Player Watch #41: Mabior Chol [ROOKIE]

Remove this Banner Ad

Phar Ace

Premium Platinum
Feb 9, 2017
4,650
9,895
Sunshine Coast
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Brisbane Bullets, Firebirds
Here is one for the statistic haters!

Had to have a chuckle at this - Chol led the table for DT Breakeven this week. Effectively he had to give away 10 free kicks AND not get a touch to NOT reach his break even, and yet was still only 98% chance to exceed his break even. Someone must have seen him a a huge free kick risk :D

PlayerTeamPriceGAvgBreakevenLikelihood %
M. Chol FOR​
$245,000​
2​
81​
-29​
98%​
 

Willo_23

Debutant
Apr 15, 2019
52
273
AFL Club
Richmond
Talk about getting something out of nothing! Admittedly I probably didn't know enough about him or his progress in the VFL over the past few seasons, but at the start of this year I probably had him pencilled in as someone who probably wasn't going to be on the list next year.

So what happens next year? Will he be someone who ends up being traded just due to there not being a definite spot for him when we're all healthy? Or can he legitimately be a part of our best 22 even while Nank, Lynch, Riewoldt etc. are all playing?
 

Marcel Proust

"Oohh WADA ooga booga" {Jul 11 2013}
Sep 6, 2018
8,640
14,626
#BigBigSound
AFL Club
Richmond
Talk about getting something out of nothing! Admittedly I probably didn't know enough about him or his progress in the VFL over the past few seasons, but at the start of this year I probably had him pencilled in as someone who probably wasn't going to be on the list next year.

So what happens next year? Will he be someone who ends up being traded just due to there not being a definite spot for him when we're all healthy? Or can he legitimately be a part of our best 22 even while Nank, Lynch, Riewoldt etc. are all playing?
Must keep him...

He loves Tigerland, too
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Listclogger

March Champion
Feb 11, 2016
981
2,301
AFL Club
Richmond
So what happens next year? Will he be someone who ends up being traded just due to there not being a definite spot for him when we're all healthy? Or can he legitimately be a part of our best 22 even while Nank, Lynch, Riewoldt etc. are all playing?
Yes I think so - his mobility is an asset and Nank needs a chop out that’s better than a Grigg/Caddy type.

My only question is can we play those 3 + Chol + Balta?
 

Mister M

Premiership Player
Oct 16, 2016
3,631
4,001
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Furies
Yes I think so - his mobility is an asset and Nank needs a chop out that’s better than a Grigg/Caddy type.

My only question is can we play those 3 + Chol + Balta?
I think that Chol/Balta currently play the same "role" within the side as the Tall Utility. For most of the game we can only really afford to have two key forwards (Lynch & Riewoldt) and the Ruck (Nank), but Chol/Balta can play a range of roles in the side for parts of games (resting ruckman, tall wingman, midfielder for a really short stint, forward while lynch/Riewoldt is on the bench, etc.)

I think despite as well as Chol has played the past two weeks, the position still belongs to Noah Balta in the medium-term.
 

Mr Magic

Brownlow Medallist
Mar 1, 2010
17,605
9,725
AFL Club
Richmond
I thought Chol had another reasonable game on the weekend, especially in the ruck.

What was interesting was when he took the mark and kicked the goal that he started initially away from Lynch contest and used his mobility and reach to win the ball.

JR made an interesting comment about giving Lynch space and trying to work together in the forward line not getting in each others way.

I think at times Chol was positioned a little too deep and too close to goal. I think once Prestia kicked it to Chol with a couple of Gold Coast players near the point side of the goals that was not really a effective option.

When JR comes in he can complement Lynch because of his ground ball ability and agility. I would like Chol to position himself out a little bit on the fat side of attack as an off centre option and alternatively a little further up the ground as a link option on the fat side flank where he can utilise his speed, mobility and reach more effectively in space!!

If McIntosh drifts away from the wing as a glove following Whitfield Chol can position himself on the flank side as a marking option for the midfield in transition and drift into the forward line when warranted or backline for that matter
 
Last edited:

Phar Ace

Premium Platinum
Feb 9, 2017
4,650
9,895
Sunshine Coast
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Brisbane Bullets, Firebirds
I thought Chol had another reasonable game on the weekend, especially in the ruck.

What was interesting was when he took the mark and kicked the goal that he started initially away from Lynch contest and used his mobility and reach to win the ball.

JR made an interesting comment about giving Lynch space and trying to work together in the forward line not getting in each others way.

I think at times Chol was positioned a little too deep and too close to goal. I think once Prestia kicked it to Chop with a couple of Gold Coast players near the point side of the goals that was not really a effective option.

When JR comes in he can complement Lynch because of his ground ball ability and agility. I would like Chol to position himself out a little bit on the fat side of attack as an off centre option and alternatively a little furze up the ground as a link option on the flanks where he can utilise his speed, mobility and reach more effectively in space!!
Like you I thought Chol was more than handy on the weekend, and actually think he will be hard to leave out again while he plays like that. He has really surprised me. I always knew he was a lovely kick, but always saw his footy smarts as holding him back positioning wise. That old Dyerism, he's always where the ball ain't. That has happened much less so in the past two weeks, and he's looked very handy. Playing in the ruck he has looked quite good at times, beaten soundly at times as well, but second game up you have to expect that.
 

living_in_syd

Premiership Player
May 2, 2009
3,524
5,010
sydney
AFL Club
Richmond
Like you I thought Chol was more than handy on the weekend, and actually think he will be hard to leave out again while he plays like that. He has really surprised me. I always knew he was a lovely kick, but always saw his footy smarts as holding him back positioning wise. That old Dyerism, he's always where the ball ain't. That has happened much less so in the past two weeks, and he's looked very handy. Playing in the ruck he has looked quite good at times, beaten soundly at times as well, but second game up you have to expect that.
I thought he a lot better soldo. He follows up whereas soldo just stands there...
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Mr Unbelievable

Club Legend
Nov 27, 2014
2,522
6,295
Melbourne
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Arsenal
Yes I think so - his mobility is an asset and Nank needs a chop out that’s better than a Grigg/Caddy type.

My only question is can we play those 3 + Chol + Balta?
Yes, in my opinion.... we must. It will give us soo much flexibility and the opposition might need to start planning for it as well.
Even if Balta is in defense .... just do it because I want to see how it works
 

amcre

Norm Smith Medallist
Aug 8, 2009
8,717
7,913
AFL Club
Richmond
Id say Caddy will replace Chol, and Nank obviously replaces Soldo.
Agree the Soldo for Nank is obvious.

I more meant how long we keep playing two rucks plus Jack/Lynch.

However I would say right now he is much more valuable than Caddy.
 

Top Bottom