Remove this Banner Ad

Past #29: Will Phillips [Part II] - delisted end '26 - 50 NM games/8 NM goals - Farewell Sweet Prince

Does he stay, goes or is rookied....

  • He Stays and is offered another year..

    Votes: 37 53.6%
  • He Goes

    Votes: 30 43.5%
  • He is rookied

    Votes: 2 2.9%

  • Total voters
    69
  • Poll closed .

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

God damn. Really thought he’d be retained considering our lack of midfield depth.

Hope he gets an oppurtunity elsewhere.
I’m probably the opposite.

I knew he was on thin ice and I really don’t care whether he gets an opportunity elsewhere.

I just want NM to be a decent team again someday.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Will
robin williams its not your fault GIF
 
Watched some of his games in the VFL this year. Fair to say there is not much call for slowish, neat footballers anymore. Looked like a real prospect in Year 1 but never developed from there.

Thanks for trying. Absolute professional.
 
We move on.
Exactly. While we could find reasons to give Will one more year (even though those reasons are more around our lack of midfield depth than Will's career prospects and talent), ultimately, I think it's pretty clear that Will would be at best a break-glass option, and that's for a shit bottom 3 side, mind you.

Best we just move on.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Derksen (if he gets delisted) or maybe Blight as a big bodied stopper. Supposedly Blight doesn’t pass the character test though!
What Character test is this
A sit down meeting with the NMFC Woke Empire members eating Scones with cream and jam ,cucumber sandwiches with sort of decaf beverage to drink agreeing with every BS thing they say?
 
Lovely guy but what an awful draft selection. Remarkable how bad we got it
Hey Uncle_Leo, I think your being a wee bit harsh on the young man, I mean he's had so many setbacks in his short career + the ill-fated illness that many athletes don't recover fully from, if that had not have happened who knows, but it did and really only being able to play mid probably didn't help his cause, the actual draft selection was okay, if you look at that draft its turning into a bit of a horror show, we liked Elijah Hollands, how did that turn out? We have made some bad draft selections over the years, but this is not one of them. All recruiters know that sometimes you get it wrong and sometimes the players you choose don't go on the next level for a variety of reasons, that is life, you move on and don't dwell on it. :)
 
When will this clubs player Devolpment get reviewed?

Between 2001 & now our club has had the most 1st round selections of any AFL side ever.

We should be a dynastic premiership side by now, besides Wells & Sheezel we’ve managed to flunk every single last one of ‘em.
 
Hope he gets another chance somewhere else, but hard to disagree with this call. I still think he can be a valuable part of another team, and a fresh start will do him wonders.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Hey Uncle_Leo, I think your being a wee bit harsh on the young man, I mean he's had so many setbacks in his short career + the ill-fated illness that many athletes don't recover fully from, if that had not have happened who knows, but it did and really only being able to play mid probably didn't help his cause, the actual draft selection was okay, if you look at that draft its turning into a bit of a horror show, we liked Elijah Hollands, how did that turn out? We have made some bad draft selections over the years, but this is not one of them. All recruiters know that sometimes you get it wrong and sometimes the players you choose don't go on the next level for a variety of reasons, that is life, you move on and don't dwell on it. :)
Love Will. Ripping person, always up for interacting with fans, but I think it was the right call to move on.
I had hoped this year was going to be different, as he told me he was in ripping nick after an uninterrupted preseason, but it looks like he just couldn't get over those illnesses to be able to run hard in transition and be damaging enough with his ball use like most modern mids. I wish him all the best. Hope he gets a fresh start somewhere else and enjoys his footy.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Past #29: Will Phillips [Part II] - delisted end '26 - 50 NM games/8 NM goals - Farewell Sweet Prince

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top