i'm with you to a degree Mario, in that we should never overrate our list. I'm always on the more pessimistic side, let's be honest, we're still 16th on the ladder. And our skills are sporadic, inconsistent and developing at best.
But, I'll also always go into bat for a ball getter / rock. Joe Misiti, Brett Kirk, Cameron Ling, Lenny Hayes, Sam Mitchell, Gary Hocking, Greg Williams, Dale Weightman, whoever. A team can look as sharp as they like, but you still need to get the thing, and get it going forward. Tucky would definitely get a game in my side, and who knows, would prob get seriously looked at for a start in my side if I coached Geelong. Only Lids and Jack could say the same at this point in time.
Loving the look of kids, but they need looking after.
Many players in the league could learn from Tucky.