A. Rocca or Richo

[Partridge]

Richo has won the club's goal kicking 11 times!!

Rocca's good but Matty Richardson is a freak athlete who covers 18km a game and is statistically the best contested mark since Wayne Carey.

I think Richo is not only the most underrated player ever, but easily the most unjustly criticised. For most of his career he has played in a crap side, yet he still performs. Year after year after year. But for reasons I'll never understand he cops vitriol from the media and ignorant supporters like no one I've ever seen.

Great, great player.

 

[Heisenberg_]

Anthony is close to Sav tho, that is the point

No he isn't, Richo and Sav are about the same, and Anthony isn't in the same league as them

 

[Will.B.Worth.Da.Waite]

Didn't comment!



Kept two of the games stars (Judd and Black) to under 17 touches last year. Useful?



So?

I think you are a bit out of your depth here, little boy. Go home and play with mum

lol u commented on the fact that because carlton won the last 2 wooden spoons, we were in no position to comment on richmond.

lol how bout all the stats for all the shthouse games hes had where he's done nothing. ud think that even he could have a few good games

So, whats ur point about jarrad waite? u commented on waite's ability and his performance in ur DT, i did the same thing about a richmond player.

lol n the fact that uve resorted to insulting me n the only intelligent thing in ur last post was about judd n black, suggesting that its u perhaps u whose outta their depth???

 

[Upgrayedd]

I may be biased but I' take Rocca over Richo any day of the week

obviously you are
rocca is exactly like richo, chucks a fit when he doesnt get it his way, difference is that richo also kicks goals

 

[OneEyedHawk]

I think Richo is not only the most underrated player ever, but easily the most unjustly criticised. For most of his career he has played in a crap side, yet he still performs. Year after year after year. But for reasons I'll never understand he cops vitriol from the media and ignorant supporters like no one I've ever seen.

Great, great player.

I'd agree with all of that.

Richo- better than Sav, miles better than Anthony.

 

[thegrach]

Will.B.Worth.Da.Waite;7200305]lol u commented on the fact that because carlton won the last 2 wooden spoons, we were in no position to comment on richmond.

Thats right.

ol how bout all the stats for all the shthouse games hes had where he's done nothing. ud think that even he could have a few good games

The question was name one good thing he has done. Question answered

So, whats ur point about jarrad waite? u commented on waite's ability and his performance in ur DT, i did the same thing about a richmond player.

Do you know what your screen name says?

lol n the fact that uve resorted to insulting me n the only intelligent thing in ur last post was about judd n black, suggesting that its u perhaps u whose outta their depth???

That actually makes no sense. Try grammar and punctuation, champ. I'm done trying to reason with neanderthals!

 

[Kaiser Powser]

Richo by an absolute country mile.

How can you compare the two?

Richo is a champ, Rocca is a workhorse forward.

A fairer comparison would be Rocca vs Lynch. Both slow but with a good grab and big kick. Neither kick a lot of goals dispite being the number 1 forward at their teams.

 

[doppleganger]

No he isn't, Richo and Sav are about the same, and Anthony isn't in the same league as them

some Collingwood people would argue that A.Rocca is the better player than Sav

Richo is a gun, id take him over both of em anyway

 

[UpTheGuts]

Richo's just super. I've seen the best and worst of that bloke and reckon he's a champ.

Sad, sad, sad day when he says goodbye. Really like no other in his era

 

[Colonel Matrix]

I'm a biased Richo fan, I'll admit it, I've got to thank all the posters on this thread who've given him some kudos, it warms my heart.

It annoys me that people forget he's one of the last true contested marking players in the game...

 

[doppleganger]

Rocca stepped up and won the game for the woods

Richo wasted his chance

 

[lids2004roar]

3QTR time.

Rocca gets a kick from 10 metres out.

Siren goes.

The scores are level.


HE KICKS IT ON THE FULL.

Don't get too carried away, Richo should have kicked 7 but had his annual shit game where he misses everything. He'll be back next week while Rocca will continue to not even show up for half a game.

 

[doppleganger]

3QTR time.

Rocca gets a kick from 10 metres out.

Siren goes.

The scores are level.


HE KICKS IT ON THE FULL.

Don't get too carried away, Richo should have kicked 7 but had his annual shit game where he misses everything. He'll be back next week while Rocca will continue to not even show up for half a game.

who stood up when the game was there to be won......A.Rocca

who pissed multiple oppoertunities down the drain.....Richo Richo Man

poor tuggers

 

[TigerGlory]

who stood up when the game was there to be won......A.Rocca

who pissed multiple oppoertunities down the drain.....Richo Richo Man

poor tuggers

81% of voters really couldnt care less.

 

[dtm06]

D. Shwartz says Richo coz he would be the first player in his team any day

 

[lihei]

Don't get too carried away, Richo should have kicked 7 but had his annual shit game where he misses everything.

I thought annual meant once a year, not once a month

 

[Magpie Mick]

As long as Richo is the go to man in the Tigers forward line they will continue to be a team going nowhere FAST!

 

[Will.B.Worth.Da.Waite]

Thats right.

The question was name one good thing he has done. Question answered

Do you know what your screen name says?

That actually makes no sense. Try grammar and punctuation, champ. I'm done trying to reason with neanderthals!

lol so u agree u commented then? because ur last post said tha u "didn't comment" man wtf are u on. u dun even kno wot ur sayin anymore do u?

lol ur so lost its funny. go back to my last post. i neva asked for one good thign he has done. i asked how often does he do somethign useful. my god u are a dumb sht

btw how did richmond go on the weekend? richo had another good game didnt he i drove back to sydney today, went to the carlton v bombers game. man fev was good. must suck having richo as ur most important forward. shows how good tigers are going this year

 

[DrWho]

GO PIES

Rocca over Richo anyday

 

[Thrawn]

Richooooooooooooooo!

 

[Merv]

Richo by a country mile.

Rocca has a heart the size of a pea.He is a front runner that refuses to dig deep when it's needed

Richo might makes mistakes and have brain fades but he tries his guts out for a team that has struggled for most of his career.

IF Rocca had half of Richo's endeaver, he would be a champion

 

[Deledio2Conca]

Is this the most definitive poll ever?

Wow Rocca played his one good game out of every 5. Rocca is terribly inconsistent.

 

[Ron]

Richo by a country mile.

Rocca has a heart the size of a pea.He is a front runner that refuses to dig deep when it's needed

Umm did you even watch the game last weekend? When the game was there to be won, Rocca stepped up and won it. Richo choked when the pressure was on.

Richo is no doubt a better player but your comments are typical of a bomber supporter, no idea as usual.

 

[Bulldog1954]

Absolutely ridiculous poll. Rocca isn't in Richos league, amazing that anyone can say otherwise

 

[Ando_4]

Richo's almost 5x better according to this poll.

Is that all?