- Joined
- Mar 14, 2006
- Posts
- 1,084
- Reaction score
- 855
- Location
- Victoria
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Mega Drive, Super Nintendo, Amiga
Great crowd at the G.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

Fantasy Footy Notice Image Round 12
SuperCoach Rd 12 SC Talk - Trade Talk - Capt/VC - 2026 Fight MND Comp ,//, AFL Fantasy Rd 12 AFF Talk - AF Trades - Capt/VC
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
27,013 in Round 1 2015.What's the Demons biggest home crowd vs the Suns? Think that may be broken next week.
Not at all. Just explaining logic that can swell some crowds well beyond expectations. Blues hardly expected to be deep finalists so there’s other factors that drive it.dave10
Respect your tenure fella, but to undermine this one as circumstantial must mean then, that all other stand out crowds fall under the same?
Absolutely the ingredients you point out did enhance the crowd.Not at all. Just explaining logic that can swell some crowds well beyond expectations. Blues hardly expected to be deep finalists so there’s other factors that drive it.
Early season Sunny afternoon slots in Melbourne traditionally surprise to the upside early in the season, certainly for competitive / intriguing games. Just noting with hindsight, this had several ingredients that’s all.
You’re not the only salty one this year!Absolutely the ingredients you point out did enhance the crowd.
My point is that every stand out crowd had ingredients that grew it to be notably large. Fine to unearth those reasons, just read it as a little salted out with the use of word 'expected'.
Here I now am salty, crowd proud though.
Not a single change it gets broken on Easter Sunday which is probably the second worst day to play football after Mother’s Day.What's the Demons biggest home crowd vs the Suns? Think that may be broken next week.
Wow. That is massive overs for mine. I genuinely thought this was sub 30,000 k on a cold Saturday night with our poor form.I don’t have an official crowd but they announced that the crowd last night at Bombers / Kangaroos was 41,000+.
Amazing what happens when you don’t force punters to pay $55 for a seat in the nosebleeds.Wow. That is massive overs for mine. I genuinely thought this was sub 30,000 k on a cold Saturday night with our poor form.
Put team form to one side, and these last two Melbourne games prove that the average fan will turn up when the game is expected to be close, and there's genuine uncertainty over who will win, where both average sentiment, people doing their footy tips earlier in the week, and the bookmaker odds all suggest generally that you can't be confident over which team will win the game Something that the AFLW could learn form, but I digress.Amazing what happens when you don’t force punters to pay $55 for a seat in the nosebleeds.
Why? Melbourne and Carlton Dre between 38-47k every year until both teams were in th top 4 and it capped at 55k and 68k both on Saturday nights in top 4 clashes.
How many times have they played on a Sunday afternoon in April? I'm not surprised this game drew 68,000 tbh. Carlton are an enormous club and an up about Melbourne always draw large crowds.
There is a misconception that Melbourne is a small club like North, St Kilda and the Dogs but they consistantly proven they are a much bigger club if competitive.
Not sure the other evidence shows that they are bigger, more just that their supporters are better at going to games.How many times have they played on a Sunday afternoon in April? I'm not surprised this game drew 68,000 tbh. Carlton are an enormous club and an up about Melbourne always draw large crowds to the MCG.
There is a misconception that Melbourne is a small club like North, St Kilda and the Dogs but that is not the case at all. They are a much bigger club (in Victoria).
Disagree - one piece of evidence of this is people nominating Melbourne as their favourite team in polling is smaller than every other club in Victoria bar North:How many times have they played on a Sunday afternoon in April? I'm not surprised this game drew 68,000 tbh. Carlton are an enormous club and an up about Melbourne always draw large crowds to the MCG.
There is a misconception that Melbourne is a small club like North, St Kilda and the Dogs but that is not the case at all. They are a much bigger club (in Victoria).
Anzac Eve needs to stay above 70k but this will be the most challenging year for that I suspect. Its good that they are selling GA tickets and are going to allow a GA rollup.Blues and Dee’s the crowd of the year so far by a long way. Nearly 70,000.
That’s an Anzac eve marquee type attendance.
So, Hawthorn should play four games in Tasmania just in there is a season where a home games might only draw 22K? Makes no sense. Play those four games in Melbourne and an extra 100k would attend.Nothing, it's just that it would inevitably lead to crowds of 22,000 against GC somewhere along the cycle, which Hawks want to avoid and therefore they're not "missing out" by taking games to Launceston, what sparked this debate
Dude, I'm just relaying information from people high up in the Hawks and Tassie and people associated with them that I've heard. I have no idea or I'm not providing commentary on it, just that everyone who makes the decisions and that are party to it seem to be happy with it, it seems to be a successful venture beyond just the headline attendance numbers, and Hawthorn have a genuine home ground advantage there in a sporting sense. And there's very minimal Hawks member grumbling as well (you aside), possibly because there isn't much fan demand for a Docklands home game in a half-empty stadium with zero away supporters that would be played if there were more games in Melbourne, so there's not much complaints for avoiding such a game.So, Hawthorn should play four games in Tasmania just in there is a season where a home games might only draw 22K? Makes no sense. Play those four games in Melbourne and an extra 100k would attend.
Yep, as someone who moved to Victoria, there's definitely a lot more Dees supporters than what a lot of people think.How many times have they played on a Sunday afternoon in April? I'm not surprised this game drew 68,000 tbh. Carlton are an enormous club and an up about Melbourne always draw large crowds to the MCG.
There is a misconception that Melbourne is a small club like North, St Kilda and the Dogs but that is not the case at all. They are a much bigger club (in Victoria).
They have the MCC advantage.
Disagree - one piece of evidence of this is people nominating Melbourne as their favourite team in polling is smaller than every other club in Victoria bar North:
This almost lines up perfectly with 2025 membership numbers which the bottom clubs were ordered in the exact same way - North fewest polled fans, fewest members, Melbourne second-fewest fans, second-fewest members in Victoria.
That being said, Melbourne being an MCG tenant club will always lead to greater attendances when they're the away team at the MCG (in contrast to Saints, North and Dogs' away attendances when they play their away games at Docklands being much lower than their home crowds). This is because of Melbourne having ~10,000 of their club members being MCC/AFL Gold members (who do not care for home or away), plus the fact that the bigger GA capacity for away fans meaning that your typical reserved seat holders in home games feel happy sitting in GA seats because there's lots of space, vs a Dogs/Saints/North reserved seat holder maybe not liking Docklands GA where they don't want to sit next to an opposition fan.