- Nov 14, 2010
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
Unfortunately it's not an area of expertise for me. I'm sure he had plenty of physios/strength and conditioning coaches etc before being cleared. Really feel for him - was playing well when he got injured last year
He’s done the ACL once. The previous 2 were PCLs.As I am going through acl rehab myself, I asked my physio about recurrent ACL tears like EVW. He does some consulting for an AFL club here.
He just said that the data isn't there yet. Everybody's great strengthens at a different rate and no one will ever get ethics clearance to test the breaking point of a great at any given point in time. All we know is that it's not at full strength until 24 months after the reconstruction.
Plus there's always the higher risk of doing your other ACL due to movement patterns that become a new normal during recovery.
With regard to EVW, he believes that all they can do is reconstruct and then take a more conservative approach with return dates. He needs to pump some weights on the legs and hit some yoga.
Someone already corrected, but the point still stands. Both ligaments responsible for knee stability in different directions.Correct me if I am wrong, but I don’t believe EVW has had recurrent ACL injuries.
Had a long term PCL and then ACL in round 1 2019.
Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
And yet they still use an autograft from which the data we have about their healing rate is insufficient. I don't think it's a huge stretch to say that the former PCL probably contributed to the ACL going pop. Doesn't mean our staff are doing a bad job, but these things happen and we just need to persist.PCL’s are totally different, they are 95% of the time an impact injury rather than a twist injury
He’s was getting in his gym work on the Saturday morning open day last week.Forgotten man.
Seen Ed on a couple of NMFC vids at Thommo's retirement and with the kids doing a anti-gambling advertising speel and he looks good.
With Thommo retired becomes very important to us and reckon he will come up with the goods in 2020. Small glimpses have shown how good he can be.
One positive going forward.
I have done both ACL once pcl twice both twisting injuries. The second PCL was as simply as going for a mark and landing awkwardly. But like you say the general rule with a PCL is impact.PCL’s are totally different, they are 95% of the time an impact injury rather than a twist injury