Reading this thread over, how many people have actually seen Wade keep?
He is the only specialist keeper in the country that is worse than Brad Haddin, so there is absolutely no way you would replace Haddin with Wade.
Haddin & Wade are 2 peas in a pod, very average keepers who are quality aggressive strokemakers with the bat. Wade has nowhere near the experience & nous behind him that Haddin does, so replacing Haddin with 'Haddin Lite' would be a very strange thing to do.
Yes, Haddin has got out to some questionable shots recently. Most people vividly remember his shot when we were al out for 47, but its important to note that we were ALL OUT FOR 47, there were 6 batsmen before him that did no better, whether they got out attacking, or defending.
Brad Haddin is a much better batsman when he plays his natural game. Counter attacking when he comes to the wicket at 5-50 or putting on the cream when he comes in at 5-400. Either way, he's likely to get out playing an expansive drive. He's also likely to hit 30+ off about 50 balls.
He averages 35 in test cricket, which is up there in all-time averages for specialist keepers. Gilchrist was an exception, not the norm.
People remember the times when Haddin gets out aiming a drive at a wide one, but forget his match winning 50 in South Australia, or his counter attacking 100's in the opening test matches of the last 2 Ashes series, or his 50's in the 2nd, 3rd and 4th Ashes tests last year when he came to the wicket with us at 5 for ****all.
I would argue that someone like Michael Clarke, who is rightfully the toast of Australian Cricket at the moment, as got out to irresponsible shots in tight situations far more often than Brad Haddin.
People really do have short memories.
Tim Paine is the long term answer, and in the meantime if they do want an improved keeper at the expense of batting prowess, they should go with Chris Hartley, who is clearly the best gloveman in the country and will be adequate with the bat. He also has a knack of scoring most of his runs when arriving at the crease at 5-for **** all, which should help!