Remove this Banner Ad

Past #29: Will Phillips [Part II] - delisted end '26 - 50 NM games/8 NM goals - Farewell Sweet Prince

Does he stay, goes or is rookied....

  • He Stays and is offered another year..

    Votes: 37 53.6%
  • He Goes

    Votes: 30 43.5%
  • He is rookied

    Votes: 2 2.9%

  • Total voters
    69
  • Poll closed .

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Roo roo roo there's a reason you're on ignore. Ya ****ing nuts. Scott is better than stout Will, not thats saying much. The rest were all delisted.

I thought you were listing players that should have been delisted instead of Woeful Will.

I don't disagree they're all as bad as each other
How could i possibly name 40 players that currently should be delisted instead considering we have 42 on our list.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Kayne turner, b Scott, Marley Williams, Pittard, Polec, Ed vickers Willis, dom Tyson, Tom Campbell, Paul ahern, Nathan hrovat, Curtis Taylor, Darcy tucker, Josh walker, T Murphy, Kyron Hayden, Boner, Jack Mahoney, Lachie young, lazzoro, menadue, hosie, Flynn perez, atu, spicer, kal dawson, bergman, howe, drury, ty seller, biggy, Alex Morgan, josh Williams, Dan Nielsen, brayden preuss, Declan mountford, Mitchell hiberd, Billy hartung, Paul ahern, Eddie ford, Caleb Daniel, fisher, ccj.

Hope that’s enough for you dinkers

He wasn't better than at least a third of this list at AFL level, and many of them were better state league players too. Take off the pick 3/good bloke glasses
 
Was a big Will fan, but can't say anything about our selection of him at 3. Was rated to go in top 6.
As others have pointed out only a few hits in the first 20 that year. I am sure we would gone thilthorpe if he was there at 3. Holmes at 20 would have been great, but a stretch at 3.
Hope you go well Will.
As for people saying he was a shit footballer you are just wrong. Lacked fitness yes. We can argue why this was so, but shit player that's a lot of crap!
 
Really sad. One of my real favourites.

Complete professional, mature and had a real love for the club - and seemingly was great to have round the club. Stayed and fought for his spot and deserved to succeed.

Compare this to the attitudes and behaviours of some others we've seen in recent times.

Really hope Will gets another crack somewhere and I'll be looking forward to seeing what comes next for him. Feel like the organisation will lose something with his departure.
 
Kayne turner, b Scott, Marley Williams, Pittard, Polec, Ed vickers Willis, dom Tyson, Tom Campbell, Paul ahern, Nathan hrovat, Curtis Taylor, Darcy tucker, Josh walker, T Murphy, Kyron Hayden, Boner, Jack Mahoney, Lachie young, lazzoro, menadue, hosie, Flynn perez, atu, spicer, kal dawson, bergman, howe, drury, ty seller, biggy, Alex Morgan, josh Williams, Dan Nielsen, brayden preuss, Declan mountford, Mitchell hiberd, Billy hartung, Paul ahern, Eddie ford, Caleb Daniel, fisher, ccj.

Hope that’s enough for you dinkers

About half of them last played for us over 5 years ago. Paul Ahern on the list twice.

The first five on your list were better AFL players than Will, too (and I was a big Kayno knocker), as were a few of the others.

Perhaps you should have just admitted you exaggerated.
 
Kayne turner, b Scott, Marley Williams, Pittard, Polec, Ed vickers Willis, dom Tyson, Tom Campbell, Paul ahern, Nathan hrovat, Curtis Taylor, Darcy tucker, Josh walker, T Murphy, Kyron Hayden, Boner, Jack Mahoney, Lachie young, lazzoro, menadue, hosie, Flynn perez, atu, spicer, kal dawson, bergman, howe, drury, ty seller, biggy, Alex Morgan, josh Williams, Dan Nielsen, brayden preuss, Declan mountford, Mitchell hiberd, Billy hartung, Paul ahern, Eddie ford, Caleb Daniel, fisher, ccj.

Hope that’s enough for you dinkers

Some mistakes here and there but shit what an awesome comeback in just a few minutes

GIF by Quizizz
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Kayne turner, b Scott, Marley Williams, Pittard, Polec, Ed vickers Willis, dom Tyson, Tom Campbell, Paul ahern, Nathan hrovat, Curtis Taylor, Darcy tucker, Josh walker, T Murphy, Kyron Hayden, Boner, Jack Mahoney, Lachie young, lazzoro, menadue, hosie, Flynn perez, atu, spicer, kal dawson, bergman, howe, drury, ty seller, biggy, Alex Morgan, josh Williams, Dan Nielsen, brayden preuss, Declan mountford, Mitchell hiberd, Billy hartung, Paul ahern, Eddie ford, Caleb Daniel, fisher, ccj.

Hope that’s enough for you dinkers
Looking at that list, I am disappointed and ashamed that I wasn’t drafted by North in the last 10 years.

And you didn’t even name Tom Wilkinson who left the club to go appear on The Amazing Race.

We are garbage
 
Kayne turner, b Scott, Marley Williams, Pittard, Polec, Ed vickers Willis, dom Tyson, Tom Campbell, Paul ahern, Nathan hrovat, Curtis Taylor, Darcy tucker, Josh walker, T Murphy, Kyron Hayden, Boner, Jack Mahoney, Lachie young, lazzoro, menadue, hosie, Flynn perez, atu, spicer, kal dawson, bergman, howe, drury, ty seller, biggy, Alex Morgan, josh Williams, Dan Nielsen, brayden preuss, Declan mountford, Mitchell hiberd, Billy hartung, Paul ahern, Eddie ford, Caleb Daniel, fisher, ccj.

Hope that’s enough for you dinkers

Oh Rawling
 
Really sad. One of my real favourites.

Complete professional, mature and had a real love for the club - and seemingly was great to have round the club. Stayed and fought for his spot and deserved to succeed.


Compare this to the attitudes and behaviours of some others we've seen in recent times.

Really hope Will gets another crack somewhere and I'll be looking forward to seeing what comes next for him. Feel like the organisation will lose something with his departure.

Even if he was no closer to the senior team despite six solid weeks of VFL, there he’d be near the front row in the rooms at the coach’s address with a massive smile on his face taking every word in with the best attitude you’ve ever seen.
 
Probably to counter the 'he'll win a Brownlow at another club' crowd.
yes, look at all those posts claiming that, my gosh they are everyehere, cant swing a cat in here for all the brownlow predictions
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

TT was an academy rort to begin with, we traded JHF for Wardlaw and Goad, and everyone else taken in 2020 was a bust anyway. Whatever.
Every successful team have high profile busts.

Dees with Toumpas etc
Lions with Schache
Hawks with DGB

We also never really celebrate Xerri and Curtis becoming a graders from deep in the draft.
 
Every successful team have high profile busts.

Dees with Toumpas etc
Lions with Schache
Hawks with DGB

We also never really celebrate Xerri and Curtis becoming a graders from deep in the draft.
not to mention Larkey and Zurhaar.

I agree, I'm not saying we shouldn't be critical of things at the club but our high pick drafting is a silly thing to focus on, especially those 3 examples where really only Will was taken higher than he deserved, JHF didn't want to stay and we got fair value, and TT destroyed his own life but from what I can tell the club did everything they could to get him on a better path, and any other club would've taken him given the opportunity.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Past #29: Will Phillips [Part II] - delisted end '26 - 50 NM games/8 NM goals - Farewell Sweet Prince

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top