We have you Langdon for a steal though
Traded Adam Cerra traded to Carlton for pick #6 and F3
- Thread starter Lore
- Start date
- Tagged users None
hawkman
Hall of Famer
If we did finish last i would be just offering a take it or leave it offer 20 and Collingwoods 2nd pick. Could maybe add a future 2nd. No way would a 1st rounder be involved due to the risk of missing out of another top 4 pick next year.
If they don't want it, take him in the preseason draft. Freo won't like it but we aren't going to be offering a 1st that we own
If they don't want it, take him in the preseason draft. Freo won't like it but we aren't going to be offering a 1st that we own
Get ready to be reemed by future clubs if you dont wanna trade fair then haha
I’d agree if he was a free agent, but he isn’t. Everyone would love a great talent on a free but it just doesn’t happen.
hawkman
Hall of Famer
We have been reemed for years. About time we fight back
I actually think you guys have done quite well. Mitchell for what pick 13 odd? Good buy that
We have always traded fair and one thing under Graeme Wright was we'd always try get deals done with a club once the players nominated us, with Wright leaving will be interesting to see how we trade going forward.
We definitely aren't in a position to trade our current or future first, so don't think you'd get the best deal trading with hawthorn as others have said our two 2nds is most I'd personally offer given our situation.
We certainly paid overs for both Wingard & O'Meara.
If you guys had pick 2 and traded it for Cerra. Would you call it a loss?
- Oct 11, 2012
- 3,952
- 6,116
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
and everyone at the time, except Hawthorn, thought you were overpaying for those two!
Yeah I'd say so. Besides Horne & Callaghan you can make an arguement that Cerra is more valuable then any other player in the current draft.
But given our situation I'd take the top two pick get either Horne or Callaghan on their rookie contract and hope they fulfill their potential.
- May 3, 2007
- 36,507
- 21,162
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Man City, Valencia, Lazio, Panthers
I dont think richmond has ended their era yet. Got injuries right now and can do damage next season in finals.
This bloke is so overrated and anyone thinking of paying him $750k/year needs to slap themselves.
He's worth about 2/3 that at the moment at best and if he wants to come to Richmond I certainly wouldn't be offering him anywhere near that.
He's worth about 2/3 that at the moment at best and if he wants to come to Richmond I certainly wouldn't be offering him anywhere near that.
That values Cerra higher than Kelly. Do you really think he's worth more?
Kelly was traded for the equivalent of Pick 2, but West Coast essentially paid more (on a points base) due to the actual picks they traded as they couldn't get a pick in the top 10, so they needed to pay more.
In terms of pick value it will be somewhere around Pick 6-10. I still think the value will be somewhere around the Prestia trade (Pick 6 offset by an upgrade of a later pick - so somewhere value wise around Pick 9)
Snuffaluphagus
Moderator
- Sep 10, 2015
- 21,235
- 71,554
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Moderator
- #1,764
I dont know about overrated given his game on the weekend showed what you might get consistently in a couple of years but I agree he's not worth 750k. I'll actually be annoyed if we sign him up for that because he hasnt earnt it yet, especially if its a two year deal
- Aug 15, 2011
- 23,781
- 8,381
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Port Adelaide
The difference between Tim Kelly and Cerra is that Tim Kelly couldnt get to a WA club in any other way than a trade. PSD wasn't in question.
The bottom 3 sides currently are all victorian.
Its highly unlikely to come to PSD and i dont think it will.
But anything around pick 5-6 is very fair value
Kelly essentially went for pick 1-2 in the end
The bottom 3 sides currently are all victorian.
Its highly unlikely to come to PSD and i dont think it will.
But anything around pick 5-6 is very fair value
Kelly essentially went for pick 1-2 in the end
When you're bringing a young player over at his age you're also paying for the player you believe he'd become, his game on the weekend is definitely a 750k player.
Electronic_Renaissance
I ain't sayin' nothin'!
- Mar 25, 2021
- 5,522
- 14,149
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Las Vegas Bears, Perth Scorchers
He's a good player, could be a gun player but you never know. No way would I sign him at 750k, whether it's a two or four year deal.
He's only 21, he has plenty of time to prove himself. Then he can be paid the big bucks. Too many players of late have been signed up on mega deals and then started cruising, don't want to risk that.
Snuffaluphagus
Moderator
- Sep 10, 2015
- 21,235
- 71,554
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Moderator
- #1,769
Yeah, maybe I'm off because I think your paying a premium in draft picks but not money, maybe its because I dont care what clubs pay him if he leaves but want to get proper draft compensation.
For me, if he never improved on this year, you'd pay pick 6-10 and be happy you're going to get at least 200 games of very good football, something you'd pay 600k a year for.
Most likely he's going to improve per his game on the weekend so your going to have to sweeten pick 6-10 to get it done, so maybe you pay him 700k as well.
Remuneration is harder to prove on previous trades so its easy to guess what his draft cost will be then his pay
- Sep 25, 2013
- 14,979
- 29,140
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Fair comment. Fisher is great but getting 22 games out of him is another question.
- May 3, 2007
- 36,507
- 21,162
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Man City, Valencia, Lazio, Panthers
I do rate SPS, But I am not keen for freo to pay way over the odds for him. Averages 15 or 16 disposals game. Its sort of expected where he was played in is career.
Up forward, could be that 25-30 goals a season small forward pocket player freo needs.
Fisher.... You expect pick 15-25 for? Is he contracted?
As much as I want freo to get a top 5 pick, we wont get it. I mean freo wanted a lot for Brad Hill back in 2019. Peter Bell demanded a couple of 1st rounders for the saints including their pick 5 or 6. Turned out a decent deal in the end.
Freo is more likely going to trade Cerra and a future 3rd for like pick 10, a 4th rounder and a future 2nd.
I rather Cerra goes to the tigers. at least richmond has picks to trade. The have WA players besides shai bolton as well.
Its always gonna be a gamble but cerra is a proven player. Horne isnt although i must admit i havent watched draft vids
Morro
Brownlow Medallist
Was he playing on the wing on Heeney on the weekend?
Morro
Brownlow Medallist
Serious question for Freo fans, where does Cerra rank right now in your midfield group?
Fyfe
Mundy
Brayshaw
Serong
I would suggest he's your 5th best mid?
There isnt another club in the comp that would expect 2 x 1st rounders for their 5th best mid. Keep in mind, hes the 5th best mid in a middle of the table club.
Fyfe
Mundy
Brayshaw
Serong
I would suggest he's your 5th best mid?
There isnt another club in the comp that would expect 2 x 1st rounders for their 5th best mid. Keep in mind, hes the 5th best mid in a middle of the table club.
Maybe not overrated internally, but anyone wanting to pay him $750k or Shai Bolton north of $800k is definitely overrating both of them.
Currently they are B grade and play well every 2-3 weeks.
Similar threads
