Love the Drake
Club Legend
Got our man. Paid overs. Can’t win every deal.
Welcome Adam. Can’t wait to watch you play for Carlton next year.
Welcome Adam. Can’t wait to watch you play for Carlton next year.
NCL
0 v STM
0 PM
WAR
24.18
162 v PAL
5.6
36 FT
TIWI
7.9
51 v WAN
37.19
241 FT
SD
9.10
64 v DAR
11.10
76 FT
SA
103 v HOU
91 FT
SYD
1 v WSW
1 FT
SAC
100 v LAC
138 FT
POR
112 v ATL
106 FT
MIA
100 v DET
120 FT
LAL
112 v NO
95 FT
BUF
17 v BAL
3 FT
BRO
122 v ORL
115 FT
ADE
116 v SEM
108 FT
TOR
116 v CHA
113 FT
MIL
112 v DAL
109 FT
OKC
127 v CHI
125 FT
CLE
106 v NY
103 FT
CNS
87 v SYD
86 FT
UTH
116 v ATL
92 FT
MCY
2 v WUN
1 FT
MEM
106 v PHI
104 FT
NEW
1 v MAC
2 FT
BOS
124 v ORL
97 FT
News Adam Saad nominates Carlton
- Thread starter Aphrodite
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
The Old Dark Navy's
Moderator
Something doesn't mean a top 10 pick. Ugly deal for us. We mishandled this from the time he nominated us too early.
kingkingston
Premiership Player
Nah, we got it done. Kemp is our rookie for next season anyway
Disagree. Essendon needed this trade to happen to keep their trade period moving. They could also have lost him for nothing.
Eiffel 65
Premiership Player
- Sep 18, 2018
- 3,853
- 10,139
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Gryffindor
We'll probably end up trading it for Fogarty at the rate we're going.
Disappointing we bent. Dodo's strategy works well against Austin. Hopefully we don't have to trade with Adelaide as Reid might get his revenge.
Glad we got Saad but sad we can no longer expect our trade team to stand firm on a fair price.
Glad we got Saad but sad we can no longer expect our trade team to stand firm on a fair price.
Faz 2000
Norm Smith Medallist
My quick maths says this values Saad at about pick 12, which is a little more than the 15-20 I'd have thought he'd be.
Come round 1 next year, it really won't matter very much. Saad should be a fantastic addition to our side!
Not thrilled with how the Blues played it, though. 78 for 87 switcheroo is a circle-jerk at the end to make it seem like we got something when we really didn't.
Come round 1 next year, it really won't matter very much. Saad should be a fantastic addition to our side!
Not thrilled with how the Blues played it, though. 78 for 87 switcheroo is a circle-jerk at the end to make it seem like we got something when we really didn't.
BLUEALLTHRU
Brownlow Medallist
We need to take the bull by the horns and aim for a flag! We have done this. I'm happy we got our man and pick 8 who really cares! We now back in our development and have a real crack!
kingkingston
Premiership Player
Neither club was going to do that
We failed
CarltonFan
Club Legend
This reminds of the Touhy trade with Geelong. We were all very pleased to get a 1st round pick from Geelong at the time, but I think the winners of that trade were actually Geelong as Touhy has been a real consistent HB rebounding defender that has helped them play finals for years. I think Saad will be in the same boat, pick 8 is loss, but seeing what Saad does for our team week in week out will mean we wont care about what it cost all those years ago.
p*** weakWe failed
Lace_Out
Norm Smith Medallist
- Oct 1, 2014
- 5,037
- 9,271
- AFL Club
- Carlton
The way this years draft is with the amount of academy kids and players not playing any footy in Vic, the heartland of footy, pick 8 is not as valuable as other years.
We know what we have and it's ELITE and EXACTLY WHAT WE NEED.
I'm happy, as the old saying goes a bird in the bush...
Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk
We know what we have and it's ELITE and EXACTLY WHAT WE NEED.
I'm happy, as the old saying goes a bird in the bush...
Sent from my SM-G965F using Tapatalk
Aphrodite
Moderator
- Status
Similar threads
