

1. Aleer
2. Bergman
3. DeKoning
4. Harley Reid
& high end draft picks

For: Marshall, NWM, Steele, Wilkie & Windhager

Then so be it.

And Sinclair the captain for the next 3 years, easily solved!!!

How the NWM trade gets done;

We send Nas to the Crows, Windhager to Port

Crows send Curtin to WCE & their 1st round pick to Port.

Port sends Georgiadis to WCE & Bergman to us

WCE send Reid & a 2nd round pick to us.

Completion of trades;

Crows recieve NWM

Port recieve Windhager & 1st round pick from Crows

Saints recieve Harley Reid from WCE, Miles Bergman from Port & a 2nd round pick from WCE

WCE recieve Daniel Curtin from the Crows & Mitch Georgiadis from Port

 

[dudeintheswamp]

Wheres Harley Reid????

Well Harley wouldn't sign the $25m dollar deal because of the behavioural clauses, so we got smart and took those out and then he signed for only $24m! Off he then went to celebrate in South East Asia and after a few weeks was busted at a halfmoon rave drinking a mushroom shake with a buncha pingas in his pockets and some K. That old Cruel Sea song springs to mind. Anyway there's still lots of too and fro with the Embassy and now I believe we may be able to wrangle him back by about 2031.

He's gonna be a rich man when he gets out!

 

[Tom12]

If we got for next year

1. Aleer
2. Bergman
3. DeKoning
4. Harley Reid
& high end draft picks

For: Marshall, NWM, Steele, Wilkie & Windhager

Then so be it.

And Sinclair the captain for the next 3 years, easily solved!!!

How the NWM trade gets done;

We send Nas to the Crows, Windhager to Port

Crows send Curtin to WCE & their 1st round pick to Port.

Port sends Georgiadis to WCE & Bergman to us

WCE send Reid & a 2nd round pick to us.

Completion of trades;

Crows recieve NWM

Port recieve Windhager & 1st round pick from Crows

Saints recieve Harley Reid from WCE, Miles Bergman from Port & a 2nd round pick from WCE

WCE recieve Daniel Curtin from the Crows & Mitch Georgiadis from Port

I actually love this.

 

[Saintscomemarchingin]

Trade: lf they wanna leave like some are saying.

Marshall to Geelong for Brad Close 27 y.o small forward & a draft pick

Steele to Sydney for Ollie Florent, 27y.o flanker, Beaumaris bred.

Wilkie to Port for Ollie Lord 23 y.o 195cm KF, East Brighton lad

 

[saintderby]

Trade:

Marshall to Geelong for Brad Close 27 y.o small forward & a draft pick

Steele to Sydney for Ollie Florent, 27y.o flanker, Beaumaris bred.

Wilkie to Port for Ollie Lord 23 y.o 195cm KF, East Brighton lad

OK I will bite - You need serious help - Ollie Lord for Wilkie ??? FMD

 

[Captain Paddy]

Trade:

Marshall to Geelong for Brad Close 27 y.o small forward & a draft pick

Steele to Sydney for Ollie Florent, 27y.o flanker, Beaumaris bred.

Wilkie to Port for Ollie Lord 23 y.o 195cm KF, East Brighton lad

wtf

 

[Saintbloke]

We mightn't recognize next year's team

 

[Saintscomemarchingin]

OK I will bite - You need serious help - Ollie Lord for Wilkie ??? FMD

That's if he wants to walk like some say
30 y.o on 750k
And not a part of our future success.
If he's pissing on the club to the media, definately not captain material.

 

[Saintscomemarchingin]

wtf

Well if they wanna walk, gotta get something for them
Draft Picks won't suffice. At best we'd get a 3rd rounder for each of them.
The 3 of them are on big money & all 30y.o, next year
And not a part of our future success.

 

[ScrappyDo]

Howes now signed for 2 more years so CJ isn't a bad option at the right price.
I hate to say it, but I'd probably happily let Roma and Steely go now if/when TDK comes on board. Get something whilst they're still worth it.

 

[CDC60]

Well Harley wouldn't sign the $25m dollar deal because of the behavioural clauses, so we got smart and took those out and then he signed for only $24m! Off he then went to celebrate in South East Asia and after a few weeks was busted at a halfmoon rave drinking a mushroom shake with a buncha pingas in his pockets and some K. That old Cruel Sea song springs to mind. Anyway there's still lots of too and fro with the Embassy and now I believe we may be able to wrangle him back by about 2031.

He's gonna be a rich man when he gets out!

So, Port is losing Georgiades and Bergman, who has signed a new two year contract, for Windager and a first round from Adelaide that they obtained from WC for Curtin who might well be the Rising Star? That's risible. Curtin has signed a new contract and will be a Top 20 AFL player in two years. It looks likely NWM is leaving and whether it is Port or Cows you're getting a Dangerfield to Geelong from Adelaide trade from either club because they won't offer you any more.

 

[Jackbenimble]

So, Port is losing Georgiades and Bergman, who has signed a new two year contract, for Windager and a first round from Adelaide that they obtained from WC for Curtin who might well be the Rising Star? That's risible. Curtin has signed a new contract and will be a Top 20 AFL player in two years. It looks likely NWM is leaving and whether it is Port or Cows you're getting a Dangerfield to Geelong from Adelaide trade from either club because they won't offer you any more.

Ahh! I see you've been drinking the Rucci coolaid.


I will come back and dry your eyes with this post in a few weeks

 

[SaintsSeptember]

So, Port is losing Georgiades and Bergman, who has signed a new two year contract, for Windager and a first round from Adelaide that they obtained from WC for Curtin who might well be the Rising Star? That's risible. Curtin has signed a new contract and will be a Top 20 AFL player in two years. It looks likely NWM is leaving and whether it is Port or Cows you're getting a Dangerfield to Geelong from Adelaide trade from either club because they won't offer you any more.

The AFL have an arbitration system in place to stop unfair trades being forced. ( or reasonable trades being refused ). Compared the the current market , the Dangerfield deal ( Pick 9 and Pick 28 ) would probably be unders.

 

[hangdog]

Trade: lf they wanna leave like some are saying.

Marshall to Geelong for Brad Close 27 y.o small forward & a draft pick

Steele to Sydney for Ollie Florent, 27y.o flanker, Beaumaris bred.

Wilkie to Port for Ollie Lord 23 y.o 195cm KF, East Brighton lad

I honestly think Wilkie is the player on our list we can least afford to lose. No way I'm parting with a contracted, and likely future captain for anything other than an AA gun ala Sam Taylor or Jacob Weitering

 

[Browny2Carlisle]

Trade: lf they wanna leave like some are saying.

Marshall to Geelong for Brad Close 27 y.o small forward & a draft pick

Steele to Sydney for Ollie Florent, 27y.o flanker, Beaumaris bred.

Wilkie to Port for Ollie Lord 23 y.o 195cm KF, East Brighton lad

Yeah maybe never do this again

 

[Mavefromdelburn]

Trade: lf they wanna leave like some are saying.

Marshall to Geelong for Brad Close 27 y.o small forward & a draft pick

Steele to Sydney for Ollie Florent, 27y.o flanker, Beaumaris bred.

Wilkie to Port for Ollie Lord 23 y.o 195cm KF, East Brighton lad

Nas and Pou to Adelaide, straight swap for Kieran Strachan also

 

[Saintscomemarchingin]

Nas and Pou to Adelaide, straight swap for Kieran Strachan also

Pou's just signed on for an extra 3 years, why would you even try boofhead.
My trades show that, yes we ain't getting much for those 3. But if they wanna walk, there's some options out there.
Not good but the reality is we pretty much get didley squat, l agree with that much.

 

[Saintscomemarchingin]

Yeah maybe never do this again

Your missing the point really.
The reality is we ain't getting much for those 3 if they walk.
My trades show the sad reality of it.
But we gotta get something? out of it.

 

[Mavefromdelburn]

Pou's just signed on for an extra 3 years, why would you even try boofhead.
My trades show that, yes we ain't getting much for those 3. But if they wanna walk, there's some options out there.
Not good but the reality is we pretty much get didley squat, l agree with that much.

Yes but... Wilkie for Ollie Lord ffs.
What does he come with? Their next 13 FRDP's?