- Joined
- Aug 26, 2004
- Posts
- 109,784
- Reaction score
- 223,110
- Location
- CHANEL BOUTIQUE!
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
"Goddess"

- Thread starter
- Staff
- #2
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

PLUS Your club board comp is now up!
BigFooty Tipping Notice Img
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Opening Round
The Golden Ticket - Official AFL on-seller of MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
"Goddess"

Still would have preferred a few other players over Cripps, watching Dumont slip to 30 was criminal.

That's 3 nominees in the last 25 weeks. 1 every 8 weeks is pretty good in an 18 team comp![]()
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
3 of our own have picked up the rising star nominations in the last 2 years... but the question in my mind is... how many times can he get nominated this year?Wait what, Carlton has developed one of there own kids![]()
I think it was more a case of "no assembly required". He pretty much came to the club with all the tools in hand, and hired his own running coach during the off season. It still does nothing for our credibility as player developers.Wait what, Carlton has developed one of there own kids![]()
3 of our own have picked up the rising star nominations in the last 2 years... but the question in my mind is... how many times can he get nominated this year?
What happens if he absolutely destroys the filth this week? Does he get another nod?
Anyone else notice the irony of this statement (in hindsight)![]()
Which is a great thing, because I wonder if this has perhaps been another weak area in our recruiting (mental strength/willpower).It was quite noticeable in the VFL last season that whenever it looked like Paddy was spent physically, he found a way to will himself through to the end of games. Mentally, I think he is one of the stronger players at the club. Heading towards Judd territory.
It was quite noticeable in the VFL last season that whenever it looked like Paddy was spent physically, he found a way to will himself through to the end of games. Mentally, I think he is one of the stronger players at the club. Heading towards Judd territory.
I said it in our podcast last night...I think the example that Cripps is setting (in hiring his own running coach etc) can only have a good influence on the rest of the team, regardless of their age. Soon enough the other lads won't want to be shown up by him, and they'll either move on or put in as much effort as he does.Absolutely right and even with a broken leg. Judd, Curnow and Cripps.
It's great to now see the likes of Graham, Walsh, DVR, Smith etc pushing themselves almost as hard.
We finally have some good young leaders but Cripps is right at the top of that tree.
I don't want to sound like the kind of poster to pump up one player by bagging out another, but I'd love it if Menzel could show the same work ethic and sheer dedication to teamwork as Crippa has already.
I'm not a fly on the wall so I don't actually know how Menz goes about his training and the like, but I get the impression at least on-field he could push himself harder to go with that ridiculous amount of talent.
We have him locked to 2017. And all the vision I see of him shows him to be a very happy young man with zero go home factor.I think it was more a case of "no assembly required". He pretty much came to the club with all the tools in hand, and hired his own running coach during the off season. It still does nothing for our credibility as player developers.
We need to lock him up long term ASAP. The bean counters need to work out what this kid is going to be worth in a few years and make sure they're willing to pony up. West Coast will undoubtedly make a massive play for him at some point. Try to take him home and pair him up with his cousin.
Menzel is a beautiful player and he doesn't have to be a Cripps, Judd or Curnow................not everyone can be.
I just get the feeling that Menzel does crave a little attention but he'll have to be the one who demands that attention and not expect others to help him along. Team first attitude must be in place and maybe it already is. Let's see from here on in.
Menzel has to improve his work rate and influence the game a lot more than he currently does.
Jesus I nearly got lynched for saying the same thing a few weeks ago.

Of course I did, the ones who pave the way are always the ones who attract criticismYeah, but you deserved it.........................
Would like to see the tall forwards get out of the way and leave Menzel at FF, 1 on 1


2017 is not long term. If we can extend his contract for another couple of years early on, we won't have to pay as much (at the moment he isn't attracting the kind of attention that Boyd did, or that Howe is now getting), but at some point he is going to be a very expensive player.We have him locked to 2017. And all the vision I see of him shows him to be a very happy young man with zero go home factor.