Player Watch #40: Will 'Mingma' Snelling - Will debut against Adelaide - 18/7

(Log in to remove this ad.)

BrunoV

Brownlow Medallist
May 5, 2009
15,438
18,966
AFL Club
Essendon
He was okay.

If he was some previously un-sighted VFL player I doubt his performance would be getting more than the plaudits that someone like McKenna would have gotten in the last few weeks when he has been effective or Dixon, I think it was, who was good today.

I thought he was pretty scrappy in close, certainly nothing special. Windy Hill is not a venue that has any real outside component of a game (give its overall size) so we didn't really get the chance to see any of the speed he is renowned for.

Doesn't mean anything after 1 game, of course, but given that the post above me is saying to bring him in for an AFL match, I thought some perspective would be in order.

First impression is that if his speed is what I understand it to be, a Richmond style small utility who is hammering the secondary contested ball (whether it's from a wing or half forward) is the sort of player I see him as.

Would want to see something elite about his inside game before thinking he'll be playing AFL midfield any time soon. It's important to remember that there are "stats" and then there are "stats".

Zac Clarke looked like the reincarnation of Jesus Christ on paper playing WAFL last year.
 
Last edited:

Duckworth

Peptide Awareness
Oct 8, 2006
7,174
5,602
Melbourne
AFL Club
Essendon
He was okay.

If he was some previously un-sighted VFL player I doubt his performance would be getting more than the plaudits that someone like McKenna would have gotten in the last few weeks when he has been effective or Dixon, I think it was, who was good today.

I thought he was pretty scrappy in close, certainly nothing special. Windy Hill is not a venue that has any really outside component of a game (give its overall size) so we didn't really get the chance to see any of the speed he is renowned for.

Doesn't mean anything after 1 game, of course, but given that the post above me is saying to bring him in for an AFL match, I thought some perspective would be in order.

First impression is that if his speed is what I understand it to be, a Richmond style small utility who is hammering the secondary contested ball (whether it's from a wing or half forward) is the sort of player I see him as.

Would want to see something elite about his inside game before thinking he'll be playing AFL midfield any time soon. It's important to remember that there are "stats" and then there are "stats".

Zac Clarke looked like the reincarnation of Jesus Christ on paper playing WAFL last year.
Baguley's VFL craft was less impressive.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Jaxes

Club Legend
Jun 14, 2012
1,412
1,079
AFL Club
Essendon
i highly doubt anyone at the club would think he would be playing afl the week after his vfl debut in a brand new (to him) side. they will make sure he gets to know the system first and backs up multiple good vfl performances
 

Cold Sober

Premiership Player
Suspended
Sep 28, 2016
3,228
3,312
AFL Club
Essendon
Other Teams
Man U .White Sox;Storm,Victory
It takes years for Woosha to give young blokes a go, so unless Mingma is related to Baggers he should wait in line. Me, I'd play him.
Why walk into a bottle shop, purchase a can of beer then put it in the boot.
 

Rebellya

Premium Platinum
Oct 17, 2012
1,413
3,465
AFL Club
Essendon
It takes years for Woosha to give young blokes a go, so unless Mingma is related to Baggers he should wait in line. Me, I'd play him.
Why walk into a bottle shop, purchase a can of beer then put it in the boot.
I don’t think I’ve ever heard a coach talk more about ‘getting to know each other, and learning to trust each other blah blah blah” than Worsfold. I’d say that he will want his beer put in the fridge till it’s icy cold, no way he’s serving warm beer.
 

MiguelM

Club Legend
Feb 22, 2014
1,428
1,171
AFL Club
Essendon
It takes years for Woosha to give young blokes a go, so unless Mingma is related to Baggers he should wait in line. Me, I'd play him.
Why walk into a bottle shop, purchase a can of beer then put it in the boot.
Totally different scenario to a young player IMO. Mingma has come from the AFL system already (Port Adelaide) and had senior exposure. He was specifically brought in to replace Smith, exactly what the mid season draft was for. Recruiters/selectors must believe he is ready on SANFL form, they would have done their research.

Expect he will get a call up soon. Long term, maybe worth a spot on list if Smith's issues are not resolved.

Yep, I am with you, drink the beer!
 
Top Bottom