_RT_
Not A Minion
- Joined
- Sep 17, 2006
- Posts
- 50,642
- Reaction score
- 104,039
- Location
- Southern Stand Punt Road End
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Staff
- #1,968
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

LIVE: Western Bulldogs v Sydney - Rd 7 - 7:30PM Thu
Squiggle tips Dogs at 51% chance -- What's your tip? -- Injury Lists » -- All Rd 7 Games
BigFooty Tipping Notice Img
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 7
The Golden Ticket - Corporate tickets, functions, Open Air Boxes at the Adelaide Oval, ENGIE, Gabba, MCG, Marvel, Optus & People First Stadiums. Corporate Suites at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Not reallyIt’s farcical these “academies”. For kids raised on footy, they should never ever be part of academies. Son of an AFL player? What a joke the system is
I calculated from pick 2 3 where we should have been picking and ending up at 7 8 we lost points value equivalent to pick 6 (for all the people who don't want to compare via points its just a good reference to see how costly it is)We need to ask the AFL for some compensation, thats 2 years in a row now our 1st picks will get pushed down the order because of these rules.
Not good enough
Jesus if we can add this bloke then our midfield will be set
Best players are mostly dual position and Shai comes to mind automatically along with Izak RankinWhy play him in the midfield when he’s an elite forward.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Best players are mostly dual position and Shai comes to mind automatically along with Izak Rankin
Hope notI think our midfield is done. If anything we need ruck talent. Maybe Arki for a medium forward. But I doubt he’s ours next year. He’ll be a E-girl for sure
Hope not
I dont believe our midfield is done and need another 1-2 multi positional players looking beyond Tarant/Hopper/Prestia/Ross
Lalor - Smillie - Hotton - Cumming and hopefully McAuliffe & Campbell
Ruck im not fussed about and just grab a competent Ruck from another club after they have gone 60-70% into developing them. Nic Madden is a player i hope we are talking to as he fits perfectly
Exactly.I just love how our club is not swayed by media or emotion. Think for themselves. If you like a kid, then you take him. If Blair was at Norf last year they would have taken Tauru at 2 last year.
Hotton isn’t a pure mid. Will spend a lot of time forward. Ditto Lalor (not sure he has the hamstrings to be a full time mid). Smillie I have genuinely put a line through. Won’t make it. Bust. Grlj is a back flanker. KMac won’t make it - VFL player. Cumming is a hybrid.Hotton, Lalor, Smil, Grlj, mcauliffe & Cumming is 6 mids that we have.
Didn’t think we would need more.
But I suppose you could add Armstrong.
Arki butler could play in the middle if needed.
Hotton isn’t a pure mid. Will spend a lot of time forward. Ditto Lalor (not sure he has the hamstrings to be a full time mid). Smillie I have genuinely put a line through. Won’t make it. Bust. Grlj is a back flanker. KMac won’t make it - VFL player. Cumming is a hybrid.
We need at least two more star mids.
You’ve put the line through a kid who hasn’t even had a chance yet. That’s pretty averageHotton isn’t a pure mid. Will spend a lot of time forward. Ditto Lalor (not sure he has the hamstrings to be a full time mid). Smillie I have genuinely put a line through. Won’t make it. Bust. Grlj is a back flanker. KMac won’t make it - VFL player. Cumming is a hybrid.
We need at least two more star mids.
Pretty standard for BigFooty. So many Richmond “fans” are only happy when they’re throwing rocks at the club.You’ve put the line through a kid who hasn’t even had a chance yet. That’s pretty average
Hotton isn’t a pure mid. Will spend a lot of time forward. Ditto Lalor (not sure he has the hamstrings to be a full time mid). Smillie I have genuinely put a line through. Won’t make it. Bust. Grlj is a back flanker. KMac won’t make it - VFL player. Cumming is a hybrid.
We need at least two more star mids.
Hotton isn’t a pure mid. Will spend a lot of time forward. Ditto Lalor (not sure he has the hamstrings to be a full time mid). Smillie I have genuinely put a line through. Won’t make it. Bust. Grlj is a back flanker. KMac won’t make it - VFL player. Cumming is a hybrid.
We need at least two more star mids.
Our midfield is done? Are you serious?I think our midfield is done. If anything we need ruck talent. Maybe Arki for a medium forward. But I doubt he’s ours next year. He’ll be a E-girl for sure
I just love how our club is not swayed by media or emotion. Think for themselves. If you like a kid, then you take him. If Blair was at Norf last year they would have taken Tauru at 2 last year.
I think our midfield is done. If anything we need ruck talent. Maybe Arki for a medium forward. But I doubt he’s ours next year. He’ll be a E-girl for sure
Your presuming that every player picked now is going to make it. Also our midfield is hardly done. We need wings they are considered part of the midfield.
Yeah well, I’m talking about our centre bounce. We have one injured wing, Judson. Hopefully the knee holds up. He could be a Lachie Whitfield type. But I’m suprised we didn’t grab a winger in the draft tbh. Maybe that’s what there planning to do in the near future with free agency.
I'm just massively annoyed so I'm pretty negative right now. We did pick a wing Mr pick 99. Club is keen to turn him into a success story so they can tell us how smart they all are.
Sometimes the best thing to do is not to out think it and pick best available.
The club can't honestly tell me these players picked were best available.
Cumming was best available.I'm just massively annoyed so I'm pretty negative right now. We did pick a wing Mr pick 99. Club is keen to turn him into a success story so they can tell us how smart they all are.
Sometimes the best thing to do is not to out think it and pick best available.
The club can't honestly tell me these players picked were best available.