A phantom based on needs

[Asgardian]

Well these are my guesses anyway for the PSD and 1st 2 rounds of the Rookie Draft

Pre-Season Draft

1/- Melbourne - Casey Sibosado (Tall Defender)
2/- Port - Josh Carr (midfielder)
3/- Essendon - Hayden Skipworth (Midfielder)
4/- Carlton - Chris Johnson (Medium Defender)
5/- Brisbane - Michael Rix (Ruckman)
6/- Richmond - Kade Klemke (Medium Defender)


Rookie Draft

1/- Melbourne - Andrew Browne (Ruckman)
2/- West Coast - Ian Richardson (Small Forward)
3/- Fremantle - Adam Cockie (Midfielder)
4/- Port Adelaide - Michael Gugliotta (Tall Defender)
5/- Essendon - Robin Nahas (Small Forward)
6/- Carlton - Hamish Shepheard (Tall Forward)
7/- Brisbane - Tom Allwright (Midfielder)
8/- Richmond - Matthew Deboer (Midfielder)
9/- North Melbourne - Riley Milne (Tall Defender)
10/- Adelaide - Cory Dellilio (Small Forward)
11/- Collingwood - Zach Stengstock (Tall Defender)
12/- Sydney - Charlie Sharples (Small Forward)
13/- St Kilda - Bryce Carroll (Medium Forward)
14/- Bulldogs - Tom Rockliff (Medium Forward)
15/- Geelong - Andrew Duhau (Midfielder)
16/- Hawthorn - Taylor Gilchrist (Medium Defender)
17/- Melbourne - David Gourdis (Tall Forward)
18/- West Coast - Tom German (Midfielder)
19/- Fremantle - Adam Varcoe (Medium Forward)
20/- Port Adelaide - Matthew Martin (Tall Defender)
21/- Essendon - Ben Birthisel (Tall Defender)
22/- Carlton - Zac Dawson (Tall Defender)
23/- Brisbane - Xavier Gotch (Midfielder)
24/- Richmond - Jamie Sheahan (Midfielder)
25/- North Melbourne - Zach Ledin (Midfielder)
26/- Adelaide - Brayden O'Hara (Utility)
27/- Collingwood - Clancee Pearce (Medium Defender)
28/- Sydney - Steven Gaertner (Tall Defender)
29/- St Kilda - Kane Goodwin (Midfielder)
30/- Bulldogs - Tom Simpkin (Tall Defender)
31/- Geelong - Bryn Weadon (Medium Defender)
32/- Hawthorn - Callan Bond (Medium Forward)

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Remind me again why Essendon with Lovett, Davey, Monfries, Jetta..and according to our "needs" we draft another small forward!

 

[beatlesmith]

if we pass on clancee pearce and get a mid, i will shoot someone.
We need Small, negating defenders more than mids, we just drafted 3 mids and naita, who gets a shiteload of clearances.

 

[Jumbo]

Rix? I doubt they would pick up a 28 yr old ruckmen who's done very little. They still have Leuy & Charmers plus didn't the pick up a ruck in the ND. Redden?

Brissy picked up Jack REDDEN who is 188cm mid/forward. Port got Jarred REDDEN (ruck).

 

[Bonuspoints]

I'm pretty sure Voss has even said they are looking at Rix as a ready to go back up.

 

[raffrox]

I'm pretty sure that the word is that Richmond have penciled in Gourdis with their PSD pick.

 

[whelan=legend]

The last thing Melbourne needs is another tall defender. But Sibosado is a tall forward anyway so you seem a little confused.

 

[Asgardian]

The last thing Melbourne needs is another tall defender. But Sibosado is a tall forward anyway so you seem a little confused.

According to Matt Burgan he's a tall defender, read the following

44 – ADELAIDE – CASEY SIBOSADO
Northern Territory Thunder, NT, Tall defender, October 13, 1990, 192.9cm, 84.7kg
(Draft range: 28-not selected)

Some talent identifiers believe Sibosado is a top 25 selection and others believe he will be chosen as a rookie. Still, expect him to find a home in this draft, particularly with Adelaide believed to be red hot at their picks No.28, No.44 or No.60. Fremantle will also be in the mix and don't be surprised if Port Adelaide snaffles him at No.54 if Adelaide passes. Keep a watch on Hannebery, Wright, Motlop, Jack Redden, Shiels, Bucovaz, Gugliotta, Nathan O'Keefe and Chris Hall for the Crows.

So perhaps if you knew a fact from crap someone could take your comments seriously

 

[whelan=legend]

So perhaps if you knew a fact from crap someone could take your comments seriously

So because Matt Burgan said it it's true? Anyway even if it is the LAST thing Melbourne needs is a tall defender, so thanks for trying.

 

[Bombers1234]

So because Matt Burgan said it it's true? Anyway even if it is the LAST thing Melbourne needs is a tall defender, so thanks for trying.

Well I know who i'd rather trust out of Burgan and you.

 

[DemonErrol1964 - dees]

Bomber's that's a bit below the belt mate.

I'd trust Wheel's judgement before Burgen.

 

[Silvagnis]

Why does Carlton need a muppet like Dawson in the second round?

I guess it's because we don't have any young defenders.

This cliche is still being wheeled out for the Blues in phantom drafts.

Dawson won't develop into anything or force his way into our team ahead of Bower, Jamison Waite, Thornton, Setanta and Austin.

The Hawks need defenders and have cut him.

I haven't seen him play, yet I'd be happy if we picked up the untried Alex Silvagni somewhere.

 

[IbbosBFF]

mate Fremantle need talls and backmen in the rookie draft.

Ill spit chips if we recruited a medium forward @ 19 when Pearce(my love child), Gaertner and Gourdis were available

 

[Palmervich]

Clancy Pierce wont fall to the second round, and if he does, he wont get past West Coast or the Dockers twice.

 

[Atavistic]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/default.aspx?newsid=70100
Casey Sibosado
Date of birth: 13/10/90
Height: 192cm
Weight: 85kg
Club: Northern Territory Thunder
Bio: An athletic and versatile tall forward who's strong overhead, Sibosado represented Northern Territory in the NAB AFL Under-18 Championships.

 

[whelan=legend]

Whelan=Legend wins!

 

[Asgardian]

Okay,

How's this sound?

I reckon he's a tall defender who can also play as a tall forward, you reckon he's a tall forward who can also play as a tall defender

We're both correct, okay?

 

[Asgardian]

Well these are my guesses anyway for the PSD and 1st 2 rounds of the Rookie Draft

Pre-Season Draft

1/- Melbourne - Casey Sibosado (Tall Defender)
2/- Port - Josh Carr (midfielder)
3/- Essendon - Hayden Skipworth (Midfielder)
4/- Carlton - Chris Johnson (Medium Defender)
5/- Brisbane - Michael Rix (Ruckman)
6/- Richmond - Kade Klemke (Medium Defender)


Rookie Draft

1/- Melbourne - Andrew Browne (Ruckman)
2/- West Coast - Ian Richardson (Small Forward)
3/- Fremantle - Adam Cockie (Midfielder)
4/- Port Adelaide - Michael Gugliotta (Tall Defender)
5/- Essendon - Robin Nahas (Small Forward)
6/- Carlton - Hamish Shepheard (Tall Forward)
7/- Brisbane - Tom Allwright (Midfielder)
8/- Richmond - Matthew Deboer (Midfielder)
9/- North Melbourne - Riley Milne (Tall Defender)
10/- Adelaide - Cory Dellilio (Small Forward)
11/- Collingwood - Zach Stengstock (Tall Defender)
12/- Sydney - Charlie Sharples (Small Forward)
13/- St Kilda - Bryce Carroll (Medium Forward)
14/- Bulldogs - Tom Rockliff (Medium Forward)
15/- Geelong - Andrew Duhau (Midfielder)
16/- Hawthorn - Taylor Gilchrist (Medium Defender)
17/- Melbourne - David Gourdis (Tall Forward)
18/- West Coast - Tom German (Midfielder)
19/- Fremantle - Adam Varcoe (Medium Forward)
20/- Port Adelaide - Matthew Martin (Tall Defender)
21/- Essendon - Ben Birthisel (Tall Defender)
22/- Carlton - Zac Dawson (Tall Defender)
23/- Brisbane - Xavier Gotch (Midfielder)
24/- Richmond - Jamie Sheahan (Midfielder)
25/- North Melbourne - Zach Ledin (Midfielder)
26/- Adelaide - Brayden O'Hara (Utility)
27/- Collingwood - Clancee Pearce (Medium Defender)
28/- Sydney - Steven Gaertner (Tall Defender)
29/- St Kilda - Kane Goodwin (Midfielder)
30/- Bulldogs - Tom Simpkin (Tall Defender)
31/- Geelong - Bryn Weadon (Medium Defender)
32/- Hawthorn - Callan Bond (Medium Forward)

Oh well, not a great effort by me