Exactly its all supposition so I don't get why we are surmising that he will leave. I cant see any situation where he decides to take the cash elsewhere, he doesn't appear to be the type. He isn't going to go home like Conca, which is why he chose to take a contract for freo. I wouldn't also say it was big bucks either. Imo we have tried to get a good backline together, we have finally done it, and now we want to split it up? I understand part of this is seeing where Garth fits but you don't get rid of a player like Astbury for a player like Garth at this stage. If Astbury goes, your more than likely see Rance retire.Why would Freo offer him big bucks then and why did Conca walk into our finals after a serious injury?He would have played every week if it wasn’t for his injury early on. Astbury’s career was also injury hampered early on and he doesn’t get up each week .
Every player on our list is integral to our present and our future performances.For example The Lids trade was crucial in us winning the 17 flag.
BD like could and should is personal opinion and speculation. For example Cotchin could leave as he once said he would retire if he won a flag. If you’re on the list then it’s best 22 and the last time I checked Rance was on it, but he’s not the topic of discussion here and not the point being made based on UFA as he’s in the top 25% earners at the club which makes him a FA .