AFL Player 31: Zach Reid

[Lore]

 

[eth-dog]

Well they barely kicked a footy in 2020

How the hell do you count that?

You made a mistake in your wording. Own it.

 

[Keystone agony]

How the hell do you count that?

You made a mistake in your wording. Own it.

I didnt

 

[citizen-erased]

Delist!


But seriously, it is a massive concern that Reid, Cox and Jones can't get on the field. And that's a chunk of our wannabe spine for the next decade.

I think we forget their young talls sometimes though.
in most clubs you generally give them the first two years as a development pass before you want to see them in the side

if we'd invested a little more in the spine since Knights, we'd probably be in a position to let these kids develop into their bodies and bring them in when the current incumbents in defence and up forward are ready for replacing.
one F/S fwd + one late draft speculative KPD before we drafted Jones, Cox, Reid, Eyre, Brand & Hayes.

 

[bombreys]

Definitely becoming a bit of a concern.

We seem to be so far behind in player development. Richmond just played a final with a first year KPD.

 

[faible]

Definitely becoming a bit of a concern.

We seem to be so far behind in player development. Richmond just played a final with a first year KPD.

How old was the rest of their defence around that first year KPD?

 

[bombreys]

How old was the rest of their defence around that first year KPD?

A good mix - Gibcus with mainly Tarrant, Broad, Balta, Grimes, Vlastuin & Short.

No real different to us.

Their average age 27.

Ours (Cutler, Ridley, Laverde, Kelly, Redman, BZT, Heppell) just over 26.

 

[faible]

A good mix - Gibcus with mainly Tarrant, Broad, Balta, Grimes, Vlastuin & Short.

No real different to us.

Their average age 27.

Ours (Cutler, Ridley, Laverde, Kelly, Redman, BZT, Heppell) just over 26.

Remove Heppell who's playing on the wing and recalculate, remove Cutler who only covered injury and recalculate.

Then consider how many games those players remaining have played, and how many of them have been in defence.

Richmond's backline is far easier to play in as a young KPD than ours.

 

[citizen-erased]

Remove Heppell who's playing on the wing and recalculate, remove Cutler who only covered injury and recalculate.

Then consider how many games those players remaining have played, and how many of them have been in defence.

Richmond's backline is far easier to play in as a young KPD than ours.

premiership backline no less
vs. one that has leaked scores for years.

 

[andleanback]

Are they going to update us on Reid, or are we to assume it’s worst than they originally said. Almost mid February and he isn’t back to running yet.

 

[yodellinhank]

Are they going to update us on Reid, or are we to assume it’s worst than they originally said. Almost mid February and he isn’t back to running yet.

Back to running? I don't think he's ever been up to running, has he?
Reid
There you go, I ruled a line through him.

 

[ant555]

Are they going to update us on Reid, or are we to assume it’s worst than they originally said. Almost mid February and he isn’t back to running yet.

Can not give you an official update but Saturday he just did 5 minutes of handball so it doesn’t look all the good right now. I doubt he is playing before mid season.

 

[andleanback]

Can not give you an official update but Saturday he just did 5 minutes of handball so it doesn’t look all the good right now. I doubt he is playing before mid season.

If I recall originally they said he would have a modified program for a few weeks. It’s been 2 months and all he’s doing is handballing. It would be great if afl clubs in general were much more transparent with how players are tracking. Is it much worse than first thought? Has he had a set back? Are they taking extra precaution? Not that hard to announce a simple update.

 

[TheGrizz]

Three stress related back injuries in three years. I can see why we drafted Lewis Hayes.

 

[citizen-erased]

There's an irony that dodoro preaches get the spine right and drafts a(nother) kid whose spine we can't get right

Hopefully sorts itself out a la Ridley. And soon.

 

[faible]

Hopefully sorts itself out a la Ridley. And soon.

No rush, we've got James Stewart for another 2 years remember?

 

[Nifft]

No rush, we've got James Stewart for another 2 years remember?

 

[citizen-erased]

No rush, we've got James Stewart for another 2 years remember?

i was making light fun...but you had to take it too far

In Zerk we trust.

 

[Don Won]

If I recall originally they said he would have a modified program for a few weeks. It’s been 2 months and all he’s doing is handballing. It would be great if afl clubs in general were much more transparent with how players are tracking. Is it much worse than first thought? Has he had a set back? Are they taking extra precaution? Not that hard to announce a simple update.

I remember training watchers saying that he was distraught after receiving news, but then they released a relatively mild prognosis. It didn’t really add up

 

[Vander18]

Skinny talls with narrow shoulders - a pattern is starting to emerge. It’s a body type to be avoided I reckon.

 

[BringFevBack2021]

If I recall originally they said he would have a modified program for a few weeks. It’s been 2 months and all he’s doing is handballing. It would be great if afl clubs in general were much more transparent with how players are tracking. Is it much worse than first thought? Has he had a set back? Are they taking extra precaution? Not that hard to announce a simple update.

More than handballing. Yet to do a full session however.

Maybe first month he misses.

 

[BrunoV]

Skinny talls with narrow shoulders - a pattern is starting to emerge. It’s a body type to be avoided I reckon.

Yep. Put a line through that, certainly in the top 15.

It's not just being thin. Danier, McKay and the Kings do not have powerhouse builds but the proportions are there.

It's proportions that don't looking like they can hold weight.

 

[ant555]

Just shows how much a freak Fletcher was.

 

[Vander18]

Yep. Put a line through that, certainly in the top 15.

It's not just being thin. Danier, McKay and the Kings do not have powerhouse builds but the proportions are there.

It's proportions that don't looking like they can hold weight.

Skinny seems Ok when coupled with broad, square shoulders….it’s the size of the frame I think.

Gumby was the same - looked wider at the hips than across the shoulders.

 

[Vander18]

Just shows how much a freak Fletcher was.

He was broader than Cox or Reid…but take you’re point. Did Fletch avoid weights? Kept his speed forever.

I often think guys like Cox are better off staying skinny and focusing on maximising their strengths- I.e. running. There will be a degree to which some size and strength follows naturally….just let that happen.

 

[BrunoV]

He was broader than Cox or Reid…but take you’re point. Did Fletch avoid weights? Kept his speed forever.

I often think guys like Cox are better off staying skinny and focusing on maximising their strengths- I.e. running. There will be a degree to which some size and strength follows naturally….just let that happen.

I reckon Fletch was quite broad in the shoulders. Similar shape to Joe.