Past 3. Marc Murphy

[1981]

From what I've been told its got less to do with possible success as it does money, which is fair enough.

 

[Jimmae]

My proposal is premised on both having two good years left. If confident Kreuzer lasts until 2022 I agree with you. Is that likely? He is 28. When do ruckmen usually play until?

I look it as these two guys in 2022 versus two Zac Fishers.

Don't need link but would love you to PM me some of your past comments/suggestions. I like to know who has a history of calling it the right way so I can pay more attention to their POV. Makes sure I don't re-enforce personal bias in what I read.

1. While he's talented and capable I'm not sure the team will be inherently improved by adding 2 more of Zac Fisher to the list.

2. How delusional are you that you want me to sit down with you and demonstrate my worth to you because you have the faintest curiosity. Why on earth would I spend my time this way? You're going to have to be far more specific for me to lend you a hand on my posting history.

 

[ESKIE]

1. While he's talented and capable I'm not sure the team will be inherently improved by adding 2 more of Zac Fisher to the list.

2. How delusional are you that you want me to sit down with you and demonstrate my worth to you because you have the faintest curiosity. Why on earth would I spend my time this way?

 

[Soapy V]

Murphy will stay and it will be settled soon. Loves the club and they love him



ps. this is based on a gut feel and with absolutely no inside info

 

[AxeCapital2000]

1. While he's talented and capable I'm not sure the team will be inherently improved by adding 2 more of Zac Fisher to the list.

2. How delusional are you that you want me to sit down with you and demonstrate my worth to you because you have the faintest curiosity. Why on earth would I spend my time this way? You're going to have to be far more specific for me to lend you a hand on my posting history.

I try not to be but you were so forthright in your view I assumed you had a well known track record to post in such a manner.

 

[Arr0w]

Murphy will stay and it will be settled soon. Loves the club and they love him



ps. this is based on a gut feel and with absolutely no inside info

Soap cut it out, opinions just won't do

 

[gardiner stand]

Maybe he wants a crack at a premiership before he retires? Definitely not gonna happen if he stays with us, sadly. I don't think thats particularly selfish of him after 12 years of service.

Ask Deledio how that turned out for him

 

[passmark]

He can do what he likes as far as I'm concerned .

He doesn't owe the club anything and I'm happy for the club to work on a future without him.

if we do decide to go on without him I just hope they do it with respect . It costs nothing and, in of itself, is good publicity for the club if we do it properly.

 

[Jimmae]

I try not to be but you were so forthright in your view I assumed you had a well known track record to post in such a manner.

I suppose I shouldn't expect much more of your trading analysis given your username, but you're sorely forgetting that we're talking about 2 significant individuals among an organisation of about 200 here, not economic units you can exchange with ease.

 

[AxeCapital2000]

I suppose I shouldn't expect much more of your trading analysis given your username, but you're sorely forgetting that we're talking about 2 significant individuals among an organisation of about 200 here, not economic units you can exchange with ease.

Mitchell. Hodge. Hawthorn

 

[Arr0w]

Ask Deledio how that turned out for him

Or perhaps Brian Lake

 

[Jimmae]

Mitchell. Hodge. Hawthorn

Mitchell (34 at the time) was a godfather trade that gave them much needed salary cap relief to move on, as was Lewis (30). Lewis wouldn't have been played regularly if he'd stayed, while Mitchell would have retired.

Hodge (33) had retired, and pulled a Brett Favre.

 

[AxeCapital2000]

All three have different reasons. The club handled it well and the result was positive for the club. If other clubs can manage such exits to their advantage why can't we?

 

[Jimmae]

All three have different reasons. The club handled it well and the result was positive for the club. If other clubs can manage such exits to their advantage why can't we?

Can you even name who'd be left on our list over the age of 27 when you're done?

Our over 24s are largely a shit show, and you want to take 2 of the 5 good ones we have, and go to the draft with 4 top 20 picks... again? Come on mate.

I think I might just stop rewarding your profligacy.

 

[AxeCapital2000]

Can you even name who'd be left on our list over the age of 27 when you're done?

Our over 24s are largely a shit show, and you want to take 2 of the 5 good ones we have, and go to the draft with 4 top 20 picks... again? Come on mate.

I think I might just stop rewarding your profligacy.

Great servants to the club. Are they really great leaders? I back Cripps and Docherty to set the culture.

Funny I am delusional but you think responding to me rewards me

 

[gardiner stand]

Or perhaps Brian Lake

Or even Nathan Buckley

 

[koutamarto]

Just saw Murphy’s interview in the carpark on the news. Well his stock standard response of “ i’ll sit down with my manager” when asked about his future sums up Murphy and the CFC since he was drafted. Petulant and selfish!!

Why can’t he just say “ I love the club and I want to stay and help because it’s more important than me finding personal success at another club which is not guaranteed anyway”?

If it’s money then really it can’t be much more than he’s already getting so I’d call that selfish and it just proves that he’s always been about the cash. If he leaves for success then he can’t really have his heart in the club.

Personally I hope he goes because that Ratten era of Murphy Gibbs Judd Fevola was a cancer borne of selfishness.

His response all year has been he wants to stay and be a one club player. He has stated the same today I believe.

 

[Bluebag13]

Some 2nd hand news, not sure if posted thought i would past it on.

Murphy likely to stay, tested the waters was offered around 350-400 and 2 years from 2 clubs. Carlton paying closer to 600 and 2 years.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

[Bluechip66]

Or even Nathan Buckley

Bryce Gibbs......too early? Lol

 

[Soapy V]

Or perhaps Brian Lake

Greg Wells

 

[NumberEight]

Just go Murph. All in or not at all. And please take the Vet with you.

 

[Arr0w]

Or even Nathan Buckley

Or Burgoyne, Hale, Frawley, Dew

 

[AxeCapital2000]

Some 2nd hand news, not sure if posted thought i would past it on.

Murphy likely to stay, tested the waters was offered around 350-400 and 2 years from 2 clubs. Carlton paying closer to 600 and 2 years.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

That $600k better have heavy incentive clauses. Why two years? Over 30 and injury prone. 1 year contract.

 

[AxeCapital2000]

Ask Deledio how that turned out for him

Funny when GWS slipped outside the 8 I bet on them for the flag. Last week I got on them to go the rest of the year undefeated.

My bookie loves me for a reason

 

[Cripps 'n' Blue Bloods]

AxeCap- if u need further help about who to listen too please just ask , I’m sure a few of us will be willing to help....

Here’s a tip, don’t listen to me.