Aaron Naughton or Oscar Allen

[Loz89]

Is that what an Eagles supporters life is like atm? Lurking old threads to make the season relevant. Nobody would take Allen over naughton cause he's missed years of football. Naughton is durable and a game changer. Allen has played 8 games of decent footy in 2.5 years.

To be honest, yeah, it has been that bad. Its subjective, but with all things considered I think Allen is a better player and prospect.

 

[St 07]

Is this poll serious

 

[TheUnicorn]

Is this poll serious

IKR! How is Oscar Allen losing when he’s clearly the better player! Imagine if he wasn’t in the worst team in the comp, would probably be the Coleman medalist.

 

[Foxman98]

IKR! How is Oscar Allen losing when he’s clearly the better player! Imagine if he wasn’t in the worst team in the comp, would probably be the Coleman medalist.

Harry McKay won a coleman in a team that came 13th and only won 2 games more than 17th.

 

[TheUnicorn]

Harry McKay won a coleman in a team that came 13th and only won 2 games more than 17th.

Ok?

 

[BloodRet]

I mean it’s not even a discussion. Allen far superior

 

[My Tilly]

Imagine swapping Naughton for Allen.
Do you realistically believe Allen is managing just 1.1 last night against Geelong?

 

[Danger in Texas]

Allen out of these two for mine. Naughton’s marking and around the ground is first class of course, but Allen just looks like such an all round dangerous player

Tell you what though, if the Dogs put Naughton back, I reckon he’d be an all-timer KPD. Doubt they will, though

Yeah I’m still taking Allen

 

[TheEscapeClub]

Noone would take Allen over naughton. Naughtons air presence and pressure on the ground is elite for a kpf too

I would at Geelong. A lot of Geelong supporters were keen on him as part of the Kelly trade.