Player Watch #31: Josh Goater - re-signed until the end of 2025 - ruptured Achilles injury vs GWS

[DuckYeah]

Grow up

No! * the spoiled campaigner. He is bordering 25 years old. What the * is that teaching the kids? Want me tp grow up? TT needs to *in grow up
campaigner.

Replace him with Goater plus a first round pick. * petulant players. * polec and * TT (right now)

 

[The Nostradamus]

Give us a debut announcement!

 

[the flying ham]

Get him in!

 

[Johnny99]

Should have got a game before Arch jnr.

 

[RossHenshaw]

Should have got a game before Arch jnr.

These decisions are player killers .
We have a top 2nd round pick kid. Killing it a junior level & pre season without a sniff of getting selected for a game after 16 rounds .
We are the best at killing careers off early in kids .

 

[Mav]

These decisions are player killers .
We have a top 2nd round pick kid. Killing it a junior level & pre season without a sniff of getting selected for a game after 16 rounds .
We are the best at killing careers off early in kids .

Mate, it would just be nice to get a first year player through the year without getting injured.

 

[DarkPhoenix]

No! * the spoiled campaigner. He is bordering 25 years old. What the * is that teaching the kids? Want me tp grow up? TT needs to *in grow up
campaigner.

Replace him with Goater plus a first round pick. * petulant players. * polec and * TT (right now)

Bordering 25? he's JUST turned 22. By your logic, he's 20.

 

[marklovesbeer]

These decisions are player killers .
We have a top 2nd round pick kid. Killing it a junior level & pre season without a sniff of getting selected for a game after 16 rounds .
We are the best at killing careers off early in kids .

How do you know what boxes the club has set him to tick before he gets a game?

He’s a life long supporter who’s been at the club as a player for 7 months & you’re already grouping him with players who’ve had their ‘career killed off early’?

Calm down mate.

 

[DunderHead]

How do you know what boxes the club has set him to tick before he gets a game?

He’s a life long supporter who’s been at the club as a player for 7 months & you’re already grouping him with players who’ve had their ‘career killed off early’?

Calm down mate.

Lol.

He's in the I'm upset we're losing club. So he finds any and every reason to be angry with decisions that are being made. It feels right so he must be right.

 

[The Y Factor]

How do you know what boxes the club has set him to tick before he gets a game?

He’s a life long supporter who’s been at the club as a player for 7 months & you’re already grouping him with players who’ve had their ‘career killed off early’?

Calm down mate.

Correct - The club spoke to this in a semi- recent video.

Goater wasn’t ready to play as a defender when he arrived so they are teaching him.He’s doing well and zi suspect he’ll see the 1sts before years end.

But why rush him when he’s just hitting his straps

 

[ferball]

Lol.

He's in the I'm upset we're losing club. So he finds any and every reason to be angry with decisions that are being made. It feels right so he must be right.

There's a few people in that club right now.

 

[The Y Factor]

There's a few people in that club right now.

There are plenty - me included

But not everyone trashed the club or individual players every other post as a way of dealing with it

 

[RossHenshaw]

How do you know what boxes the club has set him to tick before he gets a game?

He’s a life long supporter who’s been at the club as a player for 7 months & you’re already grouping him with players who’ve had their ‘career killed off early’?

Calm down mate.

All I’m saying is that by now he would of been ahead of Bergman & Archer who have both tasted the AFL .
Plus by now I don’t trust or believe in the club “tick the boxes” rule .
It’s adamant we don’t have NFI what we are doing…..
Why don’t you calm down & have another beer

 

[Masked Avenger]

There are plenty - me included

But not everyone trashed the club or individual players every other post as a way of dealing with it

Yep. There's also a limit to how many times you can hear how bad something is that you give a stuff about. Thankfully, there are a few at least that have decided the better bet is to focus on solutions.

 

[RossHenshaw]

Lol.

He's in the I'm upset we're losing club. So he finds any and every reason to be angry with decisions that are being made. It feels right so he must be right.

Im upset like all of us in our performance. I love the club & have supported it with a membership for 30+ years . My comments are just a fact on how we have brought potential talent in the past and have done nothing with it . I don’t what this to happen again . Kids get demoralised & lose confidence very quick at this age .
See you all in Geelong today ? Go North

 

[Usayed Givashe]

Correct - The club spoke to this in a semi- recent video.

Goater wasn’t ready to play as a defender when he arrived so they are teaching him.He’s doing well and zi suspect he’ll see the 1sts before years end.

But why rush him when he’s just hitting his straps

I didn’t realise he was Trans.

How fabulous!

 

[The Y Factor]

Yep. There's also a limit to how many times you can hear how bad something is that you give a stuff about. Thankfully, there are a few at least that have decided the better bet is to focus on solutions.

I get it - I just believe that even the worst player or coaching decision has good intent so needs some level of respect if if its critical or constructive disappointment etc.

 

[Passmore]

I didn’t realise he was Trans.

How fabulous!

We’re targeting the market. Innovative as always.

 

[Roosurgence]

These decisions are player killers .
We have a top 2nd round pick kid. Killing it a junior level & pre season without a sniff of getting selected for a game after 16 rounds .
We are the best at killing careers off early in kids .

Why Goater wasn’t given a game instead of bringing in Atu has me ducked!

Atu is a spud!

 

[RossHenshaw]

Why Goater wasn’t given a game instead of bringing in Atu has me ducked!

Atu is a spud!

19 disposals today @ nearly 80% efficiency , 8 tackles .
Love to know what “box” he needs to tick still ?!

 

[Passmore]

Good to see him running into some form.

Sent from my SM-A908B using Tapatalk

 

[Steele7]

Would of given Goater a bit of a run in the centre bounce

 

[Roosurgence]

19 disposals today @ nearly 80% efficiency , 8 tackles .
Love to know what “box” he needs to tick still ?!

Once the box on the David Noble exit form is signed, we might see deserving players rewarded.

 

[Usayed Givashe]

19 disposals today @ nearly 80% efficiency , 8 tackles .
Love to know what “box” he needs to tick still ?!

Imagine playing Young, Atu, Walker, Turner, Mahony and others ahead of this guy.

 

[Shinboner1]

wonder if he gets a run next week as turner is out with concussion